Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

One Man’s Trash is Another Cat’s Treasure (with Video)

Sometimes paper hunting is a waiting game.

Hi, I’m Dr. Karyn! Read my introduction to learn more about me and meet my five hilarious cats: Clutch, Cyril, Alex, Zelda, and Zazzles.

There are certain sounds that cats cannot resist – peeling back the lid of a can, the shake of the kibble box, or the opening of a refrigerator door – for Alex, it’s the rustle of paper being screwed up into a ball. I can be anywhere in the house, at any time of the day, and as soon as my hand starts to close around that piece of paper…Boom! The ginger ninja is there, long whiskers twitching, eyes wide, waiting to pounce.

You might recall that I recently talked about indoor cats and whether they should be allowed to hunt. When I watch the waves of anticipation ripple over Alex’s back as he readies himself to pounce on the unsuspecting ball of paper that has been so carelessly (strategically) tossed aside, I can see that he is able to flex his predatory instincts in a way that is safe for him, and seems to provide him with plenty of satisfaction.

Alex keeps his eyes on the prize.
Alex keeps his eyes on the prize.

divider cats oct 2024

Fresh is Best

Alex is quite particular about the quality of his crinkly quarry – evidently this type of game only stays fresh for a short time, and he’s soon back on the prowl. You might think that events like Christmas would be Alex’s idea of heaven, but not so. Apparently, the attraction of the paper prey is significantly reduced when available in large numbers – sort of like ‘shooting fish in a barrel’. It’s only fun if he needs to hone his instincts and strike with the precision of his wild ancestors, and evidently, being surrounded by a flurry of discarded wrapping paper and ribbon doesn’t have the same appeal!

Do the other cats get in on the action? Strangely, no; this is just Alex’s arena. Cyril occasionally looks on curiously, his fuzzy little brow furrowed in concentration, trying to work out the game, losing interest when he realizes there is no food reward.

Hunting, indoor cat style.
Hunting, indoor cat style.

When the hilarious duo, Ned & Fred, joined our household, there was suddenly competition. The tiny Chihuahuas are equally enamored of rustling wrappers, though they are usually motivated by the hope that there is something delicious contained within. Alex was initially put off by the Chihuahua’s energetic interference, but he now seems to enjoy the added difficulty level.

Zelda’s Stretch Appeal

Zelda is another of our hunters, but rather than engage in something as crass as chasing paper balls, her target requires something of a more stealthy approach. Hair ties and rubber bands are her quarry of choice, and she has a remarkable ability to sniff them out. Being that we would very much like to avoid these items lodging themselves in her intestines, this is something we try to prevent, but the fact that we actively deter and intercept her hunt seems to make it all the more satisfying for her.

Spoils of the Hunt
Spoils of the Hunt

On more than one occasion I have walked into the ensuite in the middle of the night to find Zelda precariously balanced on the shower door, trying to reach the hair tie I carelessly left hanging from the shower caddy. Just last night, she darted through the cat door that leads to the catio outside, with a large rubber band clamped firmly between her tiny white teeth. Realizing she had been spotted, she moved like black lightning across the room, equal parts determined and gleeful, knowing I was close behind, wondering how on earth a large rubber band found its way into the catio in the first place. These springy objects are the only toys she has ever shown any interest in – unless you count the kitchen sponges she liked to shred into confetti as a kitten – and when I hear her jumping and galloping around upstairs, I know exactly what I will find.

Fortunately, Zelda has not suffered any gastrointestinal consequences from her choice of prey, and seems to lose interest as soon as she has succeeded in breaking through the band – evidently an elastic string lacks the appeal of the stretchy ring. But I am not willing to take my chances, and so we will continue our little ritual: Zelda, lurking in wait for the opportunity to sniff out an errant elastic band, me, ever alert to her strange little game.

My cats, just like yours, help us find joy in the simplest of things. Their affinity for discarded objects and trash often leaves me wondering how the cat toy industry stays afloat when most moggies are determined to make their own fun.

This article is a part of Dr. Karyn's series with her five hilarious cats.

Dr Karyn signature

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

Inappropriate Elimination In Cats: Vet-Approved Guide & Explanation

Cats usually are pretty good about going to the bathroom in their litter boxes, but some occasionally veer off course and start peeing...

Vitamin B12 for Cats: 7 Vet-Approved Food Sources

Vitamin B12, or cobalamin, is an essential nutrient for cats, having a vital role in multiple key body functions and processes. Cats cannot...

5 Possible Reasons Why Your Cat Isn’t Drinking Water: Vet-Reviewed Facts, Remedies & Info

A proverbial thorn in the rose of being a cat parent seems to be worrying if our beloved felines are drinking enough water...

Are Sunflowers Toxic to Cats? Vet-Verified Facts & Safety Tips

Bright, colorful, and towering far above most of our heads in their natural growth state, sunflowers are the kind of bloom that makes...

More related

6 DIY Cat Pillow Plans You Can Make Today

While most cats are happy to nap just about anywhere in the home and often sleep in strange positions that don’t seem at...

Is It True That All Cats Hiss? Vet-Verified Facts & FAQ

When coming in contact with a strange cat you’ve never met, your first reaction may be to pet them. Reaching your hand out...

How Do Cats Cool Down? Vet-Reviewed Methods & Signs of Overheating

Like most mammals, when the weather gets hot, cats use different methods to stay cool. That’s especially true for cats with thick coats...

How to Find the Perfect Cat for Your Family: 8 Vet-Approved Tips & What to Look For

Cats remain one of the most popular companion animals in the world, and if you’re considering adding a cat to your family, there’s...

Keep reading

Can Cats Eat Pepperoni? Vet-Reviewed Nutritional Facts & Safety Info

You might have left out a leftover pizza only to be interrupted by a phone call. When you come back, you find your cat chomping down on the pepperoni. Should you be worried? Can cats even eat pepperoni? We’ll look...

Can Cats Eat Pepperoni

3 Food Sources of Thiamine for Cats (Vitamin B1): Vet Reviewed Options

We all want our cats to be healthy, happy, and with us for as long as possible. That’s why we take them to the vet for checkups, feed them high-quality, protein-filled food, and keep them indoors most of the time....

Munchkin cat eating

How Much Does It Cost to Spay or Neuter a Cat? 2025 Update (Vet-Verified)

Spaying and neutering are both common medical procedures recommended by veterinarians, breeders, and shelters. Spaying or neutering your cat removes the possibility of them reproducing. Besides helping prevent unplanned litters of kittens, spaying and neutering can prevent a wide range...

Two veterinarians holding down a Persian cat at the exam table

6 Best Cat Foods for Hyperthyroidism in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Hyperthyroidism is a disease that can negatively impact both humans and animals. Unfortunately, it is quite common among cats and can impact them enough to lessen their quality of life. This disease most frequently affects middle-aged and older cats causing...

siamese kitten eating from a stainless bowl

Why Do Cats Groom Humans? 8 Vet Reviewed Reasons

You can be sitting on the couch and scrolling on your phone when, all of a sudden, you start to feel an unusual feeling on the top of your head or arm. Your cat is licking you a lot lately,...

cat sitting behind the man licking his head

Why Do Cats Howl? Vet-Approved Reasons & What to Do

Cats can surprise us with their unexpected and unusual sounds during the day, but how often do you take the time to hear what they have to say? Even though they don’t speak our language, cats use various vocalizations to...

angry cat meowing outdoor

When to Euthanize a Cat With Hyperthyroidism: Vet-Approved Advice

Making the heartbreaking decision to euthanize your pet is never easy. You’ve likely gone through an emotional journey with your cat; from their first worrying signs, through diagnosis and anxiously waiting for test results, to managing the condition and finally...

vet checking cat on the table

Chronic Diarrhea in Cats: Our Vet Discusses Signs, Causes & Treatment

Nobody likes it when their cat has diarrhea, the kitty included. Not only is it potentially messy, but it can also be frustrating if it’s been going on seemingly without end or if it keeps popping back up when you...

maine-coon-cat-using-the-litter-box