Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

How to Choose a Cat to Adopt: 6 Vet-Approved Factors to Consider

Girl and woman cat owners holding cats in shelter to adopt

You’ve decided you want to welcome a cat into your home, but you’re not sure how to get started. Adopting a cat is a wonderful experience, but it can be a nerve-wracking affair if you’re a newbie to pet ownership. Considering that a cat is a long-term commitment, it’s a good thing you’re here. In this article, we’ll delve into all the major aspects you’ll need to consider when choosing your perfect kitty to bring home.

Check it out below, right after a quick list of the supplies you’ll need.

divider 1 paws

Before You Begin

Before you start on your cat adoption journey, it’s essential to go shopping for essential supplies. While food, litter, and treats are recurring costs, most of the following items are one-time or long term purchases.

Essential Cat Supplies
  • Litter box
  • Cat litter
  • Travel carrier
  • Food & water bowls
  • Collar with ID tag & your contact information
  • Scratching post/mat
  • Cat food of choice
  • Cat treats
  • Pet bed
  • Toys
  • Pet wipes
  • Pet shampoo
  • Cat tree (optional)
  • Cat shelves (optional)

Note: it’s best to start with the food your cat is used to in their shelter and slowly transition them to another food (if necessary).

That’s really all you need to bring your cat home for the very first time, and you don’t necessarily need to go all out with the fanciest products. You can start with the essentials and incorporate more toys, etc. later on. Now that you’re armed with your essential cat supplies, it’s time to discuss what to look for in an adorable cat before adopting. Read on for the details and consider jotting some of this down for later.

Cat Essential Tools
Image Credit: Yuriy Golub, Shutterstock

divider 1 paws

The 6 Things to Consider When Adopting a Cat

1. Kitten or Adult Cat: Which Should I Get?

Adult cats are typically easier to care for as a first-time pet owner than a kitten, but it depends on the type of companion you’re looking for. A kitten is a big commitment from day 1, and they don’t always have a fully formed personality like adult cats.

Kittens go through spurts of hyperactivity, may need help with litter training, and overall are more work. There is something truly beautiful about raising a kitten and watching their little identity blossom as they bond with you, but it may not be for everyone due to the rigors involved.

On the other hand, adult cats are typically neutered/spayed, have been vaccinated, and have a distinct temperament all their own. You likely won’t have to teach your mature cat how to use a litter box, and those with a history of being house trained are relatively quick to adapt to a new house. This makes adults a good choice for someone who isn’t used to cats and may not be confident in their ability to look after a kitten.


2. Investigate the Cat’s Health

When looking at adult cats, you should ask about their medical history. Broadly speaking, a clean, well-groomed cat with clear eyes and trimmed nails will be healthier than a malnourished cat with unkempt, dirty fur and painfully long nails.

Purebred cats are often predisposed to certain genetic risks (depending on their breed) and may be associated with more veterinary costs as a result of these risks.

Adult cats from rescue shelters are sometimes hit-and-miss on medical history, so we urge caution. If someone doesn’t want to talk about a cat’s medical history, won’t let you visit the facility, or the cat appears unwell, it’s a major red flag.

two women adopting cats at the shelter
Image Credit: BearFotos, Shutterstock

3. Ask About the Cat’s Background

You can tell a lot about a cat by where they come from. The tricky part is that many rescue kitties come from checkered, often abusive circumstances, and there are many strays or feral cats that may get mixed in, too.

What to Ask About:
  • Ask about previous homes, if possible. Cats who grew up with children might make a good family cat, while a history of abuse may require more effort on your part to bond with the cat.
  • What was the specific reason the cat was surrendered? Was it neglectful owners or something else that you should be aware of?
  • Does the cat have special needs that will require additional veterinary expenses and at-home care?
  • Is the cat litter trained?
  • Does the cat have any major behavioral problems or quirks you should know about?
  • Ask whether the cat is more outgoing, reserved, clingy, energetic, laidback, etc. It’s important the cat has a personality compatible with your lifestyle.
  • Does the cat have any special dietary needs?

4. Assess the Cat’s Personality

You’ll need to meet with multiple cats before you get a handle on which you resonate with most. Is it the shy, sweet calico that prefers wet cat food? Maybe the forwardly affectionate tortoiseshell? Finding the right cat may take some patience, but we have tips that can help when you’re meeting cats.

Tips for Assessing Cat Personality include:
  • Look for a relaxed, easygoing posture
  • Look for a cat that isn’t scared to approach you
  • See if the cat enjoys physical contact with you
cat getting adopted
Image by: Anika Moritz, Shutterstock

5. Consider Your Home Environment & Lifestyle

Think about what you’re really looking for in a cat when you go to meet kitties for the first time. Are you looking for a mellow companion with a short, low-maintenance coat, or do you prefer a more active, fluffy/furry family companion that’ll play games with you? To help you determine the type of cat that might fit your home, ask yourself the following questions.

Important Questions include:
  • Do you have kids, and if so, how old are they? Younger children require more supervision around pets and may do better with a robust adult cat rather than a young kitten.
  • Can you comfortably afford the recurring food and medical expenses a cat needs?
  • Do you have other pets? Introducing new pets can be a challenging process when not approached carefully.
  • Is your home safe for a pet? Think about any major hazards that could hurt your pet, like exposed electrical outlets or wiring.
  • Do you have time to spend with your cat outside of work and your other commitments?
  • Do you travel? Traveling cat owners need to pay for pet sitters and kennels and typically pay pet fees at hotels.

6. Let the Cat Choose You

If, after all our tips, you’re still having a hard time, let the cat choose you. Like people, sometimes, when you meet a cat, you feel an instant connection. That’s a pretty good sign you’ll be fast friends! We know we threw a lot of info at you above, but in the end, you should trust your gut instinct.

If a cat is grumbly and antisocial, it’s okay to meet other kitties. It’s better to wait for your perfect cat than to settle for one you won’t get along with. Once you bring your cat home, you should take things at their pace.

They’re in a new place and don’t know what’s going on. Give them time and space to acclimate to their new home and routine while maintaining a calm, loving presence. This can take days to weeks and possibly longer with some cats.

adopting a cat
Image Credit: Susan Schmitz, Shutterstock

divider 1 paws

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right cat to adopt requires you to do your research on a cat’s history, personality, and health and think about whether they fit in well with your lifestyle. It’s also always a good idea to consult a vet about what you should know about a feline’s health & care before adopting your ideal kitty.

See also:


Featured Image Credit: BearFotos, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

Cats and Countertops: What Olga Gets Away With

Hi, I’m Christopher! Read my introduction to learn more about me and my silly Russian Blue cat, Olga. Due to their climbing and...

Golf Course Cats: Keeping Up With Milly (Part One)

Welcome to the Wednesday Cats of Catster! Every week, we share a story from one of our cat-loving Catsters. This week is about...

Environmental Enrichment for Cats: 12 Vet-Reviewed Tips

While indoors is the safest place for cats, it’s not always the most enriching. It’s important to remember that cats, at their very...

How Do I Know if My Cat Is Healthy? 12 Ways to Check at Home (Vet Approved)

We all want the best for our pets. Sometimes, they make it challenging, as cats are well-known for their penchant to hide illnesses...

More related

Can Cats Eat Pretzels? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts & Risks

Pretzels are baked snacks with a dusting of salt on top. They’re addictive to you, but can your cat enjoy them with you?...

Can I Crate My Cat During the Day? Vet-Approved Tips & FAQ

If your cat gets into trouble when left home alone, you might be desperate for a solution, especially if they’re prone to destructive...

Indoor vs. Outdoor Cat Food: Vet-Reviewed Nutritional Differences

You’ve probably stood in the cat food aisle of your local grocery or pet store and marveled at the sheer number of options...

How to Get a Cat to Use a Cat Tree: 6 Vet-Reviewed Tips & Tricks

Cat trees keep our cats off the furniture and provide a comfy, secure place to lounge. They’re also excellent scratching outlets that minimize...

Keep reading

Can Cats Eat Cheez-Its? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts & Considerations

Our pets are like family members to us. They join in on quality time with the rest of the kids and adults and often become the center of attention with their hilarious antics. However, when it comes to sharing your...

Can Cats Eat Cheez-Its

What’s the Cost of Cat Insulin in 2025? Price Guide & FAQ

Our feline friends can develop diabetes, and like us, they might require insulin. If your cat has been diagnosed with this disease, you’re likely wondering how much you’ll be paying for cat insulin. The good news is that the price...

Cat's owner measuring the blood sugar values of his feline using glucometer

When Do Male Cats Start Spraying? Vet-Reviewed Facts & Tips

Male cat pee has a distinct odor, and when your male cat sprays outside the litter box, you know it without a doubt. In fact, both male and female cats spray, but males do it the most. For those with...

Norwegian forest cat male marking its territory

7 Best Cat Foods for Pancreatitis in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Feline pancreatitis is one of the most troublesome cat diseases. This condition is not only difficult to diagnose but also tends to be resistant to treatment. Cats are good at hiding illness, meaning you might not know that your kitty...

Cat hungrily eats dry food

At What Age Can You Touch Newborn Kittens? Vet-Reviewed Handling Guide

The worry you feel when your cat is pregnant can be overwhelming. As a pet parent, you’re constantly watching the little momma and trying to make sure she’s ready when the time comes. Then you see the kittens. It’s no...

newborn kitten in man's hand

Are Tomato Plants Toxic to Cats? Vet-Reviewed Houseplants Examined

There’s nothing more exciting than welcoming a new cat into your life. Having a pet involves taking good care of it and buying the proper cat food, plenty of kitty litter, and some toys. If you plan on allowing your...

Catster_Are Tomato Plants Toxic to Cats

Do Cats Get Annoyed? 10 Vet-Reviewed Signs & What to Avoid

Cats can get annoyed just like humans, although they usually express it differently than us. Even the most loving and content feline can experience annoyance. It is one of the many emotions cats can feel. A cat will show clear...

An annoyed cat or angry cat with a ball toy.

Can Cats Eat Pears? Nutrition Facts & FAQ

Fruit is a tasty addition to a healthy diet; it provides plenty of dietary fiber and many other essential minerals and vitamins. It is well known that dogs can have small amounts of fruit as a part of their regular...

Can Cats Eat Pears