Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Do I Have a Finicky Cat? Is a Finicky Eater a Behavior Issue? (Vet-Reviewed)

cat-near-food-bowl-with-food-at-home

Cats can seem like mysterious creatures and exhibit behaviors that make no sense to us. If your cat is healthy but turns their nose up at some types of food, you likely have a finicky cat!

With healthy cats, picky eating can be a matter of taste and a battle of wills.

However, there are reasons why your cat may be refusing certain foods, and ensuring they have a clean bill of health is your priority. Picky eating can be a behavioral issue, but it’s usually due to your cat’s preferences. The wide variety of foods available has made finicky eating less common, but some cats still refuse to eat their meals.

divider cat paws oct 2024

 

What Is Finicky Eating?

Finicky eating is being choosy over food. Your cat may refuse their food for no reason after eating it a few times or may only like a specific brand and type. This can present a problem for owners since they want their cats to get enough to eat, and it can get expensive if they have to change their food often and waste it.

Grey domestic cat being given food in a bowl
Image Credit: Valeri Vatel, Shutterstock

Is My Cat A Finicky Eater?

One important distinction to make is that an overfed cat may refuse a meal simply because they are not hungry; this does not make them a finicky eater. A finicky eater will eat less than the ideal amount of calories per day while an overfed cat will eat more.

The first thing to look at is how much your cat actually consumes per day. Measure how much food is put out each day and how much is left to give you an idea of how much they are eating. Most commercial foods will have a feeding guide of how much a cat should eat per day based on their weight. Remember that you should subtract the calories from any treats or other foods from this guide.

If your cat is eating roughly the recommended amount, or more, they are not a finicky eater. The feeding guide is a rough guide as the metabolism and activity level of every cat is different. Your cat’s body condition score should also guide you as to whether they need more or less calories.

What Causes Finicky Eating?

Some picky cats don’t like the texture, size, or flavor of the food, and their owners must experiment with different formulas to determine which type their cats prefer. Cats who enjoy human food or table scraps can also become picky since they prefer it over cat food.

It can be very tempting to give your cat treats when they’re not eating their food, but it can exacerbate the problem and make it harder to transition them back to feline foods.

Training a cat with treats
Photo Credit: Svetlana Rey, Shutterstock

divider cat paws oct 2024

What Other Reasons Are There for Finicky Eating?

If your cat starts refusing food in any way, you must take them to your vet’s office for an examination. There are many reasons why your cat may not be eating their food, and each can show different signs.

If your cat eats certain textures of food but refuses others, there could be problems with their teeth. For example, periodontal disease or mouth lesions can cause pain. Dry food can be particularly difficult and painful for cats to eat if they have problems with their teeth, and it could be the reason why they’re refusing their dry food but eating wet food.

Your cat may also begin to refuse food if they have digestive discomfort. This usually comes with other signs of illness, such as vomiting, diarrhea or gas, but a visit to the vet is in order, even if you don’t notice other signs.

Finally, cats who have problems with their sense of smell or feel sick may not want to eat as much. Cats cannot taste food if they can’t smell, so if something is blocking their nose (such as mucus or a mass), they can stop eating altogether.

Veterinarian checks teeth to a big maine coon cat at vet clinic
Image Credit: Ermolaev Alexander, Shutterstock

divider cat paws oct 2024

What Should I Do to Stop Finicky Eating?

There are a few ways you can address your cat’s finicky eating after the vet has cleared them. First, you can change the way you feed your cat. Cats eat small meals often in the wild, and your feline may not want to eat large portions.

You can feed your cat in the morning and leave the food out for around 30 minutes. Then, you can take it away until the next meal; your cat will learn that if they don’t eat when the food is available, they’ll not be able to until later!

This can be difficult with wet food since you have to remove uneaten portions so they don’t spoil. So, you can serve smaller portions until your cat is eating better to avoid waste. Offer more meals throughout the day at the start, around four or five, to ensure your cat gets enough calories.

If your cat likes a particular taste or texture, it’s best to identify it and stick with it. This will (most likely) help your cat eat more and save money on wasted food!

woman-feeding-cats
Image Credit: Dora Zett, Shutterstock

Can I Stop Feeding My Cat for a Short Time?

It’s unhealthy and dangerous to stop feeding your cat completely. Although cats typically eat when they’re hungry, a stubborn cat or cat with other health issues can get very sick from extended periods without food.

For example, cats with medical conditions can develop hepatic lipidosis in a short amount of time without food, which can be fatal. Healthy, picky eaters may refuse a meal initially, but most won’t starve themselves and eventually eat their food.

Determining which type they prefer by experimenting with different formulas is vital to helping them find one they like. However, when a cat doesn’t eat because of a health issue, they need veterinary assistance to get them back to a regular eating schedule.

Need veterinary advice but can't get to the clinic? Catster recommends PangoVet, our online veterinary service. Talk to a vet online and get the answers and advice you need for your cat without having to leave your living room — all at an affordable price!

PangoVet_Mention-in-Content for PangoVet2 save money

divider cat paws oct 2024

Conclusion

If your cat is fussy but healthy, you can provide several formulas for them to sample until you find one they like. However, it’s essential to rule out any health problems before making changes to their diet.

You can do a few things to remedy finicky eating, including changing your cat’s feeding routine and sticking to one type of food. Ultimately, some cats are just particular, and it takes trial and error to determine which cat food is best for them.


Featured Image Credit: Pixel Shot, Shutterstock

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

How To Keep Possums Away from Cat Food: 11 Great Ways

Possums are a common problem for pet owners. No one likes to find a possum raiding their cat’s food bowl. They are attracted...

Why Does My Cat Try to Climb Walls? 4 Vet Reviewed Causes & What To Do

Cats are mysterious creatures. Their independent and secretive nature makes them quite fascinating. They also have a unique set of behaviors that make...

Are Cats Territorial About Their Litter Box? Our Vet Explains

If you know anything about caring for cats, you’ll know that toileting habits are a particularly important aspect of feline husbandry. Cats will...

Why Does a Comb Make a Cat Gag? Vet-Reviewed Facts & FAQ

Maybe you have seen the videos online or experienced this yourself at home: you flick the teeth of a comb, and your cat...

More related

Can Cats Eat Crickets? Vet Approved Health Facts & Precautions

We all know that our cats are carnivorous beasts hidden in cute bodies. Cats are obligate carnivores, which means the majority of their...

Most Popular Cat Names That Start With O: From Fun to Outrageous

Congratulations on the new addition to your family! Adopting a new kitten is an exciting time full of wonder and opportunities. It seems...

How Much Does Cat Asthma Treatment Cost? 2025 Update

Just like people, cats can suffer from asthma. This is a narrowing of the airways and swelling of the lungs, making it difficult...

When to Take Your Cat to an Emergency Vet: 6 Signs It’s Urgent (Vet Answer)

Cats have an innate ability to hide when they are sick and/or injured until the situation has become severe. In addition, because many...

Keep reading

10 Best Dry Kitten Foods (2025) – Reviews & Top Picks

Growing kittens need the right mix of nutrients, minerals, and vitamins to thrive, and the dry food you choose to feed these developing felines is an important choice. This stage of growth and development will set the stage for the...

two kittens eating cat food_shutterstock_MaraZe

Can I Put Catnip in My Cat’s Food? Vet-Reviewed Potential Pros & Cons

People are always looking for ways to improve their cat’s life and diet, and one thing that often gets paired with cats is catnip. But whether you’re looking at putting catnip in their food for health purposes or just want...

cat-eating-catnip

Will My Cat Eat My Guinea Pig? Risks, Safety Tips & FAQ (Vet-Verified)

If you’re a cat person who is interested in becoming a guinea pig person or vice versa, you may be wondering if it’s safe to bring the two together. Do cats eat guinea pigs? The good news is that many...

light brown guinea pig in cage enclosure with food

Can You Be Allergic to Some Cats & Not Others? Vet-Reviewed Facts & FAQ

Cat allergies can be a real bummer, especially if you’re a cat lover hoping to introduce a cat to your home. There are things you can do on your side to minimize the effects of your allergies, like taking medications...

woman with cat allergy

Why Do Cats Rub Their Faces on You? 3 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

A cat rubbing their face on you is one of the highest compliments you can receive from your furball, and it’s seriously adorable to boot. This behavior is called “bunting,” and it’s a common way cats greet their human companions,...

Gray cat licking owners face

What Is High-Rise Syndrome? Cat Balcony Safety Explained

Cats have a way of turning a clumsy fall into a graceful landing by hitting the ground on all fours with their dignity well intact. While it’s true that they have a natural ability to position themselves during a fall...

cat sitting on the roof

How Does a Cat Neutering Procedure Work? Vet-Reviewed Facts & Care Tips

A neuter procedure is the surgical removal of a male cat’s testicles. Reading that definition might make you cringe. You may even question if the procedure is worth it. It’s not something you or your cat enjoys, but it comes...

cat neutered

Messy Mutts Messy Cats Interactive Slow Feeder Review 2025: A Detailed Look

If you have a tubby tabby or a food-obsessed Felix, you’ve probably considered using a slow feeder. But finding an effective, quality slow feeder that works for cats can be tricky. I know, I’ve been searching for one for my...

Messy Mutts Messy Cats Interactive Slow Feeder