Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Is Your Cat an Old Soul? Feline Myths 

Prominent “M” markings on tabby cats are said to represent more than meets the eye.

Hi, I’m Dr. Lauren! Read my introduction to learn more about me and my two adventurous cats, Pancake and Tiller.

This week’s topic is a light-hearted look at the myths about cats, and what makes them old souls. Cats at home are stoic, steadfast creatures. Sometimes to their own detriment.

As a vet, I’ve seen cats in great pain, accomplish great things. From dental disease, where people might find it difficult to comprehend that their cat is in pain due to how well they are still eating (top pointer: cats can eat just fine, even when they have some horrible dental issues!), to patients that have been hit by cars in sub-zero temperatures, crawled home without being able to use their back legs, and lived to tell the tale. (Of course, it took a few weeks’ of hospitalization, and a lot of TLC, as well). Or the cat who just showed up with 60% of her abdomen covered in third degree burns: like nothing had happened. No one even knew how she’d gotten them! (She also survived, with over a month of bandage changes, and intensive surgeries to clean the wound, removing dead tissue after every few days and slowly closing the wound back upon itself).

Such heroic stoicism might mean that cats are perceived as old souls. Is there merit in this belief?

Dr. Lauren and Pancake on the sailboat 2
Pancake pondering the world from the deck of my sailboat.

divider 1 paws

What Is An Old Soul?

An old soul is defined as someone who demonstrates a maturity, understanding, or seriousness that is typical of someone much older.1

Some consider old souls to be synonymous with past lives. Cats are certainly believed to have 9 lives, but can cats be old souls? (And for what it’s worth, we don’t actually seem to know where the myth that cats have 9 lives comes from, though it may be linked to Ancient Egypt…)

Cats are believed to have begun living with humans around 10,000 years ago, based on a mutual need for food and vermin control. A wonderful Just-So story by Rudyard Kipling, author of the Jungle Book, puts a semi-lighthearted take on the matter, describing how dog became man’s best friend, while the cat remained useful, but aloof, preferring his independence to a life of certainty. Entitled The Cat That Walked By Himself, it is an allegorical tale on many levels, and well worth a read if you’re a cat fan.

Closer to home, one apocryphal tale was told to me, unexpectedly, on a Friday night.

Some say they were sent for us…suggesting they are indeed old souls with a purpose.

I was driving to my sailboat on a Friday after work. Both Tiller and Pancake were with me, and as we stopped briefly at the last grocery store en route, I bought a few cans of cat food and some fresh chicken as treats for them during the weekend ahead.

Tiller sitting on the edge of the kitchen table
Tiller is always ready for a chicken treat.

The cashier looked knowingly at my cat food and enquired about my cats. We had a brief conversation about the two and their antics, which included plans to go sailing with me that weekend. To which she asked me a question that I would never forget.

Are they tabby cats?

Yes, they are, I replied.

She smiled knowingly and told me I was indeed a lucky person. Tabbies, she went on to explain, were sent to people for very specific reasons, by the powers that be. The M mark on their forehead was proof.

Her story went like this: When Jesus was a baby in a manger, at the night in the barn that fateful Christmas, he was cold, despite all attempts to keep him warm. The cat jumped up to sleep next to him, purring to comfort him, and keeping him warm. As a result, Mary marked all cats with a M on their forehead, to thank and bless them for what they had done. Thereafter, any cat sent with a special purpose came marked with the tabby M.

It’s stuck with me, ever since.

Either way, the tabby markings, and indeed cats in general, make for some great legends.

Pancake and Tiller spend the majority of their day sleeping

divider 3 paws

Are Cats Old Souls?

I read once that seagulls are actually the souls of dead sailors, come back to rest at the seaside, never truly to be parted from the ocean that will always call to them. I’d like to think that cats are not that far off. Whether they’ve lived some of their 9 lives, or are a tabby that’s been sent back for some greater purpose, they certainly are more than meets the eye.

This article is a part of Dr. Lauren, Pancake, and Tiller's series.

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

9 Best Outdoor Cat Beds in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Whether your cat lives outdoors full-time or is a part-time explorer, at some point, they’ll need a space to relax. Finding a soft,...

Microchip Now: To Prevent Apocalypse Now

Hi, I’m Dr. Lauren! Read my introduction to learn more about me and my two adventurous cats, Pancake and Tiller. As a veterinarian,...

7 Best Cat Trees for Small Apartments in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Many cats love the excitement and coziness of a cat tree. Cats will leap, run, scratch, and snooze in their favorite cat condo....

8 Best Flea Killers for Your Yard in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

When the seasons change, it can pose a big issue for indoor/outdoor pets and their homes. Even if your animal only goes out...

More related

300+ Male Cat Names: The Ultimate List of Masculine, Adorable & Tough Options

Having a hard time naming your cat is a relatable challenge that many cat owners experience. There are endless possibilities, and it’s often...

Tortoiseshell Cat: Info, Pictures, Care & Facts

It’s hard not to notice a tortoiseshell cat. Their appearance is striking, with their uniquely colored fur. No two felines are the same,...

Why Does My Cat Kick Litter Out of the Box? 5 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

Cat owners all over the world are familiar with that awful feeling of stepping barefoot on small litter pebbles, which is usually followed...

Ask Dr. Paola – Low Iron, Newborns & Digestive Issues (September 29, 2025)

Welcome to our “Ask Dr. Paola” series, where every Monday we bring expert advice straight from Dr. Paola Cuevas (MVZ) to help our...

Keep reading

Arm and Hammer Cat Litter Review of 2025: Recalls, Pros & Cons

Review Summary Introduction Cat litter is an essential item on any cat owner’s shopping list, and most of us have heard of Arm & Hammer, a brand that has been on shelves for over 170 years. All Arm & Hammer...

Arm & Hammer Cat Litter Review

What Houseplants Are Poisonous to Cats? 15 Vet-Verified Toxic Types

Wondering what plant to get that won’t upset your cat? We’ve got you covered. This post lists 15 common houseplants that should be avoided by cat owners—usually. In some cases, cat owners can have a plant that is not necessarily...

a black cat with succulent plants

Why Is My Cat Licking All Her Fur Off? Vet Approved Reasons & Tips

Cats are perfectionists in grooming, dedicating plenty of time each day to removing loose hair, dirt, and other debris from their coats. Catching your cat grooming several times per day isn’t abnormal, but if your cat is licking to the...

Chinchilla Persian Cat licking its paw

Do Cats Learn From Their Mistakes? Feline Assimilation Facts

People develop and grow from making mistakes and learning from them, but can the same be said for cats? Do cats learn from their mistakes? The answer is not entirely clear. Like other animals, cats do not use human logic....

tuxedo cat on tree

Can Cats Eat Raspberries? Vet Reviewed Nutritional Facts & Safety Guide

If your cat needs to shed a few pounds, part of their diet plan might include cutting back on treats or looking for lower-calorie alternatives to commercial kitty snacks. We know that fruits, such as raspberries, are healthy choices for...

Can Cats Eat Raspberries

How Many Hours a Day Do Cats Groom? Vet-Reviewed Behavior Explained

Imagine spending half of your waking hours in the shower every single day. While that might seem exceedingly boring and tedious to us, cats spend approximately 2–5 hours grooming themselves every day, which is between 30% and 50% of their...

bengal cat grooming itself

Can Cats Drink Lactose-Free Milk? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts

The image of the happy cat lapping up milk is an old cliché. While many feline parents assume that their kitties would enjoy a bowl of milk now and then, the surprising truth is that dairy products from cows could...

Can Cats Drink Lactose-Free Milk

Can You Catch a Cold From a Cat? Vet-Verified Facts & Info

Once cold and flu season hits, most people find themselves feeling pretty crummy at some point. As soon as one person in the household goes down with a fall or winter cold, it seems like only a matter of time...

teenager cat owner cuddling with pet cat