Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Homemade Cat Toys vs Commercial Toys: Olga’s Unusual Favorites

Share

Olga with her strange toys

Hi, I’m Christopher! Read my introduction to learn more about me and my silly Russian Blue cat, Olga.

I give Olga a pack of catnip mice to play with every Christmas, and she loves batting them around for about a week. Whether she’s only attracted to toys with fresh catnip or gets tired of playing with the mice, I don’t know, but I’m lucky she doesn’t have expensive taste. My yearly catnip purchase is the extent of my pet toy budget, and for the remaining 51 weeks of the year, Olga chases paper balls and plays with a three-pronged plant holder.

divider cat paws 2 oct 2024

Premium Pet Toys

Several years ago, when I was in college, I met a student who spent nearly $1,000 on a carpeted cat tree. It was shaped like a giant mushroom and was at least 4 feet wide and 8 feet tall. It took up most of the space in her bedroom, and although it was a bright green monstrosity, I was impressed that her hefty cat slept on the tree and seemed to like it.

At the time, I thought it was careless for anyone, especially a college student, to spend that much on their cat, but I’ve changed my mind. I still think it’s excessive, but I understand how owners feel about their pets. In this age of digital purchases, there are plenty of moronic ways to blow your paycheck. Is a $1,000 cat tree more ridiculous than buying a rare non-fungible token (NFT) featuring an animated pickle for the same amount?

Olga playing with wadded up paper
Luckily, Olga doesn’t have expensive taste…

divider cat paws 2 oct 2024

Homemade Toys for Olga

I’ll spend any amount at the veterinarian’s office to ensure Olga stays healthy, but I’m unaccustomed to buying expensive toys since Olga prefers homemade ones. She loves dribbling a paper ball around the house like a soccer player, and if she gets tired of playing with it by herself, she hits it in my direction.

A few months ago, her paper ball hit me in the head while I was watching a movie and ignoring her performance. When she’s had enough exercise, she’ll rub her head on the paper and cuddle it. She’ll do the same with her plastic plant holder, and it’s the only time she’ll let me rub her belly like a dog. Even more than the paper balls, the plant holder puts her in a trance that makes her more tolerant of petting.

Olga playing on the couch
Getting a plastic plant holder face massage

divider cat paws 2 oct 2024

When Olga Was a Kitten

I didn’t let Olga play with the plant holder as a kitten because I was worried she would tear it up and swallow the plastic pieces. However, the plastic is braided and tough and isn’t damaged after years of abuse.

She was a wild beast as a kitten who loved to bite anything in sight, including my hands, feet, and writing utensils. As an almost mature adult, she’s less fond of biting but still enjoys hitting my leg when I walk by to encourage me to play tag or fetch. Playing tag is another of her favorites, and most of the time, she hits me without using her claws.

Some cat owners aren’t as lucky, and their cats aren’t interested in playing free games like tag or cuddling a $2 piece of plastic. However, I don’t think spending a bundle on a cat is odd if the toys or equipment make them happy. If I owned an elitist feline demanding premium products, I would probably relent and buy a hurricane-proof catio decked out in stone, an automated litter box resembling R2D2, and a 14-karat gold cat brush.

This article is a part of Christopher and Olga's series.

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.




How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.


Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

Why Healthy Cats Still Vomit Sometimes (And How to Respond)

A cat that just vomited needs a specific kind of care, and the feeding decisions you make in the next few hours actually...

Scientists May Have Found the Missing Piece in Feline Kidney Disease

One of the most upsetting parts of caring for an elderly cat is the knowledge that there is a very high chance that...

Ask Dr. Paola – Help! I Am Worried My Cat Isn’t Getting Enough Water! (April 6, 2026)

Welcome to our “Ask Dr. Paola” series, where every Monday we bring expert advice straight from Dr. Paola Cuevas (MVZ) to help our...

The 10 Common Causes of Sudden Death in Cats (And Which Ones Are Preventable)

Most cat owners don’t think much about heart disease, internal hemorrhage, or viral infections until they’re staring at an empty bed. Sudden death...

More related

Why Is My Cat Pulling Their Hair Out? 7 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

Cats can spend up to 50% of their day grooming themselves. They do it primarily to keep themselves clean, but grooming also helps...

How to Prevent Insect Bites on Cats: 6 Useful Tips

It stands to reason that if you have to worry about mosquito and other insect bites in the yard, you have to worry...

Smoking Cats? Jesus Dogs? We Interview Artist Michael Caines

Art is most profound when it stirs up our minds, when it presents the world in ways we’d not consciously considered or even...

Why Does My Cat Drool When I Pet Him? 4 Vet-Verified Reasons for This Behavior

There’s nothing quite like the shared bliss of having a purring cat sleeping on your lap or chest, but nothing ruins these joyful...

Keep reading

How Long Do American Shorthair Cats Live? Average Lifespan Data & Facts

Studies have shown that owning a cat can reduce stress levels and improve mental health, leading to a longer and happier life. But not all cats are created equal when it comes to lifespan. The American Shorthair, for example, is...

American shorthair male cat tabby

How to Sedate a Cat for Grooming: 3 Vet-Approved Methods

Some cats do not like being groomed, but if they’re long-haired or unable to groom themselves for any reason, grooming is a necessity. If their coat is not free of mats and tangles, it can tug uncomfortably on your cat’s...

groomer brushing a maine coon cat

Can Cats Eat Tapioca? Vet-Approved Nutrition Facts

If you’re wondering if your kitty can lap up a bit of your tapioca pudding without getting sick or poisoned, you’ve come to the right place. Tapioca is not toxic to cats, and in fact, it is found in the...

Can Cats Eat Tapioca

9 Best Cat Foods for Diarrhea in Canada in 2026: Reviews & Top Picks 

As lucky as we are to parent our fluffy family members, it isn’t a job that comes without some pretty gross cleanups, smells, and, of course, worry. If your cat has a sensitive stomach, they may suffer from diarrhea among...

grey cat eating food

Can Cats Eat Cauliflower? Vet-Verified Nutritional Facts & FAQ

Here’s a mystery: You set a piece of cauliflower down on your plate, turn around for two seconds, and then realize that the cauliflower has disappeared. Is your house haunted? Did the cauliflower transport into a different dimension? None of...

Can Cats Eat Cauliflower

Why Does Catnip Make Cats Go Crazy? What Science Tells Us

The effects of catnip have provided content for an endless train of entertaining YouTube videos, and even the word itself grabs the attention of any cat owner who has a cat that loves catnip. Most cats exposed to catnip experience...

Gray Cat Enjoying Fresh Catnip_Anna Hoychuk_shutterstock

Can Cats Eat Pumpkin Puree? Vet Approved Facts & Nutrition Guide

When people think of pumpkins, they usually think of falling leaves, bonfires, chilly temperatures, and seasonal treats. However, did you know that some cats love pumpkin just as much as their pet parents? While your feline pal might show interest...

Can Cats Eat Pumpkin Puree

Can Cats Eat Apple Pie? Vet Reviewed Advice

Apple pie is a popular dessert, and the smell alone will attract any hungry and curious pet. If you catch your cat sniffing around the pie dish, you may be tempted to share a slice, or if your cat has...

Can Cats Eat Apple Pie

Love Cats? So Do We! Join the Catster Community

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.




Sign up for the Catster Email Newsletter

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.