Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Why Do Cats Bring You Gifts of Toys or Dead Animals? Vet-Reviewed Behavior Guide

tabby cat carrying a toy in its mouth

Everyone loves gifts, but your cat has a very different idea of what qualifies as a present than you do. If you’ve ever been the recipient of a dead bird, mouse, toy, or random object courtesy of your lovable kitty, you’re probably wondering what it means. Cats gifting dead prey animals is a perfectly natural behavior that cannot be altered.  Cats bring you gifts of toys or dead animals to signal affection, show off their catch, or as a way to “educate” their owners on how to hunt.

If you’re interested in a more detailed explanation of this behavior and would like help protecting the wildlife in your area from your cat,  we have you covered.

divider cat faces oct 2024

Why Does My Cat Bring Me Gifts?

In the wild, mother cats bring half dead animals to their kittens for sustenance and to show them how to hunt. This behavior is still ingrained in domesticated cats who may see you as part of their family like a mother sees her kittens. That means they’ll be drawn to showing off their catches to you.

Every cat is different in how they play with, hunt, and handle dead prey. Some cats are consummate hunters that ruthlessly stalk, kill, and eat their prey whole. Others are less aggressive and sometimes even leave it alive to play with.

Burmese cat face before pounce hunting to toy mouse at home
Image Credit: Viacheslav Lopatin, Shutterstock

Why Does My Cat Bring Me Toys?

If your cat brings you toys, it could be for a variety of reasons.  It might be a sign that they’re bored and want to play with you. Who can resist a cat zooming around in mock pursuit of a feather wand or a mechanical ferret? Cats play with their littermates and mothers as kittens and remember those times fondly, so bringing you toys is a sign that your cat considers you family.

Take it as a compliment! If it’s happening often, it’s likely that your cat is feeling left out and needs more attention.

Why Does My Cat Bring Me Random Objects?

It’s cute when your cat brings you random objects with an expectant gaze. Cats are mysterious creatures, and their playfulness can manifest in a lot of kooky ways. For example, some cats are enamored of plastic bags, so they might show off their latest find to you.  This behavior can also be a sign that your cat needs more stimulation, so try to increase the attention and play sessions that you give your cat.

divider cat faces oct 2024

Can Gifting Dead Prey or Objects Be Harmful? Risks Explained

Presenting you with toys is harmless, but your cat could get injured or sick when hunting prey outdoors. One of the most serious threats are venomous snakes like coral snakes or rattlesnakes, which your cat may mistake for harmless garden snakes or black racers.

However, larger birds, spiders, badgers, raccoons, and coyotes are potential threats to your cat while it is out hunting. Yet another danger is getting sick from harmful bacteria, parasites, or contaminants in prey outdoors.

To look at it from another angle, it can be considered unethical to allow cats outdoors precisely because they’re such good hunters. This 2013 study by UC Santa Cruz states that cats are considered invasive superpredators and pose considerable ecological damage.

The effects are especially pronounced in confined regions like islands, but cats are adaptable and flourish nearly anywhere they go. While you can’t fix the entire problem yourself, you could help your cat and nature stay safe by keeping your cat indoors or building a “catio” to keep your cat contained while still allowing it access to the outdoors.

Cat chaising a mouse outdoors
Image Credit: Stefan_Sutka, Shutterstock

How to Stop Your Cat From Bringing You Dead Animals

As a one off, it’s not the end of the world, but it can become a problem if your cat regularly brings you dead prey. Dead animals are unsanitary to have in your home. However, we have advice on how to stop or reduce how often your cat brings you an unwanted gift. 

Tips for Stopping This Behavior include:
  • Prevent your cat from going outside in the first place, especially at dawn and dusk, when prey animals are foraging. If they crave outside time, consider a secure catio.
  • Put a bell on your cat’s collar so that potential prey animals hear them coming. This will reduce their hunting success.  Make sure you use a cat-safe collar that has a quick-release function.
  • Invest in indoor recreation and enrichment. Consider multi-level cat towers, cat shelving along your walls, scratching posts, and toys to satisfy your cat’s ingrained need for stalking, playing and catching.
  • Walk your cat on a leash for outside time.
  • Buy toys that simulate prey to satiate your cat’s prey drive, like battery-powered toy mice that scurry around.

divider cat faces oct 2024

Final Thoughts

Next time your cat brings you a toy or a dead mouse shows up around the house, take it as a thoughtful compliment and a sign that your cat loves you. Still, your cat could get sick or hurt hunting animals outside, so we recommend popping a cat-safe collar with a bell on it to reduce your cat’s hunting success, and  boosting your daily playtime with exciting toys to help satiate your cat’s instinct to hunt.  If all else fails and your cat is content to be an indoor only cat, this can be an option, although it doesn’t work for all cats. In some cases, preventing your cat from going outside at peak prey times, such as dawn and dusk, is enough to reduce their hunting success hugely.

See Also: 


Featured Image Credit: Mary Swift, Shutterstock

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

Are Savannah Cats Legal in Maryland? Updated Restrictions Across the US

Savannah cats are large and athletic cats descended from the wild serval cat. They are highly intelligent, open to training, and incredibly curious....

6 Cat Breeds With No Tails (Vet-Reviewed Info With Pictures)

To some, it may seem impossible to imagine a cat with no tail. After all, it’s such an integral part of their communication....

Why Is My Cat Over-Grooming? 5 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

It’s completely natural and healthy for cats to groom themselves and each other, but if your cat starts overgrooming, there may be a...

10 Best Outdoor Cat Houses of 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Whether your cat spends all their time outside or just heads out occasionally, having a place that’s just for them is essential, especially...

More related

Can Cats Eat Mayo? Vet-Reviewed Nutrition Facts & Advice

Mayo is a condiment that can be found in many people’s pantries and refrigerators. But what about cats? Can cats have mayonnaise? While...

Living With Cats When You’re Immunocompromised: Our Vet Explains the Risks, Options, & Provides Tips

While countless studies tout the physical and mental benefits of pet ownership, it can still be nerve-wracking for immunocompromised people to be around...

Do Cats Need a Cat Tree? Vet Approved Pros, Cons & Considerations

Cats love to be up high and observe everything around them but also enjoy having their own space while they sleep their day...

Is Lethargy Normal After Surgery In Cats? Vet Approved Care & Health Facts

Whether it’s a routine operation or major surgery, cats need time to recover after any surgical procedure. They need extra care and attention,...

Keep reading

10 Best Cat Foods for Nursing Mother Cats in Canada 2025: Reviews & Top Picks

Taking care of any cat means being attuned to their health and their happiness. When cats go through different stages of life, a change in diet is usually required. The diet of a kitten is different from that of an...

Gray mother cat feeding kittens while taking a nap

Is Alstroemeria Toxic to Cats? Vet-Approved Advice

If your cat just ate some of your Peruvian Lily or rubbed on the petals you may be panicking. Although The ASPCA lists Peruvian Lily, also known as Alstroemeria, as safe for cats, dogs, and even horses, it is listed...

Catster_Is Alstroemeria Toxic to Cats

Can Cats Eat Plantains? Vet-Reviewed Benefits & Tips

Plantains are a delicious nutritional fruity treat for humans. They are part of the banana family and offer nutritional benefits for humans, such as fiber, vitamins A, C, K, B, and antioxidants. If you have a cat that seems interested...

Can Cats Eat Plantains

Can Cats Eat Avocado? Vet-Verified Health Concerns & FAQ

Avocados have several nutritional benefits for humans; they are low in sugar and packed with healthy vitamins and minerals. They are considered great for heart health and may help lower inflammation. Avocados can be made into dips like guacamole, added...

Can Cats Eat Avocado

Can Cats Eat Dandelions? Vet-Approved Nutritional Benefits & FAQ

If you see your cat nibbling on common dandelions (Taraxacum officinale), it can be easy to want to rush them straight to the vet. But the truth is that dandelions are healthy for your cat in moderation. They offer numerous...

Can Cats Eat Dandelions

Why Are Cats’ Noses Wet? Vet-Approved Feline Anatomy Facts & When to Worry

A cat’s nose can occasionally be used as a reasonable indication of their health, but this can be quite variable and should not be fully relied upon. It depends a lot on outside environmental conditions, as well as the cat...

pink cat nose closeup

How to Make a Hyperthyroid Cat Gain Weight: 4 Vet-Reviewed Ways to Help

Cats with hyperthyroidism can live healthier lives if their condition is managed. Since one major sign of hyperthyroidism is weight loss, cat owners may wonder how to help their cats gain weight. An experienced vet is your best source of...

loss weight or skinny cat

Can Cats Eat Mint Ice Cream? Vet-Reviewed Health Facts

It’s funny that cats are often portrayed lapping at saucers of cream or a dish of milk, because the fact is, cats shouldn’t have dairy. While kittens can handle milk, most cats begin to become lactose intolerant after they reach...

Can Cats Eat Mint Ice Cream