Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Does a Cat Scratcher Sharpen or Dull Nails? Vet Approved Tips & FAQ

Share

Cute cat sharpening claws on scratching post

A cat scratcher provides felines with a safe way to engage in their usual scratching behavior, which helps them maintain the health of their claws. It enables them to remove the outer sheaths of their claws, which need to be shed occasionally as their claws grow. Therefore, a cat scratcher isn’t really about sharpening or dulling a cat’s nails—it’s about removing the outer dead layers.

Cat scratchers do not sharpen a cat’s nails like you may sharpen a knife. Instead, the old, worn layer is removed to make way for the fresh layer underneath, which is often sharper. However, the nail can become overgrown and overly sharp without a cat scratcher, which can be a significant problem.

Felines will find a way to scratch even if you don’t provide them with the proper locations or materials. Scratching is a normal, instinctive cat behavior.  However, a cat may not scratch enough for different reasons, the most common being painful joints due to arthritis. This can lead to their nails becoming too sharp or too long. In these cases, you may need to clip their nails for them. You can do this at home or have a vet or groomer do it.

divider cats oct 2024

How Do I Keep My Cat’s Claws Healthy?

Without proper care, your cat’s claws can become increasingly overgrown and sharp. Fortunately, there are several things that you can do to help your cat’s claws stay healthy.

1. Provide a Scratching Surface

You should give your cat access to a cat scratcher or similar surface for them to scratch. You may need several of these scratching surfaces if you have a big house or several cats.

Different cats also have different scratching preferences. Some prefer to scratch vertically, while others prefer to scratch horizontally. Therefore, meeting these preferences can be helpful.

Cats naturally like to scratch to mark objects with their scent, stretch their muscles, and keep their claws healthy. A scratching post provides a textured surface for them to scratch, which can help naturally file down the claws and prevent them from becoming too sharp.

cat scratching a wall mounted cat scratchers post
Image By: Evgenia Terekhova, Shutterstock

2. Choose the Right Material

While some cats may have individual preferences for scratching surfaces, others are less picky. Typically, sisal, carpet, and cardboard are the best options. Most commercial cat scratchers are made with one of these materials.

The “right” material varies from cat to cat. Therefore, you may need to experiment with different materials to determine which option is best for your cat.

Hepper Hi-Lo Cardboard Cat Scratcher with Real...
  • Premium Materials - Hepper's cardboard scratcher is made with dense, B-flute cardboard, and a metal...
  • High, Low and Lower - A single cat scratch pad won't keep your cat engaged. 3 unique positions keeps...
  • Activates Muscles - The Hi Lo isn't just a cat nail file to stop the chief cat couch scratcher. The...

We're quite fond of cardboard as a material in cat scratchers, which is why we love the Hepper Hi-Lo Cat Scratcher. Encased within a well-constructed, modern birch plywood frame, this scratcher is designed with both cats and their owners in mind. It offers three versatile configurations to keep your feline friend active and entertained while enticing them to fulfill their natural scratching instincts (and away from scratching things they shouldn't). For more details, click here!

At Catster, we’ve admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest, so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!


3. Ensure the Proper Placement of the Scratcher

The placement of the scratcher also matters, though some cats will be pickier than others in this regard. You should put the scratcher where your cat spends the most time. If your cat scratches in a certain place naturally, you may want to place it there.

If you have several scratchers, place them in different locations. This helps your cat find somewhere to scratch no matter where they are.

cat using the scratching post
Image Credit: 5 second Studio, Shutterstock

4. Encourage Proper Scratching

While you don’t want cats scratching furniture, you do want them to scratch on the proper surfaces. By scratching these, your cat takes care of their nails, which is precisely what you want them to do.

Therefore, it’s best to redirect and encourage your cat’s scratching in the proper places. If you only get onto them when they’re scratching in the wrong places, they might assume you don’t want them to scratch at all. Of course, this can be a problem and lead to overgrown nails.


5. Do Regular Nail Trimmings

Regular nail trimmings may be necessary for some cats. Different cats have different grooming needs. Sometimes, their nails grow faster than they can wear them down. Therefore, you must trim their nails as necessary.

You can do this at home or have a groomer do it. Many groomers allow for quick appointments that only involve nail trimmings.

Hepper Cat Nail Clipper Kit
  • Complete Set - These cat nail clippers include both a large and small pair, meaning it works well as...
  • Razor Sharp Stainless Steel - The most comfortable cat nail clippers for indoor cats provide a fast...
  • Safety First - With a safety nail guard and locking spring, you can make sure every grooming cut is...

Trimming your cat's nails at home can be hard, but having a professional do it can be expensive. With the help of great tools like Hepper's Cat Nail Clipper Set, you can easily and quickly trim your cat's nails at home. This set includes two pairs of stainless steel clippers with safety guards and locking mechanisms, plus a built-in nail file and a convenient pouch.

At Catster, we’ve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!

divider 1 paws

Do Scratching Posts Make Cat Claws Sharper?

No, scratching posts do not make cat claws sharper or make them more pointed or dangerous. Scratching posts provide a textured surface that enables cats to engage in their natural scratching behavior.

When cats scratch on a suitable surface like a scratching post, they remove the outer sheaths of their claws, which may have become dull or frayed, and reveal the new layers underneath.

Regular scratching on appropriate surfaces, like scratching posts, helps prevent claws from becoming excessively sharp or overgrown. It also helps to keep the claws at an ideal length and condition.

Bengal cat plays with a scratching post in the living room
Image Credit: Amerigo_images, Shutterstock

Do Cat Claws Get Dull?

Yes, cat claws can become dull over time. The outer sheath of a cat’s claw is made of keratin, the same material that makes up human nails. As cats use their claws for various activities like scratching, climbing, and playing, the outer layer of the claw can become worn down or frayed. Regular scratching on appropriate surfaces, such as scratching posts, helps cats shed the outer layers of their claws, revealing brand-new layers.

However, if a cat’s claws are not regularly maintained or if they do not have access to suitable scratching surfaces, the outer layer of the claws can accumulate and become dull. This can lead to discomfort for the cat, as excessively long or dull claws may cause issues like snagging, difficulty retracting the claws, or uncomfortable walking.

To prevent claws from becoming excessively dull or overgrown, it’s important to provide cats with appropriate scratching surfaces, encourage regular scratching behavior, and, if needed, trim their claws using cat nail clippers. Regular nail maintenance helps ensure the claws are at an appropriate length and condition for the cat’s comfort.

divider 3 paws

Final Thoughts

Cat scratchers do not really make a cat’s nails sharper or duller. Instead, the nails are constantly refreshing themselves with new layers. The old layers will slowly wear out as the cat uses their nails. Eventually, these will be shed by scratching, revealing the newer layers underneath.

If cats never used their nails, they would get very sharp and very long, prompting a need for human intervention. Scratching will make the old layers fall off, making the nails their proper length and condition again. It’s an ongoing cycle—not one or the other.


Featured Image Credit: Amelia Fox, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.




How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.


Catster's Digital Magazine is Back!

Vet-approved health & behavior advice

Real cat stories & community features

Weird Cat Behaviors That Actually Make Perfect Sense

We have been sharing our lives with cats for thousands of years, yet we still find ourselves genuinely stumped by what they get...

The Dream of Talking to Cats Just Got Closer to Becoming a Reality

If you’ve ever wished your cat could simply tell you what they wanted, you’re not alone. From the meow that wakes you before...

Kizzy: The Feline Princess With a Purpose

We were first introduced to Miss Kizzy after she won a licky-treat challenge hosted by Professor Fluffovich, our resident feline research specialist. While...

Chatting With Sally About Mission Meow & Helping Cat Rescue Organizations Collaborate | Chatty Cattys, Episode 24

In this episode of Catster’s podcast, Chatty Cattys, Nicole and Dr. Karyn sit down with Sally Williams, the founder of Mission Meow, for...

More related

9 Best Cat Houses in 2026 – Reviews & Top Picks

Don’t tell your cat that we said this, but your house doesn’t actually belong to them. As a result, they need a place...

Does Lyft Allow Cats? Pet Policy & Travel Tips

There are times in life when you might need to travel with your cat. Whether you are flying on vacation or trying to...

7 Most Endangered Feline Species in 2026: Vet Reviewed Facts & Pictures

Far too many species are disappearing due to human activity and interference, and felines are not immune to becoming endangered and eventually extinct....

6 Vet-Reviewed Reasons Why Cats Drool & What to Do About It

Cats are much less likely to drool than dogs, which is why the phrase, “Cats rule, and dogs drool,” is so appropriate. In...

Keep reading

How to Choose Your Second Cat: Vet-Approved Tips for Finding a Great Friend for Kitty

If you currently have a cat and are planning to add another to your family, there are several critical factors to consider and steps to take before you can bring your new feline companion home. Once you’ve thought things through,...

two cats playing

Why is My Cat Peeing Everywhere All of a Sudden? 7 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

Cat owners can agree that the smell of cat urine is overwhelming. It’s a difficult odor to remove from furniture, carpeting, and other fabrics. Your home quickly becomes unpleasant if your kitty isn’t using their litter box. There are several...

cat with pee stain on the carpet

Can Cats Eat Pepperoni? Vet-Reviewed Nutritional Facts & Safety Info

You might have left out a leftover pizza only to be interrupted by a phone call. When you come back, you find your cat chomping down on the pepperoni. Should you be worried? Can cats even eat pepperoni? We’ll look...

Can Cats Eat Pepperoni

How Do Cats Hunt Birds? Everything You Need to Know!

It’s an age-old relationship—the predator/prey dynamic between cats and birds. Birds are incredibly fluttery creatures that have scattered flight patterns to divert prey. But cats are built for low-to-the-ground hunting, ambushing potential prey. So, cats can severely damage and impact...

cat hunting birds

How to Take Care of a Cat: Vet-Approved Beginner’s Guide

Here are much-needed tips on cats and how you can give a kitty the best life possible. It can be difficult to be sure if you’re ready to take on the responsibility of owning an animal, so let’s get some...

Domestic-cat-lying-on-owners-lap

Can Cats Drink Milk? Vet Approved Nutrition Facts & FAQ

Cats drinking a saucer of milk or cream is something we can all picture. Cats have been drinking milk in advertisements, cartoons, and even through popular sayings like the “cat that got the cream,” but can cats really drink milk?...

Can Cats Drink Milk

Why Does My Cat Hunt? Vet-Approved Behavior Science & Information

If you make sure your cat is always well-fed and has plenty of toys, it can be frustrating to find that they still want to hunt. Whether that’s catching something in your backyard or stalking the dog, most cats can’t...

Black Oriental Shorthair in the grass

Why Is My Cat Keeping One Eye Closed? 4 Vet-Reviewed Reasons & Tips

While it may be a cute idea to think your cat winks at you, a cat with one eye closed may be a sign that something’s amiss. If your cat has one eye closed most of the time, they may...

Orange cat with one eye

Love Cats? So Do We! Join the Catster Community

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.




Sign up for the Catster Email Newsletter

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.