What You’re Doing Wrong With Your Cat’s Litter Box

Get down and dirty with common mistakes we humans make ... and help kitty love the litter box again.

A cat staring and looking up from a litter box.
A cat staring and looking up from a litter box. Photography ©Casey Elise Photography.

Dr. Meghan Herron, professor of veterinary behavioral medicine at the Ohio State University College of Veterinary Medicine (DACVB), says there are three common offenses cats would post on a blog site, if they could:

1. The litter box or litter boxes are too small

A cat digging in his litter box.
A cat digging in his litter box. Photography ©Magryt | Getty Images.

“Cats want to sniff around and investigate, then turn around, then dig and cover what they did in the box,” Dr. Herron says. “This is a hardwired behavior among most cats. Even for your average cat, the average-sized box just isn’t large enough.” Dr. Herron and most of her colleagues believe that the larger the box, the better.

2. The litter box or litter boxes are too dirty

“Boxes should be scooped daily — even more often if several cats are sharing a box and still more often if at least one of those cats typically has a messy (loose) stool,” Dr. Herron says. Change out the entire litter box annually at the least, maybe more often in multi-cat homes.

3. The litter box or litter boxes are too hard to get to:

Veterinary behaviorist and chief investigator of many cat studies Dr. Theresa DePorter (DACVB) of Oakland Veterinary Referral Services in Michigan, explains that the law for cat boxes is to have one plus one more box for each cat in the house. So, if you have three cats, that means four boxes. If you have six cats that means seven boxes. And, at least keep a box (or more than one box) on each level of the house. Keep in mind that three boxes close together in one room, from the cat’s perspective, is like one giant box.

Dr. Herron notes that most cats prefer privacy to do their business. Who can blame them? Still, too far away from the family is inconvenient. Near windows where loud noises occur or equipment like furnaces that blast with an unpredictable loud sound can startle cats. When startled in the box, some cats may instantly have an aversion to that location and even that box.

Other things to consider when it comes to cats and litter box problems —

A cat butt or a cat walking away.
A cat butt or a cat walking away. Photography ©nevodka | Getty Images.

1. Peeing or pooping outside of the litter box isn’t revenge

Cats never have accidents out of spite. “Think about it. A cat deciding to inflict punishing people by urinating or defecating makes no sense,” Dr. DePorter says. So what’s going on? Dr. Herron, who is co-editor of a book authored by many of her veterinary behaviorist colleagues, called Decoding Your Cat (coming spring 2020) says that when she was in private practice half the clients presenting with litter box issues actually resolved with medical treatment. Whenever there is a change in a cat’s behavior — consider asking “why now?” The answer might be medical. In any case, the cat is never being vindictive but instead is only attempting to cope.

2. Make sure you’re using the right litter and litter boxes

For kittens under about 9 weeks, Dr. DePorter says easy-to-get-into, very small boxes are best. Young kitties have limited mobility. Once they reach a few months old, they become circus performers — so getting into the box is no issue. And at that point a larger box to grow into makes perfect sense. Dr. DePorter says that if you do have the opportunity to offer young kittens various litters, early positive exposure is likely a good idea, and they may accept that variation throughout life. When cats have an aversion to litter, Dr. DePorter says considering the general type of litter they were likely exposed to as a kitten may be helpful. For example, barn cats in all likelihood grew up using sand or dirt, and shelter kitties clay or clumping litters. Dr. Herron says do consider that most senior cats have some degree of arthritis going on, whether or not you see any indications.

What’s more, some illnesses, such as diabetes, GI issues and kidney disease, can induce cats to urinate and/or defecate more often. Medications may create the urge to go more frequently, too. A golden rule for cats in their golden years may mean more litter boxes in more places — and for sure boxes that offer lots and lots of elbow room. “Understand the threshold for tolerating a situation the cat really never liked may also change with age,” Dr. Herron notes. For example, a geriatric cat who tolerated a certain type of litter he never really liked for 14 years on his 15th birthday may decide not to. The easier to step into and the roomier, the better the box. Storage containers (like the kind you’d keep sweaters in under a bed) with an entrance cut out so the cat can just walk in is a good idea. Dr. DePorter says other ideas about giving geriatric cats space might be to cut an entrance into a small kiddie pool (if you want one of those in your living room) or to use a pan used at the bottom of dog crates.

3. Different approaches work for different cats

Here’s what you can say for sure about litter boxes and cats. There are absolute rules that experts, such as veterinary behaviorists, have researched. However, for every rule there are a contingent of cats who just laugh — pointing out that such rules don’t apply to them. If whatever you are doing works for your cats — go with it. But understand your cats may possibly be tolerating and adjusting.

Helpful rules of thumb for litter boxes

A cat looking out from a litter box.
A cat looking out from a litter box. Photography ©Lightspruch | Getty Images.
  1. Most cats prefer fine, unscented clumping litter. Still, all cats are individuals and have their own preferences, which may be based on early exposure or just individual proclivity.
  2. Some cats prefer covered litter boxes, as they presumably offer privacy and a feeling of safety. Having said that, many cats don’t care, and most prefer uncovered boxes.
  3. In multi-cat environments, products like Feliway MultiCat calming pheromone diffuser can lower anxiety around the box.
  4. Don’t drown the cat in 6 inches of litter or be too stingy with less than a quarter of an inch. On average, use 1 to 3 inches.
  5. Litter boxes should not be too close in proximity to food or water.
  6. If the cat jumps in the box, does his business and instantly jumps out: He’s usually saying he’s tolerating the situation but doesn’t like the litter and/or the box isn’t clean enough.

The right way to clean a litter box

Dr. Theresa DePorter likes hot water, perhaps with gentle dish soap, to clean the box. In part, this is because cats’ sense of smell is so much more advanced than our own, and in part because of what might smell great to us can be offensive to many cats.

She says NOT to use:

  1. vinegar
  2. household cleaners
  3. citrus wipe

Thumbnail: Photography ©Casey Elise Photography.

About the author

Steve Dale is a certified animal behavior consultant who’s authored several books, including the e-book Good Cat, and has contributed to many, including The Cat: Clinical Medicine and Management, edited by Dr. Susan Little. He hosts two national radio shows and is heard on WGN Radio, Chicago, and seen on syndicated HouseSmartsTV.

Editor’s note: This article originally appeared in Catster magazine. Have you seen the new Catster print magazine in stores? Or in the waiting area of your vet’s office? Click here to subscribe to Catster and get the bimonthly magazine delivered to your home. 

Read more about litter boxes and litter on Catster.com:

4 thoughts on “What You’re Doing Wrong With Your Cat’s Litter Box”

  1. I have a male 4 he is a Begil. He has filled water and 5 hours. Trouble he pees then let me cry let me and wants cleaned . So clean and the bag away 2 a day
    He fowls to into the bathroom he is with 24/7

  2. Pingback: Why Do Cats Bury Their Waste? | Catster – Petcobestfood.com

  3. My cat just started peeing outside her box. She gets into the box, digs a place to go and then gets her rear-end as high as she can. She’s almost on her toes to make sure she goes over the top and onto the floor. It’s a large box with high sides. She has only one back leg due to an electricians terrible but it hasn’t slowed her down at all. This “over the top” is new and it sure looks deliberate. The accident that cost her her leg (and tail) happened around 7 years ago, but she is a real spitfire–always running full speed and playing with her toys. Any advice? Thank you!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Catster in your inbox!

Stay informed! Get tips and exclusive deals.

Let Catster answer all of your most baffling feline questions!

Starting at just

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
Error: No posts found. Make sure this account has posts available on instagram.com.


Follow Us

Shopping Cart