Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Why Euthanasia Is A Gift: Dr. Karyn Explains

Tate and Clutch - sun worshippers

Hi, I’m Dr. Karyn! Read my introduction to learn more about me and meet my five hilarious cats: Clutch, Cyril, Alex, Zelda, and Zazzles.

This is going to be hard for me to write, so bear with me.

My pets are sometimes the one thing that gets me through the day; theirs is the definition of unconditional love. Sure, sometimes they’re demanding, and some cynical people might say that their affection is given purely in exchange for food. I feel sorry for those people, because they have clearly never experienced what I have, and I know that most of you have too.

In four decades, I have only lived 18 months without a cat in my life, and it sucked. But with all the joy, comfort, and companionship, comes the sad fact that the lifespan of our pets is only a fraction of our own (with the exception of some parrots and tortoises!). This means that at some point, we have to say goodbye.

Me and Sully the cat selfie
A selfie with my cat Sully

divider 3 paws

Euthanasia in my work

I’ve always wanted to be a vet; there was never anything else I wanted to do. But in my teens, I started to worry about how I would handle the emotion around euthanasia, and I actually delayed my veterinary training, instead doing a science degree and working for a few years. Fast forward ten years, and not only was I emotionally mature enough to cope with euthanizing pets, I came to appreciate what a gift it really was.

People often ask if I find euthanasia difficult, but I truthfully answer that, in the vast majority of cases, it is a blessing to be able to help take away an animal’s suffering. When we have reached a point where we can no longer help them medically, it is honestly a wonderful thing that we can let our pets go in a quick, peaceful, and painless way. I don’t want to open a can of worms about human euthanasia, but I personally think that it’s horrible, even ludicrous, that we are not legally able to have the same experience, without journeying to another country whose laws allow it.

Don’t get me wrong, I am not indifferent to the passing of my patients, and there have been many, many times where I have been holding back tears as I gave the injection, and others where I was blubbering right alongside the owner. Sometimes the worst ones weren’t difficult just because of the pet, but the people left behind, because I know, all too well, how they feel.

Although there are rare situations where a euthanasia doesn’t go as smoothly as we would all like, such as pets that need sedation before we can place an IV, or the animals that involuntarily vocalize as they pass (a reflex that sounds awful, but not something the pet is aware of), in the vast majority of cases, euthanasia is a calm, peaceful procedure, which can take place in a veterinary practice or sometimes at your home. When euthanasia comes at the end of a long life, or a long and difficult illness, the most common emotions I see expressed once a pet has passed away are grief, gratitude, and relief. Gratitude for having shared their life with such a beautiful soul, and being able to spare them any future pain or indignity, and relief that their pet died quickly, peacefully, and cradled by loved ones, and is no longer suffering.

Potato (Tate) the dog
We adopted Tate when his previous owners could no longer take care of him

Staying with your pet

Some people prefer not to stay when their pet is put to sleep, and that is okay. That is a personal choice. Rest assured that they will still be held and soothed and showered with affection as they pass. Whenever an owner is on the fence about whether or not they want to be present, I always encourage them to stay with their pet. If things get too difficult, they can always leave the room, but if you regret not staying, you can’t get that back.

I once went to the home of an elderly chap who had some health problems of his own, and he had finally made the decision to say goodbye to his collie, who had been by his side for 16 years, seeing him through some really tough times. He was, understandably, very emotional, and thought that he couldn’t stay in the room, but kept changing his mind, and his dog, Molly, was clearly worried about her distressed owner. In the end, we had a chat outside and I asked him to come and stay with her, just as she had been beside him all her life. And he did. He held her head and cried into her neck as she slipped away in his arms.

A few days later, he came into the vet clinic to shake my hand and thank me for “making him stay.” He was so grateful to have been there for Molly in her final moments, and bear witness to how peaceful her death was. Even though it had been a really difficult day for him, it was made a little bit easier by knowing that he’d done the right thing by Molly, and that he was with her at the very end.

Sully the cat
In her later years, Sully moved with me from Australia to the UK

Euthanasia and me

Of course, I have had my fair share of pets leave me over the years, and there have been a couple of situations that have solidified for me, just what a blessing it can be to be by your pet’s side when they die. I often hear people say that they would prefer that their pet pass away naturally, in their sleep, at home. And you know what, sometimes this does happen. But often, especially when it comes to illnesses like kidney disease or cancer, it can take a long time for death to come, and there may be a lot of suffering before it takes them. The privilege, which is what I believe it to be, of being able to take control of that final journey and make it as warm and loving as possible, is something I have envied on more than one occasion.

Twice in my life I have had pets pass away suddenly, unexpectedly, while I wasn’t home. On the positive side, I knew that neither my elderly cat or epileptic dog had been in pain or suffering prior to their deaths, and both had been enjoying life as normal on the mornings I left them, but they were dead before I came home. I know that there is nothing I could have done, but I am still haunted by the fact that I don’t know if they were scared, or in pain, or how quickly death took them. I just know that they were alone.

For this reason, when I am counseling people about making that final decision, when we know that there are no other options left, I encourage them to choose euthanasia, and choose it before it’s too late.

Sullivan (Sully for short) flew all the way from Australia when she was 14 to live with me in the UK, which she did happily for almost two years. She had shown no signs of heart problems prior to her death.

Tate (short for Potato) had joined our family when his previous owner could no longer take care of him, and he had been so stable on his medication, I couldn’t have predicted or planned for his death, which came suddenly one evening while I was at work.

I have to take comfort in knowing that they had not suffered in the days leading up to the one that would be their last. But if I had known, I would want to be there to hold them and comfort them and show them that they were so loved.

Memorial tattoo for Tate
My memorial tattoo for Tate

Parting thoughts

If you are struggling with the euthanasia decision, of knowing when the time is right, of knowing if you will be able to stay, I will leave you with this advice:

  • I have never seen the decision to euthanize a sick or suffering pet too early, but I have definitely seen it made too late.
  • It is better to say goodbye when there is still some joy left, than to wait until there is none.
  • It is unlikely that you will regret staying with your pet, but you might regret leaving.

And finally,

  • You are not killing your pet. You are not giving up or ending their life. You are ending their suffering and preventing any more. You are allowing them to pass away quickly and painlessly, in your arms.

We don’t always get to make the decision, and the death of our pets is never easy. But if euthanasia becomes the only real option in front of you, please do not think of it as something to feel shame or guilt over. Euthanasia is the last thing we can do to show our pets how much we love them; that we put their needs before our own. When suffering becomes inevitable, euthanasia is the gift that takes it away.

This article is a part of Christopher and Olga's series.

Dr Karyn signature

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

Black Cat Awareness Month: When Is It & How to Celebrate

The black cat has been given a bit of a rotten deal. There are too many superstitions and far too much misinformation about...

How to Bandage a Cat Paw: 4 Vet-Approved Tips

Cats are curious and playful creatures, which can lead to them getting injured. When a cat injures their paw or a limb, it...

Steve Connell Talks About Inspiring People to Adopt via Poetry for “Shelter Me”

The actor, poet, and playwright Steve Connell has loved animals throughout his life. When Steven Latham, producer and director of the PBS series...

9 Best Catnip Sprays of 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Are you familiar with catnip? It is a fragrant herb that gets cats licking, chewing, or rolling in bliss. Some cats become calm,...

More related

Why Does My Cat Kick the Wall? 8 Possible Reasons

Cats are masters of odd behaviors, and it’s one of the reasons that we love them so much. But what’s so interesting about...

Cats and Taxidermy: We Interview a Taxidermist About Pet Preservation

My dearly departed feline friends Ichiban and Cyclops live on – in the form of photos, a lock of fur apiece, and a...

How to Clean Cat Eye Boogers? Vet-Approved Step-by-Step Guide

A thin layer of tears protects a cat’s eyeball, protecting the eye from any irritants or foreign bodies to keep vision clear. The...

Abyssinian Cat Breed Info: Pictures, Traits & Facts

The Abyssinian cat, or the Aby, is unique compared to many other fuzzy felines commonly kept as pets. These lovely creatures combine most...

Keep reading

Is My Cat Deaf? 6 Vet Approved Ways to Tell

If you’ve been asking yourself, “Is my cat deaf or ignoring me?”, you’ve probably noticed changes in your cat’s behavior. Maybe they are not responding to your voice like they used to, or perhaps they seem oblivious to the vacuum...

cat ear close up

How Can Cats Survive High Falls? Vet-Approved Science & Info

Cats have been wowing humans with their ability to handle high falls with relative ease. Cats have survived falls from great heights, although they don’t always come out unscathed from such incidents. However, the fact that they’ve survived is considered...

side view of a blue tabby white maine coon cat jumping down from birch tree in the back yard

Can Cats Eat Pineapple? Vet-Approved Nutritional Facts

Some cats will eat their meals every day and barely even notice the human food around them, but others are more adventurous. If this sounds like your cat, they might want to try a nibble of pineapple. Don’t worry—cats can...

Can Cats Eat Pineapple

Are Goldfish Plants Poisonous to Cats? Vet-Reviewed Houseplants Examined

Hardy and colorful goldfish plants can make stunning additions to your home. The brightness of the flowers and the movement of leaves can also be an enticing sight to your curious feline. Fortunately, goldfish plants aren’t poisonous to cats and...

Catster_Are Goldfish Plants Poisonous to Cats

Is Catnip Good for Cats’ Digestion? Vet-Reviewed Nutrition Facts & FAQ

Catnip is an herb related to mint that originated in Asia and Europe. It has green or gray-green leaves, light green stems, and tiny lavender flowers. It’s technically called Nepeta cataria and has long been used in cooking and for...

cat with green eyes in catnip

When to Euthanize a Cat With Liver Failure: Vet-Reviewed Advice

If you’re considering when the right time is to say goodbye to your cat if they are in liver failure, you are not alone. Knowing when to say goodbye is a heartbreaking decision for any owner, and it can be...

woman brought her cat to the vet

9 Best Cat Meal Toppers in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Disclaimer: Before changing your cat’s food or offering new ingredients, consult with your veterinarian. Pets that are on a prescription diet or suffer from certain ailments may need to avoid certain food ingredients.Caring for a cat certainly has its ups...

Grey domestic cat being given food in a bowl

Are Roses Toxic to Cats? Vet-Verified Facts, Risks & Safety Tips

With Valentine’s Day coming up soon, you may be worried about using rose petals or buying the romantic flower for a loved one around your cat. Luckily, roses are not toxic to cats, meaning that you should not worry about...

Catster_Are Roses Toxic to Cats