Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Can Cats Eat Vanilla Pudding? Vet Approved Facts & FAQ

Catster_Can Cats Eat Vanilla Pudding_v1_Dec 4 2024

Cats are independent creatures, but they rely on us humans to take care of their nutritional needs. Commercial cat food is the easiest way to feed a cat, but sometimes, felines get into other types of food due to curiosity or hunger. They are especially interested in meat products, which makes sense because they are obligate carnivores, but they are also often drawn to dairy. So, it may seem okay to feed your cat vanilla pudding as a snack. Is vanilla pudding safe and healthy for them?

There is no reason to panic if your cat eats a small amount of vanilla pudding, but they shouldn’t be doing so. There are a few reasons to keep vanilla pudding away from your feline family member, and there are healthier alternatives to consider instead. Let’s dig into these topics.

divider 1 pawsThe Ingredients Are What Makes Vanilla Pudding Off-Limits for Cats

Cats may be attracted to vanilla pudding because it’s filled with calories and animal protein, but that doesn’t make the treat good for them. Vanilla pudding is filled with ingredients that we humans can handle during the digestion phase, but these ingredients are not as easily handled by our furry feline friends. The ingredients found in vanilla pudding include milk, butter, sugar, and vanilla extract, and they can all negatively impact your kitty in one way or another. Let’s examine each of these ingredients.

Milk

Unfortunately, almost all cats are lactose intolerant. After being weaned from their mother’s milk, they lose their ability to digest the sugars in lactose. If your kitty is lactose intolerant, they could experience problems like cramping, diarrhea, and even vomiting. Milk also tends to be high in fat, which is something cats do not need any extra of. Too much fat in the diet could lead to obesity and obesity-related health problems.

Milk on glass
Image By: Bommie, Pixabay

Butter

Leaving butter on the counter can attract your furry family member and become a tasty snack for them before you realize what is going on. However, butter isn’t something that your kitty should be snacking on at any time. Eating butter can cause digestion issues and other serious problems for your cat. There is a chance that they will present vomit or diarrhea.


Sugar

Cats can’t taste sweet, and they wouldn’t eat sugary foods in the wild. These carnivores are designed to seek out animal proteins, not fruits and cookies. So, sugar is nothing more than empty calories for your cat because they should be getting all the carbohydrates and nutrition that they need in their regular meals. Eating sugar can lead to the consumption of too many calories, which can lead to problems like obesity and heart disease. Therefore, it’s a good idea to keep sugar out of your cat’s diet.

sugar cubes
Image By: pasja1000, Pixabay

Vanilla Extract

Natural vanilla is not toxic to cats, but vanilla extracts are prepared by macerating and percolating vanilla pods in a solution of ethanol and water. Ethanol is toxic to cats, and a single teaspoon of it is enough to poison your cat.

With all these ingredients combined in one food, it is not wise to offer your cat any amount of vanilla pudding, even if it’s just the leftovers in the container that you couldn’t scrape out with your spoon.

divider 1 paws

Healthier Alternatives to Vanilla Pudding for Your Cat

While vanilla pudding is a no-go for your kitty, there are plenty of other human foods that are safe to offer in moderation. The key is to choose foods that offer nutritional value and include no toxic ingredients. Here are a few options to consider:

No human food should be offered as anything more than a snack or a treat. The more human foods that your cat eats, the less room they will have for their nutrition-packed commercial food. Speak to a veterinarian to inform yourself which foods are safe or unsafe for your cat.

Need veterinary advice but can't get to the clinic? Catster recommends PangoVet, our online veterinary service. Talk to a vet online and get the answers and advice you need for your cat without having to leave your living room — all at an affordable price!

PangoVet_Mention-in-Content for PangoVet2 save money

divider 1 pawsFinal Thoughts

Just because your cat shouldn’t eat vanilla pudding doesn’t mean they cannot enjoy human foods with you. When cooking yourself chicken for dinner, cook a small piece with no seasonings just for your feline friend. They will appreciate these offerings without the risk to their health.


Featured Image Credit: Brent Hofacker, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

15 Shorthaired Cat Breeds (With Info & Pictures)

Cats come in all shapes and sizes. While they don’t have the same diversity as dog breeds, cats have different physical traits. Shorthaired...

15 Best Cat Breeds for First-Time Owners: Vet-Reviewed Info, Facts & Pictures

As a first-time cat owner, you might be nervous about whether you can meet all the needs and expectations that your new kitty...

Are Tuxedo Cats Smarter Than Other Cats? Vet-Verified Facts & Info

Tuxedo cats are instantly recognizable by their distinctive black and white markings and have long been the subject of fascination among feline enthusiasts....

9 Best Grocery Store Cat Foods in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

If you are a cat owner, you know one of the most challenging aspects of raising your cat is feeding them healthy food...

More related

Unique Carpet Shampoo Review 2025 – Pros, Cons, & Verdict

Review Summary While Unique Camping + Marine may not be a household name in the world of pet care, don’t be too quick...

Seal Point Siamese: Info, Pictures, Origin & More

The Seal Point Siamese is considered the standard color point of Siamese cats and until the early to mid-20th Century, virtually all Siamese...

Why Is My Cat Making a Vibrating Noise? Vet-Approved Explanation

Perhaps you’re sitting on the couch with your cat that has wandered over to you for some affection. You oblige and scratch behind...

My Cat Ate Garlic Bread! Here’s What to Do (Vet Answer)

Garlic, while responsible for making so much of our food taste delicious, is highly toxic to cats. What should you do if your...

Keep reading

Grow a Herb Garden That’s Safe for Your Cat

If you love cooking with fresh herbs, you’ve probably daydreamed about growing your own little garden. But if you share your home with a curious cat, you might wonder: Are herbs safe to have around them? The good news is...

cat-palm-plant_

10 Best Cat Carriers in Canada: 2025 Reviews & Top Picks

There are several items that all pet owners should have that are essential for taking care of a pet. While carriers aren’t necessarily at the top of the list, they are still important when you need to transport your cat,...

cat in a green cat carrier

Why Is My Cat Squeaking Instead of Meowing? Vet-Verified Info & Reasons

Cats make all kinds of noises to communicate with their owners and each other. Some cats have resounding meows that owners can hear from around the house, and others will softly chirp or squeak to “talk”. All these noises are...

cat meowing

Is Your Cat Winking, or in Pain? 4 Eye Problems Every Owner Should Know

Think your cat is just winking at you in a mysterious, adorable way? Think again! If your furry friend keeps one eye closed most of the time, it might be more than a quirky habit. It could signal an underlying...

A photo of a lazy Cat winking at the camera

Vet Clinic Is Booked for the Day, What Do I Do? 5 Vet Approved Tips

Pets need to go to the vet on occasion, just like we need to visit our doctors occasionally. Often, when our pets need to go to the vet, we know in advance and can easily schedule an appointment. However, this...

man holding a cat in a waiting room at vet clinic

Can Cats Eat Lobster? Vet-Approved Diet Facts & FAQ

Not only is lobster nutritious, but it’s also something we humans look forward to spoiling ourselves with, especially in certain parts of the world. If you’re wanting to share the enjoyment and give your cat the treat of a fancy,...

Can Cats Eat Lobster

Why Do Cats Cry at Night? 8 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

Our cats are creatures of the night, so it’s no wonder you hear them howling their song into the echoing chambers of the house when all are sleeping. With as much as you’re getting used to the sound of a...

Ginger tabby young cat sitting on a wooden floor looks up, asks for food, meows

My Cat Died at Home, What Do I Do? 7 Vet-Reviewed Steps to Take

A pet’s passing is a painful and emotional time for everyone who loved and was loved by them. In some cases, we know when our pet is declining and can mentally prepare for their passing and say our goodbyes, but...

cremated remains of a pet cat