Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

What to Feed a Stray Cat That Shows Up at Your Door? Our Vet Answers

a gray stray cat is walking along the sidewalk

If you are feline-obsessed, then a stray cat showing up at your door might seem like divine providence. You were hoping for another cat, and here one just happens to show up! But many questions are running through your mind. Are you sure it is a stray? Can you keep a stray cat? What can you feed a stray cat and what do they normally eat?

Each of these questions is sensible, and before you can determine how to best handle the situation, you will need some answers. In this article, we aim to offer some succinct answers to help you figure out the right course of action to take when a stray shows up on your doorstep.

divider 2 cats

Are You Sure It’s a Stray?

The first thing you must be certain of is that it’s a stray cat. Truth be told, there’s a good chance that it is. In the United States alone, it’s estimated that there are more than 70 million stray or feral cats. To put that in perspective, there are approximately 95.6 million cats kept as pets in the country, according to a national survey of pet owners. This means there are nearly as many stray cats as domestic ones in America.

Still, you need to be sure that the cat is a stray before taking action. Appearances can often give us clues. For instance, if the cat seems very lean, has a patchy or rough coat, or displays an overall unhealthy appearance, it’s a good bet that the cat hasn’t had human contact for some time.

Make sure to check the cat for a collar or some sort of identifying tag. If you find one, the cat is almost certainly someone’s pet. Even without a collar, it’s possible that the cat is microchipped.

Exhaust all possible options when ensuring that the cat is a stray. The last thing you want to do is accidentally steal someone’s pet!

stray cat in corner
Image Credit: 1000 Words, Shutterstock

divider 2 cats

What to Feed Stray Cats

Once you’ve determined that the cat is truly stray, you can start to think about providing some care for it. So, what should you feed a stray cat?

You can feed a stray cat the same sorts of foods you would feed to your pet cat. Start by offering the cat a can of tuna or cat food. Wet food tends to be more appealing to cats, though if you only have dry cat kibble, you can try to offer that as well.

Though you’ll often see people offering milk to stray cats in movies, this is a bad idea. Most cats are lactose-intolerant. Their digestive systems are not built to process dairy. Giving a cat milk could be forcing diarrhea or an upset stomach upon them. Aside from food, you’ll also want to make sure to provide the stray cat with plenty of fresh water.

One important rule to follow is to only offer and never force. Remember, a stray cat is basically a wild animal. If you attempt to force it to eat, you could get bitten or scratched.

What Do Stray Cats Eat Normally?

cat with dead mouse
Image Credit: Piqsels

Keep in mind that cats are not helpless creatures. You see a stray cat and might have an emotional reaction that causes you to want to help, but cats are natural predators and ruthless ones at that. Feral cats have many options for food and may not need your help at all.

Some common foods that stray cats eat include:
  • Mice
  • Rats
  • Other rodents
  • Fish
  • Lizards
  • Birds
  • Insects
  • Rabbits
  • Squirrels
  • Chipmunks
  • Other small mammals

divider 2 cats

Can You Keep a Stray Cat?

If you’ve been feeding the stray you found, you might start developing some feelings towards it, which could evolve into wanting it to be your pet. First, you must remember that it’s essentially a wild animal and will require taming if you wish to keep it as a pet. But is it even ok to do such a thing?

As long as the cat doesn’t belong to anyone else, you can keep it. But you’ll need to be certain, which means taking the cat to a vet to get it scanned for a microchip.

Of course, there are other options aside from keeping the cat yourself. You could do something called a TNR, which stands for trap, neuter, return. This helps to stop the feral cat population from continuing to expand.

Another option is to find the cat a suitable home that’s not your own. This might require some additional steps and work, including possible vaccinations, deworming, spaying/neutering, and more.

One final option is to take the cat to a shelter or humane society where the cat can be put up for adoption. This isn’t an ideal solution though, so treat it as a last resort.

kittens in a cage of a shelter
Image Credit: Okssi, Shuttestock

divider 2 cats

Conclusion

Cats are incredibly capable creatures, and a stray cat probably doesn’t need your help to survive. Still, the caring instinct in you might be too strong to see a stray cat and not offer help. If that’s the case, you can provide water, tuna, or cat food to the cat. But first, you should ensure that it’s truly a stray and not someone’s pet.


Featured Image Credit: Gansstock, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

Ragdoll Kittens for Sale in Missouri: Breeders List 2025

Catster advocates for adopting before shopping, though we fully understand there are many reasons for seeking a breeder. So, we encourage it to...

The Thrill of the Hunt: Do Cats Need It to Live a Good Life?

Hi, I’m Dr. Karyn! Read my introduction to learn more about me and meet my five hilarious cats: Clutch, Cyril, Alex, Zelda, and...

Can Cats Eat Lobster? Vet-Approved Diet Facts & FAQ

Not only is lobster nutritious, but it’s also something we humans look forward to spoiling ourselves with, especially in certain parts of the...

Can Cats in the Office Help Lower Employee Stress Levels? Benefits, Facts & More (Vet-Verified Info)

It wasn’t that long ago when the concept of sharing your workplace with an animal was entirely unheard of. The workplace was for...

More related

Can Cats and Rats Be Friends? Our Vet Answers & Explains

Rats don’t get much love from pop culture or social media. But that’s not fair because these rodents can be loving, caring, and...

How Do I Find a Lost Cat with a Microchip? Vet-Verified Facts & Safety Tips

Losing your cat is a situation no one wants to go through. You might have lived with the cat for years, and losing...

10 Best Litter Boxes for Large Cats in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

All cat owners know how picky cats can be. Sometimes, finding a litter box your cat likes is difficult, especially if you have...

How Big Does an Abyssinian Get? Average Weight & Growth Chart

With a lean, elegant look, the Abyssinian cat strongly resembles the cat statues of Ancient Egypt. They’re a striking breed with exotic gold...

Keep reading

Is Dracaena Toxic to Cats? Vet-Reviewed Houseplants Examined

Having live houseplants adds a nice touch to your home and helps to keep your air clean, but our feline companions do enjoy playing with leaves and flowers. While many plants are safe, some common houseplants, like dracaena, are toxic...

Catster_Is Dracaena Toxic to Cats

Does Sevin Dust Kill Fleas on Cats? Vet-Verified Risks & Safety Info

Sevin Dust is an insecticide with active ingredients, including carbaryl, bifenthrin, and zeta-cypermethrin. It is commonly used in garden spaces to kill unwanted pests. Sevin Dust should never be used directly on your cat, it is highly toxic to cats....

vet holding magnifying glass searching cat fleas

Why Is My Cat Drooling All of a Sudden? 13 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

Our feline friends can sometimes do odd things, so you may not always know what’s normal cat behavior and what isn’t. One feline behavior that you might be wondering about is drooling. If you see your cat drooling all of...

Orange cat drooling

4 Home Remedies for a Spider Bite on Your Cat – Our Expert Guide

Some cats love to investigate anything and everything, which sometimes includes spiders! Spider bites can be serious, so while there are home remedies that you can use to soothe adverse reactions, we recommend taking your cat to the vet for...

Cat Watches Spider

Can Cats Die From Stress? Vet-Approved Facts & Advice

We’ve all been there. The second something seems off with your cat; you imagine the worst. Your heart races and your eyes swell with tears. When you’re on the phone with your vet, you ask the dreaded “what ifs.” Sound...

cat hiding

Pet Poison Prevention Week: When It Is & Vet Approved Safety Tips

National Animal Poison Prevention Week (NAPPW) is an annual event that occurs during the third full week in March, and in 2024, it runs from March 17 to 23. The event is designed to educate pet owners on the substances...

cat with pill bottle

Can Cats Eat Pumpkin Puree? Vet Approved Facts & Nutrition Guide

When people think of pumpkins, they usually think of falling leaves, bonfires, chilly temperatures, and seasonal treats. However, did you know that some cats love pumpkin just as much as their pet parents? While your feline pal might show interest...

Can Cats Eat Pumpkin Puree

Why Is My Cat Gagging? 7 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

If you’ve recently seen your cat gagging, you may wonder what causes it and whether you should be concerned. Gagging is a confusing term, as it can mean different things to different people. Short of boring you with medical definitions,...

tabby white british shorthair cat gagging outdoors