Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Pellet Litter vs Clumping: Our 2025 Comparison, Pros & Cons

Pellet litter vs clumping

There are many great reasons to have a cat as a pet, but one important reason for many is that they are relatively low maintenance. One thing that cats do require, however, is a litter box. While some people believe that any type of litter will do, many different types of cat litter are available, and each has its advantages and disadvantages. Many feel litter is a necessary evil when it comes to owning a cat. But it’s important to choose the right type of litter for your and your cat’s needs.

Two of the most popular types of litter are pellet and clumping. But how do they compare? Here is a breakdown of the two types of litter to help you decide which is right for your cat.

divider cats oct 2024

Overview of Pellet Litter:

There are many types of pellet litter for cats on the market these days. Some are made of clay, others of corn or wheat. There is even a type made out of recycled paper. The important thing to remember when choosing a pellet litter for your cat is that it should be absorbent. Some brands also add odor control to their pellets.

Cat litter made from wood pellets is mostly made from pine because it naturally has a good scent. But other types of wood can be used as well. Using pine wood prevents using chemical scents to mask the smell. As pet owners become more eco-conscious, this cat litter has become more popular. Biodegradable and often made from recycled materials, this cat litter is made from natural raw materials. In addition to lasting longer, wood pellets are much less likely to need to be changed as often as clay litter.

cat litter box on a wooden floor
Image Credit By: Grzegorz Petrykowski, Shutterstock

How It Works

Because wood pellets are highly absorbent, they make an effective cat litter. Cat litter made from wood pellets absorbs urine in a similar manner to other types of litter. In the process of absorbing urine, the odor is also absorbed. Pellets become sawdust after absorbing urine. Fresh pellets are left on top after the sawdust sinks down into the litter pan. Be aware that the pellets don’t absorb solids, however. As a result, cat feces will accumulate on top of the pellets, but the pine scent of the litter may help to mask the smell.

How to Clean and Change It

It is recommended to scoop the wood pellet litter daily and to completely change it every 2 weeks. Scoop it daily by removing the solids with a scoop. After scooping out piles of sawdust, sift the scooper to prevent dry pellets from being discarded as well. After that, you can re-fill the box with dry pellets and top it off with fresh pellets. Litter boxes should be replaced every 2 weeks with fresh pellets, but if you scoop them every day, you might be able to get away with doing it less often.

It may be necessary to change the litter more frequently if you have more than one cat. A litter box with a built-in sifter tray makes litter-changing easier. This will filter the sawdust through the sifter. Simply remove the solids and empty the sawdust from the bottom tray.

The odors and stains of cats will probably still be present around the house even if you keep a clean litterbox. None of us want trying to be more eco-conscious to come at the cost of a pleasant-smelling home. This is where pet deodorizers and stain removers can make a huge difference.

Combating tough cat litter smells is an ongoing battle for pet parents but luckily, there are products out there designed to help! Two products that significantly reduce odors are the Hepper Litter Additive and the Hepper Enzyme Spray.

Image Product Details
Best Enzyme Cleaner Hepper Advanced Bio-Enzyme Pet Stain & Odor Eliminator Spray Hepper Advanced Bio-Enzyme Pet Stain & Odor Eliminator Spray
  • Works on multiple surfaces
  • Gentle yet effective
  • Lifts stains & set-in odors
  • Best Litter Additive Advanced Bio-Enzyme Cat Litter Deodorizer Advanced Bio-Enzyme Cat Litter Deodorizer
  • Neutralizes odor within cat litter
  • Cat-safe
  • Unscented
  • At Catster, we’ve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!

    How to Dispose of It

    It is important to dispose of litter carefully, as some types may pose environmental hazards. Due to their natural composition, wood pellets are biodegradable and compostable. Composting cat feces, however, should be done carefully, as it contains parasites that can cause human toxoplasmosis. Don’t compost wood pellet litter near vegetables or other edible plants. Keep a separate compost pile for it. Alternatively, flush it down the toilet in small amounts or throw it away if you don’t compost.

    Pros
    • Eco-friendly
    • Easily disposed of
    • Produces no dust
    • Chemical-free
    Cons
    • Cats won’t use it in some cases
    • Doesn’t clump
    • Cleaning is required more frequently
    • Can smell worse if not managed properly

    divider cat paws 2 oct 2024

    Overview of Clumping Cat Litter

    The type of clumping cat litter available today is modified from the traditional type of clay cat litter. It is made up of small particles of different kinds of clay that stick together in the presence of moisture. This feature allows cat owners to remove some of the used litter without emptying the entire box.

    This type of cat litter is not naturally scented, however. There are unscented varieties available, but they won’t mask any unpleasant odors from the litter box in your home. In order to combat this, scented versions are available, but they are scented with artificial, chemical scents, which not everyone enjoys. Overall, owners find that most cats are willing to use clumping litter since it feels more natural for them to relieve themselves on the texture and consistency it provides.

    clumping cat litter
    Image Credit By: Karnstocks, Shutterstock

    How it Works

    Clumping cat litter is primarily composed of bentonite clay pulverized into smaller particles. It is named clumping cat litter because bentonite clay particles absorb moisture and clump together. Many cat owners prefer this type of litter because it is easy and convenient to clean. The litter box can be cleaned by scooping out the clumps while loose litter will sift through the scoop. There is no need for a special litter box or scoop.

    During the cleaning process, though, there is a certain amount of dust is produced. Your cat may track this dust around your house. Clumping litter does, however, have the advantage that it can last a very long time with regular cleaning.

    How to Change It

    Clumping litter can be changed in a similar manner to wood pellet litter. The main difference is that clumping litter doesn’t settle completely to the bottom, so sifting and removing it is much faster when scooping. You should scoop clumping litter every day if you have multiple cats. If you only have one cat, you might be able to get away with doing it every other day.

    You will need to use the scoop to remove the clumps from clumping litter. As you scoop, you should feel the clumps. Shake the scoop over the box after you remove a clump to remove any loose litter. Remove clumps of litter by throwing them into a bag and continuing until only loose litter remains. You should clean and replace the litter box every 2 weeks. When it’s time to change the litter, dump the box’s contents into a bag. The bottom of the box can become a mess because clumping litter sticks together. Spray soap and water on the litter box. Add fresh, clean litter after rinsing it off and drying it.

    Dr. Elsey's Clumping Clay Cat Litter
    Image Credit By: Dr. Elsey’s

    How to Dispose of It

    The chemicals found in clumping litter may cause harm to the environment. Neither composting nor flushing is recommended. Instead, throw your used litter bag into your trash can with the rest of your garbage.

    Pros
    • Budget-friendly
    • Easily scooped
    • Produces little odor
    • Most cats will readily use this
    Cons
    • Dust is produced
    • Contain chemicals that can be harmful
    • It is not eco-friendly
    • Gets tracked easily around the house

    divider cat faces oct 2024

    Other Factors to Consider

    Price

    There are a few key factors to consider when deciding whether to use pellet litter or clumping litter. First, consider the price of the two types of litter. Clumping litter is typically more expensive than pellet litter. However, you may find that the price difference is worth it for the convenience and effectiveness of clumping litter.

    When discussing the price of cat litter, it is important to consider the quality of the product, too. Higher-quality cat litter will cost more, regardless of the type of litter (wood pellets or clumping). The reason for this is that higher-quality products are made with better materials and/or have a better manufacturing process. As a result, they are able to provide a better experience for the user, which is why people are willing to pay more for them. Just remember, higher-quality cat litter generally lasts longer than lower-quality options, so you end up using less of it over time.

    metal scoop on cat litter
    Image By: Pam Walker, Shutterstock

    A Safe Environment

    There are a few safety considerations to keep in mind when using wood pellets or clumping cat litter. It is important to make sure that the area where the pellets or litter will be used is well-ventilated, and some owners like to wear gloves and a mask when handling pellets or litter, as they may contain harmful chemicals. Remember that it is important to keep the pellets or litter out of reach of children and pets, as they may be tempted to eat them.

    Despite the convenience of clumping litter, there are some safety concerns. If your cat ingests bentonite clay from clumping litter, they may experience health problems. Due to its capacity to absorb some of the liquids within their bodies, it can cause blockages in their stomach and intestines. If your cat hasn’t been eating litter, this may not be an issue. But if you see this behavior, clumping litter may not be the best choice for your cat.

    Human health is another concern. The job of cleaning your cat’s litter box falls to you because they can’t do it themselves. It is dangerous for pregnant women to scoop litter of any kind due to the presence of toxoplasmosis in cat litter. Even if you aren’t pregnant, the dust from clumping cat litter can irritate your respiratory system, especially if the litter is scented with artificial fragrances. It may be better to use wood pellets if you suffer from respiratory illness.

    Switching Litter: What to Look For

    When you are ready to switch your cat’s litter, there are a few things to keep in mind. First, you’ll want to find a litter that is similar in texture and absorbency to the one you’re currently using. This will help make the transition smoother for your cat. Secondly, you’ll want to gradually introduce the new litter by mixing it with the old litter. After switching litter, keep an eye on your cat’s litter box habits for a few days. It may be hard for some cats to adjust to wood pellets if they aren’t used to it. You will have to clean up more unpleasant messes if they start relieving themselves elsewhere. There are some cats that take longer to adapt to new litter than others, while there are others that may never get used to it.

    When switching litters, there are certain things you need to take into account to ensure the new litter is appropriate and successful for your cat. Cats are susceptible to allergies and skin sensitivities just like humans. Any respiratory problems or skin irritation may indicate an allergic reaction to either type of litter. Some cats are sensitive to fragranced litter, but wood pellets can also cause problems. If your cat is experiencing problems with the litter, you should stop using it.

    divider cat paw scratch oct 2024

    Conclusion

    In conclusion, when choosing between pellet and clumping cat litter, there are a few factors to consider. Clumping litters are generally more absorbent, while pellet litters tend to be dust-free. Clumping litters also tend to be more expensive than pellet litters, but they are easier to clean up. Pellet litters are less dusty, but they can be difficult to scoop out. Ultimately, the best litter for your cat depends on their and your individual preferences.


    Image Credit: Africa Studio, Shutterstock (L), Karnstocks, Shutterstock (R)

    How useful was this post?

    Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

    Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

    Your feedback really matters.

    What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

    Join the conversation

    Leave a Reply

    You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

    Talk With A Vet Online

    Peace of mind,
    anywhere, anytime

    Affordable vet advice

    Can You Use Horse Pellets for Cat Litter? Vet-Approved Facts & Tips

    If you are a cat owner, you know that you need various supplies to properly care for your feline, including litter. Nowadays, there...

    Horse Bedding Pellets

    Can You Compost Cat Litter? Vet Approved Facts & Tips

    Americans recycle or compost nearly one-third of the 292.4 million tons of municipal solid waste (MSW) they generate annually. It takes effort, but...

    Cleaning cat litter box

    How to Retrain a Cat to Use a Litter Box: 13 Vet-Approved Tips

    Inappropriate elimination can be difficult to deal with, resulting in ruined belongings and strained relations between cats and their favorite people. It’s one...

    Ginger cat in blue litter box

    How Much Litter Should You Put in the Litter Box? Facts & FAQ

    In general, you should add about 2–3 inches of litter in your litter box. Of course, the exact amount will depend on the...

    cat sniffing the litter box

    More related

    Open Litter Box VS Closed Litter Box

    Open vs. Closed Litter Box: Main Differences, Pros & Cons

    Your cat is an important member of your family, so you want everything to be perfect for him, from food to toys and...

    woman in a yellow sweater with jar of baking soda

    Can You Put Baking Soda in Cat Litter? Vet Approved Facts & Safety Advice

    Cat ownership changed forever when kitty litter was invented in 1947. You didn’t have to let the family pet outside to do their...

    Cat tray with crystal litter and scoop on floor near light blue wall

    10 Essential Cat Litter Box Accessories to Get You Started

    One of the challenges that cat owners face is coming up with a substantial cat litter box system and cleaning routine. More often...

    orange cat beside litter box

    8 Common Litter Box Issues & How to Fix Them

    It’s a common myth that cats always use their litter boxes without issue. For the most part, cats indeed learn to use a...

    Keep reading

    How to Tell Cat Gender By Face? 3 Vet-Approved Ways

    Male and female cats can have physical and behavioral differences. Additionally, each faces its own unique health challenges, which can make it essential to know what sex you’re adopting. The only 100% reliable way of knowing a cat’s sex is...

    close up amber smoke norwegian forest cat

    Can Cats Eat Cabbage? Vet-Reviewed Health and Nutrition Advice

    With all of the health benefits that cabbage is said to have, you may wonder if it is safe to give some to your cats. Cats are obligate carnivores and thrive on a complete and balanced source of animal protein...

    Can Cats Eat Cabbage

    10 Best Pellet & Pine Cat Litters in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

    Being a cat owner can be one of the most rewarding experiences for us humans, but one of the distinct disadvantages is dealing with the litter box. Part of the unpleasantness of litter boxes is the rather pungent odor of...

    wood-pellet-cat-litter

    How to Tell if My Cat Needs Their Glands Expressed? 6 Vet-Verified Signs

    As a cat owner, you need to make sure your beloved friend is healthy, and sometimes that means dealing with bodily functions that aren’t so pleasant. Cats have two anal sacs that help them mark their territory. The sacs are...

    Cat sitting on a vet metal table

    Can Cats Be Allergic to Litter? Vet-Approved Facts & Safety Guide

    Humans aren’t the only ones unlucky enough to be affected by allergies. Cats can also be allergic to various items, like pollen, food, and potentially even cat litter. Signs your cat might be allergic to litter are similar to those...

    orange cat beside litter box

    Treating Heartworm Disease in Cats: Can It Be Cured? Vet-Approved Info

    Finding out your cat may have heartworm can be a shock, although the diagnosis may be quite challenging to establish. Heartworms are parasites that live inside the heart and large blood vessels, causing it to function incorrectly and even stop...

    bengal cat and vet

    Why Are Cats’ Noses Wet? Vet-Approved Feline Anatomy Facts & When to Worry

    A cat’s nose can occasionally be used as a reasonable indication of their health, but this can be quite variable and should not be fully relied upon. It depends a lot on outside environmental conditions, as well as the cat...

    pink cat nose closeup

    Triumph Cat Food Review of 2025: Recalls, Pros & Cons

    Review Summary Triumph brand cat food has earned an above-average rating compared to other brands that we have reviewed. Our rating is based on product quality, packaging, price, taste, shelf life, etc. Triumph cat food is made in the United...

    Triumph Cat Food Review