It’s even more difficult now because many popular brands are no longer available, causing owners to scramble to find a new brand that their cats will eat. We selected nine brands you can still find in the grocery store to review so you can see the difference between them.
Keep reading below for our reviews while we discuss ingredients, omega fats, probiotics, packaging, and more to help you make an informed decision.
In this article
A Quick Comparison of Our Winners in 2025
| Image | Product | Details | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Best Overall
|
|
Blue Buffalo Indoor Cat Food |
|
CHECK PRICE |
Best Value
|
|
9 Lives Daily Essentials |
|
CHECK PRICE |
Premium Choice
|
|
Purina Beyond Grain Free, Natural, Chicken Adult Dry Cat Food & Topper |
|
CHECK PRICE |
| Best for Kittens |
|
Kitten Chow Nurture |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
IAMS Proactive Health Cat Food |
|
CHECK PRICE |
The 9 Best Grocery Store Cat Foods
1. Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Natural Dry Cat Food – Best Overall
| Size: | 15 pounds |
| Type: | Dry kibble |
| First Ingredient: | Deboned chicken |
Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Natural Adult Dry Cat Food is our pick as the best overall grocery store cat food. It uses all-natural ingredients to provide your cat with the best possible nutrition. It contains deboned chicken as its first ingredient to provide high-quality protein, and it also includes fishmeal that provides beneficial omega fats.
Peas and eggs increase the protein even more, and oats and rice provide the fiber that will help keep the digestive system stable, reducing constipation and diarrhea. The only downside we experienced while using Blue Buffalo Indoor was that some of our cats wouldn’t eat it even when we slowly introduced it into their food.
- High-quality protein
- Formulated for indoor cats
- LifeSource bits
- Some cats don’t like it
2. 9 Lives Daily Essentials – Best Value
| Size: | 20 pounds |
| Type: | Dry kibble |
| First Ingredient: | Ground corn |
9 Lives Daily Essentials is the best grocery store cat food for the money. It’s inexpensive for a 20-pound bag compared to other brands, and it contains plenty of protein to give your cat energy and strong muscles. The ingredients also contain taurine and omega fats that will help keep your cat healthy.
The downside to 9 Lives Daily Essentials is that it’s mostly corn, and while most of our cats like it, it also contains chemical preservatives and artificial dyes that can cause health problems in some cats.
- 30% protein
- Contains omega fats
- Contains taurine
- Contains BHA
- Artificial dyes
3. Purina Beyond Grain Free, Natural, Chicken Adult Dry Cat Food & Toppers – Premium Choice
| Size: | 16 pounds |
| Type: | Dry kibble |
| First Ingredient: | Chicken |
Purina Beyond Grain Free, Natural, Chicken Adult Dry Cat Food & Toppers is our premium choice grocery store cat food, and it contains no artificial colors or preservatives. This limited-ingredient formula contains no corn, soy, or other grains that provide no nutritional value to a carnivorous cat.
The limited ingredients reduce the risk of your cat suffering an allergic reaction and make it easier to narrow down the cause of the problem if it does. The downside to Purina Beyond is that it’s expensive. We also noticed it gave several of our cats smelly gas and soft stools.
- Grain-free
- Limited ingredients
- No artificial colors or preservatives
- Expensive
- Can cause smelly gas
4. Kitten Chow Nurture – Best for Kittens
| Size: | 14 pounds |
| Type: | Dry kibble |
| First Ingredient: | Chicken by-product meal |
Kitten Chow Nurture is our pick as the best for kittens. This brand is very high in protein at 40%, which will help provide the energy and building blocks it requires to grow into a strong and healthy cat quickly. They responsibly source all ingredients, and the formula contains omega fats, which help with brain and eye development and are a critical nutrient for kittens.
Kitten Chow is fortified with vitamins and minerals to provide your cat with a balanced meal. Most of our kittens like to eat Kitten Chow Nurture, and we were impressed with its high protein, but there are no real meat ingredients, only chicken by-products and fish meal.
- 40% protein
- Omega fats
- Responsibly sourced ingredients
- Provides a balanced meal
- No real meat
5. IAMS Proactive Health Adult Indoor Weight & Hairball Control Dry Cat Food
| Size: | 22 pounds |
| Type: | Dry kibble |
| First Ingredient: | Chicken |
IAMS Proactive Health Adult Indoor Weight & Hairball Control Dry Cat Food uses a unique formula that helps your cat control their weight and contains ingredients that help reduce hairballs. It features chicken as the first ingredient and contains no artificial colors or preservatives.
It has omega fatty acids to help improve your pet’s coat, and there is 10% less fat than in the original IAMS formula. We liked reviewing IAMS Proactive, and it’s not difficult to find in your local grocery store. However, it contains a lot of corn, and some of our cats didn’t like it.
- Helps burn fat
- Helps reduce hairballs
- Low fat
- Contains omega fats
- No artificial preservatives or dyes
- Some cats don’t like it
- Lots of corn ingredients
- Check out our list of overall best cat foods (vet recommended) here!
6. Fancy Feast Classic Seafood Feast Variety Pack
| Size: | 12 3-ounce cans |
| Type: | Wet food |
| First Ingredient: | Salmon, Cod, Ocean whitefish |
Fancy Feast Classic Seafood Feast Variety Pack is the first wet food brand on our list. It’s perfectly suited for cats with constipation and can even help get stubborn cats eating again. It contains no corn or other grains that only serve to add weight to your cat. Each package includes three flavors, so it’s easier to find one your cat likes, and they contain taurine, which is essential for your pet’s health.
The downside to Fancy Feast is that the high moisture content can cause loose stools and diarrhea in some cats. We also have a few cats that don’t like it, no matter which flavor they try.
- Taurine
- Variety of flavors
- Grain-free
- Can cause loose stools
- Some cats don’t like it
7. Purina Pro Plan
| Size: | 16 pounds |
| Type: | Dry kibble |
| First Ingredient: | Chicken |
Purina Pro Plan is a popular brand that is easy to find in most grocery stores. It features chicken as the first ingredient and contains other sources of protein, including eggs, fishmeal, and poultry by-products. It also has omega fats, which help with brain and eye development, and antioxidants to help boost the immune system.
Taurine is also included and is an essential nutrient for cats. The downside to the Purina Pro Plan formula is that the bag is difficult to open, and some of our cats had loose stools, so you may want to introduce it slowly.
- Omega fats
- Prebiotic fiber
- Antioxidants
- Taurine
- Hard to open the bag
- Can cause loose stools
8. Purina ONE Sensitive Skin & Stomach
| Size: | 16 pounds |
| Type: | Dry kibble |
| First Ingredient: | Turkey |
Purina ONE Sensitive Skin & Stomach is a high-protein diet using turkey as its first ingredient and eggs and chicken by-product meal to reach 34% protein. It has vitamin and mineral fortification, and there are also omega fats in the ingredients, but there are no chemical preservatives or artificial dyes.
The downside to Purina ONE Sensitive Skin & Stomach is that the kibble is tiny, and our cats got it all over the floor while eating. Several of our cats didn’t like it, and those that did had loose stools and occasional diarrhea.
- 34% protein
- Omega fats
- Vitamins and minerals
- Tiny kibble
- Some cats don’t like it
- Can cause loose stools
9. Sheba Perfect Portions
| Size: | 24 2.6-ounce cans |
| Type: | Wet food |
| First Ingredient: | Chicken |
Sheba Perfect Portions has three varieties to choose from, and each contains chicken as the first ingredient. No artificial colors or dyes are in any variety, and they all have taurine and omega fatty acids.
The downside to Sheba is that the packaging is tough to open, and the individual-sized packages will have you struggling frequently. The plastic packages are also bad for the environment. Only about half of our cats would eat Sheba, and each had a flavor they didn’t like. It also gave several of our cats loose stools and diarrhea due to the high water content.
- No artificial colors or dyes
- Taurine
- Omega fats
- Hard to open packaging
- Plastic packaging
- Can cause loose stools
- Some cats don’t like it
Buyer’s Guide: Buying the Best Grocery Store Cat Foods
Protein
Your cat is a strict carnivore, so the most important ingredient in any food is animal protein. We recommend choosing a brand that lists real meat like chicken, turkey, salmon, or lamb as the first ingredient. Animal protein contains taurine, which is an essential nutrient that cats can’t produce. Protein is also necessary for muscle development and energy.
Taurine
Although taurine is an essential nutrient that comes from animal protein, some brands add taurine supplements to the ingredients to increase levels. A lack of taurine in the diet can cause your cat to develop poor eyesight and heart problems, among other health issues.
Omega Fats
Omega fats help your cat’s brain and eye development and allow your pet to produce a healthy and shiny coat. Omega fats also help reduce swelling, especially as your cat ages and develops arthritis.
Wet Food vs Dry Food
We have wet and dry food on our list, but we recommend dry food for most people. Dry food is less expensive, easier to store, and helps keep your cat’s teeth clean while providing a complete and balanced meal. Wet food also provides a complete meal, but it’s usually much richer than dry food and higher in calories.
The higher moisture in wet food can also cause loose stools. Wet foods are best for cats suffering from constipation or dehydration. It’s also helpful for getting cats to eat their medicine since cats prefer wet food and are likelier to eat a hidden pill.
If it’s kibble, wet, or a combination of both that your cat enjoys, choosing the right cat bowl to serve it in goes far beyond presentation. Your cat's comfort is at the forefront with the Hepper NomNom Cat Bowl! The unique design benefits cats in many ways - dual stainless steel bowls are shallow and wide to aid with whisker fatigue and slight elevation for proper posture. The wide catch tray ensures that all food (and water!) stays exactly where you’d expect it to be - inside the bowl! Click here to learn more. At Catster, we’ve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!
What to Avoid
We recommend avoiding brands with corn listed as the first ingredient because they can cause weight gain. Meat by-products can be a great way to increase protein, but they shouldn’t be the first ingredient, and we recommend avoiding foods with artificial colors and preservatives, especially for food you intend to serve long term.
How We Selected Our List of Grocery Store Cat Foods
Catster has an experienced, expert team of writers, editors, and veterinarians who carefully consider a wide range of parameters when choosing the cat foods. This includes but is not limited to customer reviews, brand reputation, veterinary experience, hands-on testing, and of course, our cats have a say in the process too! We aim to select and review only the best products available, to help you make the best possible choice and most informed decision for your and your cat’s needs.
Why Trust Catster?
A trusted online brand since 2001, Catster has a lot of experience with cat foods. Our team of cat-loving writers, editors, and veterinarians is dedicated to helping you make the best decision for your precious cats. Our aim is to provide the best information available for cat owners to help cats live their best life possible. To do this, we scour reviews from the most trusted sources available and this, combined with our veterinary team’s experience and expertise, helps us gather the best options available to readers. Our team is deeply invested in the health and welfare of cats the world over, and believes that expert knowledge and veterinary guidance will help you make the right choices—for you and your cats!
Conclusion
When choosing your next grocery store cat food, we highly recommend our pick for the best overall. Blue Buffalo Indoor Health Natural Adult Dry Cat Food has all-natural ingredients and doesn’t contain any harmful preservatives or dyes. It’s formulated for indoor cats and contains LifeSource Bits, which are vitamins and minerals that help boost your cat’s immune system.
If you have a lot of mouths to feed and need something inexpensive, our pick for the best value is a wise choice. 9 Lives Daily Essentials provides your cats with a high-protein diet at a reasonable price.
We hope you have enjoyed reading this guide and that it has helped answer your questions. If we have helped you improve your cat’s diet, please share this guide to the best grocery store cat foods on Facebook and Twitter.
Featured Image Credit: catinrocket, Shutterstock
