Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Taking Care of a Picky Cat: How Olga’s Eating Habits Have Changed

Share

There's nothing like the flavor of processed chicken.

Hi, I’m Christopher! Read my introduction to learn more about me and my silly Russian Blue cat, Olga.

When Olga was a kitten, she wasn’t as finicky and always ran to the kitchen when she smelled my cooking. I gave her dry food every day and wet food a few times a week, and I made the mistake of replicating my previous cat’s diet. Free feeding isn’t recommended for most pets, but my Siamese cat never became overweight when allowed to graze all day on kibble.

divider cats oct 2024

Free-Feeding Frenzy

I shouldn’t have free-fed Olga; her head was much larger than her body when she was young, and her belly was starting to catch up. When my veterinarian said she was a little heavy for a kitten, I changed her diet and only gave her dry food in the morning and wet food in the evening.

It took several months, and by the time she entered adulthood, she no longer had a bulging belly. She loves wet food but only eats formulas with chicken or turkey. I discovered early on that seafood and beef weren’t kind to her gut, and until recently, she liked dry food.

Keep your feet away. This ottoman belongs to me!
Keep your feet away. This ottoman belongs to me!

Kibble Conundrum

She stopped eating her kibble, and when I tried to introduce new brands gradually, she ate them for a few days until they made her vomit. I’ve tried limited-ingredient diets and too many brands to remember, but nothing seems to agree with her stomach. She only tolerates wet food, and I no longer give her treats.

I don’t know why, but she eats more when I’m in the same room. If I go outside to fill up the birdfeeders after leaving a bowl of food for her in the morning, she waits at the window until I return and then runs back to her bowl to eat.

She doesn’t like to eat alone, and sometimes, she leaves most of her food uneaten and walks away. If I call her back and tap on her bowl, she returns to her food and devours it. Some dogs and cats become irritated or aggressive if you stand too close to them or pet them on the back when they’re eating, but Olga prefers it. She eats all her food now, but I still have to encourage her.

I'll spot you 10, but you still owe me for losing last week.
I’ll spot you 10, but you still owe me for losing last week.

Picky and Proud

Living with a picky cat is annoying, but Olga is healthy. She doesn’t bother me when I’m eating and doesn’t consume foreign objects, plants, or toxic chemicals. Being selective and indecisive may be an advantage for her. Since she has such a sensitive stomach, she may be less likely to eat something harmful.

That’s not a statement from someone with veterinary expertise, but it applies to my stubborn cat. Before dinner, she stares at me and whines if I look at her. She acts like a starving animal and tries to intimidate me by slamming the closet door or knocking my pen off my desk.

Her begging is relentless, but as hungry as she appears, she doesn’t eat all her food unless I join her in the kitchen. Olga is a freak of nature, but she’s a good cat.

This article is a part of Christopher and Olga's series.

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.




How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.


Catster's Digital Magazine is Back!

Vet-approved health & behavior advice

Real cat stories & community features

Chatting About Big Cat Tourism, Lion Hunting, and Learning From Our Mistakes | Chatty Cattys, Episode 26

In this episode of Catster’s Chatty Cattys podcast, Nicole and Dr. Karyn dive into the dark side of big cat tourism and the...

Why Cats Sit by the Door (But Don’t Go Through It)

Door-sitting is one of those quirky little habits that almost every cat owner experiences at some point. You know how it goes: a...

Six Legs Are Better Than Three – How A Tripod Dog and Kitten Found Friendship Through Recovery

Sometimes the most meaningful friendships begin in the most unexpected places. At a Maryland veterinary hospital operated by Last Chance Animal Rescue, two...

The Original Space Invaders – Why Zero Respect for Personal Boundaries Is a Good Thing

Cats have a reputation for being independent, and in many ways they are. But anyone who has tried to work at a laptop...

More related

What Your Cat’s Breed Says About You: Personality Traits Explored

Studies show 1 that a cat owner’s personality can impact the disposition of their pet. Cat owners scoring high in the openness personality...

Fussie Cat Food Review of 2026: Recalls, Pros & Cons

Review Summary This cat food is one of the higher-quality options on the market. It is made with whole meat in Thailand following...

10 Best Dog-Proof Cat Litter Boxes in 2026 — Reviews & Top Picks

Cleaning out the litter box is likely not one of your favorite chores, and you certainly don’t want your dog helping! If you...

10 Styles of Cat Scratchers: The Perfect Fit for Your Kitty (With Pictures)

Scratching is a normal cat behavior. Cats scratch for various reasons, such as to express certain emotions, maintain their claws, or mark objects...

Keep reading

Why Do Cats Like Milk? 2 Vet-Approved Reasons & FAQ

A cat lapping at a bowl of milk is something that we all think of when it comes to felines. This perception comes from farm cats from bygone eras lapping at the fatty topping of unprocessed cow’s milk and popular...

two cats drinking milk from the same bowl

Bombay Cat Health Problems: 5 Common Issues

The Bombay Cat is an adorable medium to large cat with sleek and short black hair. They’re a mix between the Burmese and American Shorthair. Bombay cats are a generally healthy breed that is also athletic and surprisingly heavy due...

Catster_Health Problems of Bombay Cat

Sphynx Cat Health Problems: 6 Vet-Reviewed Issues

Sphynx cats first came about in the 1960s as a result of a genetic mutation. Ever since cat owners have been in love with the unique look and personable nature of the hairless breed. Like other purebred cats, Sphynx cats...

Catster_Health Problems of Sphynx

Can Cats Eat Bread? Vet-Approved Facts & FAQ

Bread is a tasty treat that can be served in a variety of ways. During the pandemic, many people began experimenting with making their own bread at home due to shortages at grocery stores and bakeries, as well as to...

Can Cats Eat Bread

Can Cats Eat Sherbet? Vet-Reviewed Facts & FAQ

Have you ever wondered, as you were enjoying a cold bowl of sherbet on a hot day, whether or not it would be OK to share a bit of your yummy dessert with your favorite feline companion? Most cat lovers...

Can Cats Eat Sherbet

Why Does My Cat Sit on My Shoulder? 6 Vet-Reviewed Reasons & What to Do

If you’re lucky enough to have a cat in your home that craves attention and likes being around you, count yourself fortunate. There are cats out there who aren’t big fans of cuddles or being held. Then again, you have...

cat on woman's shoulder by head bite hair

Why Is My Cat So Jumpy All of a Sudden? 8 Vet Reviewed Reasons 

It can be alarming to see your cat act jumpy all of a sudden, especially out of nowhere. Cats cannot tell us exactly how they feel, which is why cat owners should pay close attention to their cat’s body language....

scared British blue-point cat hiding under the bed

Can Cats Eat Salami? Vet-Reviewed Risks & Healthy Alternatives

Since cats are carnivores, it may seem like they can enjoy eating different kinds of meat humans consume, such as cured meat. However, whether cats can eat cured meat is a question that isn’t very cut and dry. Although some...

Can Cats Eat Salami

Love Cats? So Do We! Join the Catster Community

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.




Sign up for the Catster Email Newsletter

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.