Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

What to Feed a Stray Cat That Shows Up at Your Door? Our Vet Answers

a gray stray cat is walking along the sidewalk

If you are feline-obsessed, then a stray cat showing up at your door might seem like divine providence. You were hoping for another cat, and here one just happens to show up! But many questions are running through your mind. Are you sure it is a stray? Can you keep a stray cat? What can you feed a stray cat and what do they normally eat?

Each of these questions is sensible, and before you can determine how to best handle the situation, you will need some answers. In this article, we aim to offer some succinct answers to help you figure out the right course of action to take when a stray shows up on your doorstep.

divider 2 cats

Are You Sure It’s a Stray?

The first thing you must be certain of is that it’s a stray cat. Truth be told, there’s a good chance that it is. In the United States alone, it’s estimated that there are more than 70 million stray or feral cats. To put that in perspective, there are approximately 95.6 million cats kept as pets in the country, according to a national survey of pet owners. This means there are nearly as many stray cats as domestic ones in America.

Still, you need to be sure that the cat is a stray before taking action. Appearances can often give us clues. For instance, if the cat seems very lean, has a patchy or rough coat, or displays an overall unhealthy appearance, it’s a good bet that the cat hasn’t had human contact for some time.

Make sure to check the cat for a collar or some sort of identifying tag. If you find one, the cat is almost certainly someone’s pet. Even without a collar, it’s possible that the cat is microchipped.

Exhaust all possible options when ensuring that the cat is a stray. The last thing you want to do is accidentally steal someone’s pet!

stray cat in corner
Image Credit: 1000 Words, Shutterstock

divider 2 cats

What to Feed Stray Cats

Once you’ve determined that the cat is truly stray, you can start to think about providing some care for it. So, what should you feed a stray cat?

You can feed a stray cat the same sorts of foods you would feed to your pet cat. Start by offering the cat a can of tuna or cat food. Wet food tends to be more appealing to cats, though if you only have dry cat kibble, you can try to offer that as well.

Though you’ll often see people offering milk to stray cats in movies, this is a bad idea. Most cats are lactose-intolerant. Their digestive systems are not built to process dairy. Giving a cat milk could be forcing diarrhea or an upset stomach upon them. Aside from food, you’ll also want to make sure to provide the stray cat with plenty of fresh water.

One important rule to follow is to only offer and never force. Remember, a stray cat is basically a wild animal. If you attempt to force it to eat, you could get bitten or scratched.

What Do Stray Cats Eat Normally?

cat with dead mouse
Image Credit: Piqsels

Keep in mind that cats are not helpless creatures. You see a stray cat and might have an emotional reaction that causes you to want to help, but cats are natural predators and ruthless ones at that. Feral cats have many options for food and may not need your help at all.

Some common foods that stray cats eat include:
  • Mice
  • Rats
  • Other rodents
  • Fish
  • Lizards
  • Birds
  • Insects
  • Rabbits
  • Squirrels
  • Chipmunks
  • Other small mammals

divider 2 cats

Can You Keep a Stray Cat?

If you’ve been feeding the stray you found, you might start developing some feelings towards it, which could evolve into wanting it to be your pet. First, you must remember that it’s essentially a wild animal and will require taming if you wish to keep it as a pet. But is it even ok to do such a thing?

As long as the cat doesn’t belong to anyone else, you can keep it. But you’ll need to be certain, which means taking the cat to a vet to get it scanned for a microchip.

Of course, there are other options aside from keeping the cat yourself. You could do something called a TNR, which stands for trap, neuter, return. This helps to stop the feral cat population from continuing to expand.

Another option is to find the cat a suitable home that’s not your own. This might require some additional steps and work, including possible vaccinations, deworming, spaying/neutering, and more.

One final option is to take the cat to a shelter or humane society where the cat can be put up for adoption. This isn’t an ideal solution though, so treat it as a last resort.

kittens in a cage of a shelter
Image Credit: Okssi, Shuttestock

divider 2 cats

Conclusion

Cats are incredibly capable creatures, and a stray cat probably doesn’t need your help to survive. Still, the caring instinct in you might be too strong to see a stray cat and not offer help. If that’s the case, you can provide water, tuna, or cat food to the cat. But first, you should ensure that it’s truly a stray and not someone’s pet.


Featured Image Credit: Gansstock, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

9 Best Cat Foods for Weight Loss in 2025: Reviews & Top Picks

Obesity is one of the most common issues affecting domestic cats, and in 2018 alone, 33.8% of cats were obese, and 27.7% were...

Cats on Cars in Cold Weather: Vet-Reviewed Facts and Safety Guide

When the cold days are among us, pet safety precautions will be broadcast over every social media platform—and for good reason! Frigid temperatures...

Does Airbnb Allow Cats? 2025 Info Guide & FAQ

Although most cat parents don’t travel with their cats, more travelers are taking their cat companions with them when they hit the road....

10 Best Blacklights for Finding Cat Urine Stains in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Cat pee is one of the most invasive smells in the world. One of the only ways to eliminate the lingering smell of...

More related

Do Cats Like the Sound of White Noise? Vet-Reviewed Facts & FAQ

Cats are known for their finely tuned senses, including their excellent hearing. This helps them evade predators in addition to hunting prey effectively....

Siamese Kittens for Sale in Washington: Breeders List 2025

Excited Cats advocates for adopting before shopping, though we fully understand there are many reasons for seeking a breeder. So, we encourage it...

7-12-Month Old Kitten: What to Expect (Vet-Verified Guide)

Most kittens get adopted before they are six months old, meaning that you get to experience the part of a kitten’s life in...

Cat Utopia: How To Design The Perfect Place For Your Feline

If you’ve owned cats for any length of time, you know that a bored cat is a mischievous cat. That’s why it’s so...

Keep reading

Heart Murmurs in Cats: Signs, Causes, and Care (Vet Approved)

The last thing that anyone wants, is to worry about the health of their pet. But cats are talented at hiding injuries or health problems until it might be too late. When it comes to the cat’s heart, various conditions...

Veterinarian doctor holds cat

How to Introduce a Cat to a New Litter Box (7 Vet-Approved Tips)

There are several possible reasons you might need to switch up your cat’s litter box. Perhaps they have outgrown their present one, are having difficulties getting in and out, or need something more open or enclosed. Simple enough, right? Not...

sphynx cat using purple cat litter box

Why Is My Cat Attacking The Mailman? Possible Reasons & Prevention Tips

There are several reasons that your cat may decide to attack the mailman. In many cases, cats attack them for the same reasons that dogs do: out of territorial instincts or playful curiosity. In this article, we go over all...

Mailman delivering mail

Do Neutered Cats Still Mate? Vet-Approved Facts

Neutering a cat involves surgically removing a cat’s reproductive organs to prevent them from reproducing. It is done by a veterinarian by the time most cats are around 4 months of age or sexually mature. Owners may choose to get...

Close-Up Photography of Tabby Cats Laying

Can Cats Get Car Sick? Vet-Verified Facts & Info

A car ride often represents three things to your cat: change, a lack of control, and loss of freedom. Felines hate all of them, and this ramped-up anxiety and stress are even able to trigger vomiting or motion sickness in...

Cat Car Carrier

9 Best Limited Ingredient Cat Treats in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

This article has been reviewed for factual accuracy by a qualified veterinarian. It should not however, replace advice tailored to your pet by your veterinarian. Cat owners are urged to consult with their veterinarian when making dietary decisions for their...

himalayan cat eating treat

8 Best Shampoos for Maine Coon Cats in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

It is no wonder the Maine Coon is among the most popular cat breeds in the world. They are known for their sociability and are revered as the gentle giants of the cat world. They come with an uneven, two-layered...

red maine coon in the bathtub shampoo

Safe & Effective Cat Shampoo Alternatives: 8 Vet Approved Options

Most cats are good at keeping themselves clean, but sometimes, your furry friend might need a little help, especially if they’ve investigated something filthy. Of course, a shampoo specifically designed for cats is the best and safest option. Sometimes, we...

Woman washing cat in grooming salon