Make the Diet Switcheroo Safe for Your Cat

Finicky Cat
Last Updated on December 6, 2019 by Bridget Shirvell

Vomiting. Diarrhea. Stomach pain. If you abruptly switch your cat’s diet, you may unintentionally cause your cat to experience one, two or all three of these reactions. Feline tummies can be sensitive, especially if changes are quickly made to your cat’s food in terms of brands, flavors and form (kibble, canned or freeze-dried).

During a cat’s lifetime, dietary changes occur as they leave kittenhood, merge into adulthood and, eventually, reach senior status. Some cats need to transition to new foods after being adopted from local animal shelters. Others may develop diseases, such as hyperthyroidism or diabetes, that may require that they eat specific therapeutic diets. And announcements of food recalls may panic some pet owners to quickly put their cats on what they perceive to be safer commercial brands. So how do you make a food switch safely for your cat’s sake?

“Any changes in diet need to be gradual,” says Kathryn Primm, DVM, owner of the Applebrook Animal Hospital in Ooltewah, Tennessee, and host of the Nine Lives with Dr. Kat and the Dr. Kat Gone to the Dogs podcast shows on Pet Life Radio. “Cats process stress in different ways, and a sudden change in diet can be a big deal to many felines. That’s because you can cause an imbalance of bacteria in the gut and cause your cat to vomit or have diarrhea or hairballs.”

Sean Delaney, DVM, board-certified veterinary nutritionist and founder of the Davis Veterinary Medical Consulting, Inc. in Davis, California, offers this insight into how cats digest foods.

“Sudden increases in dietary fat, moisture and fiber are the most likely to cause GI (gastrointestinal) upset even in healthy adult cats,” Dr. Delaney says. “Thus, switching to canned food suddenly from dry food might be more challenging than switching to another
dry food with a comparable fat and crude fiber level.”

Making the change

Many veterinarians support what is informally known as the 3-3-3 rule when it comes to safely switching your cat to a new food in any form. In general, they recommend that for the first few days, you give your cat two-thirds of his current food mixed in with
one-third of the new food. During the next three days, switch the amounts to one-third of your cat’s current food and two-thirds of the new food. Within seven to 10 days, most feline digestive systems are ready to receive meals consistently completely of the new food.

“The bacteria in a cat’s gut can be pretty picky,” Dr. Primm adds. “You may want to consult your veterinarian about supplementing your cat’s diet with probiotics and prebiotics to ensure there is a bacteria balance that is a key to your cat’s overall well-being.”

Making the right choice

When selecting food for your new or current cat, Dr. Delaney says to shop not by price. He recommends seeking out brands with reputations for safety and food quality.

“Generally, I prefer to use foods from known and established manufacturers with a good track record and at least one full-time nutritionist,” he says. “The four ‘must-have’ ingredients in cat food are animal protein/meat, minerals, vitamins and taurine. And, definitely, please speak to your veterinarian about your cat’s specific nutritional needs.”

how to switch your cat's food
Your cat will appreciate you shopping for food by seeking out brands with reputations for safety and quality. Next, the must-have ingredients in your cat’s food are animal protein (meat), minerals, vitamins and taurine.

And if your cat has been diagnosed with hyperthyroidism or diabetes, your veterinarian may recommend that you switch your cat to a therapeutic diet. Most of the time, the switch should follow the 3-3-3 rule, but there are medical exceptions.

“If the current food is making the feline patient ill actively (such as a food allergy), a sudden and immediate change is done knowing that GI upset might be a side effect but likely not worse than what is already occurring,” Dr. Delaney says. “Your veterinarian will
help guide the speed of transition as well as prescribe any concurrent medications (such as anti-inflammatory
or immunosuppressive drugs) to help ease the process.”

The main takeaway: Gradually introducing new food to your cat may minimize unwanted diarrhea, vomiting and stomach issues.

Kittens — from formula to solid food

At the SPCA of Texas with campuses in Dallas and McKinney, Kelly Garner is in charge of diets and more as the shelter intake supervisor. With kitten season typically running from April to September, she also needs to pay special attention to rescued kittens who need to transition from bottle-feeding to kitten food. Young kittens let her know when they are ready to transition from formula to food.

“We get kittens from a few days old to under 1 week of age and, in general, they stay on bottles three to six weeks,” Kelly says. “When a kitten starts to bite the bottle nipple and the baby canine teeth are showing, we will put a bowl with formula and wet food in front of them. Some go to town on this food mix and others still need to be bottle fed on formula. With young kittens, they can easily get diarrhea from changes in diet and lose weight, so we monitor them closely.”

how to switch your cat's food

By 6 weeks of age and 1 pound of weight, most kittens sport all their baby teeth. Even at that young age, some show food preferences for canned food or kibble. “We always make sure wet food is available to them, because at this age they can get dehydrated so easily if they prefer to eat dry food,” Kelly says.

When the kittens are healthy and old enough to be adopted, the SPCA of Texas staff provides pet parents with take-home supplies of their kitten’s current food. The staff also educates new adopters on how to gradually and safely transition their new felines to other commercial brands.

Read Next: How Much Should I Feed My Cat?

About the Author

Arden Moore
Arden Moore
Arden Moore, The Pet Health and Safety Coach, is a pet behavior consultant, master certified pet first aid instructor, author and host of two shows: Arden Moore’s Four Legged Life national radio show and a podcast called the Oh Behave Show on Pet Life Radio. Learn more at

4 thoughts on “Make the Diet Switcheroo Safe for Your Cat”

  1. What do you do when your cat is picky and refuses to eat current food- or prescription food from the vet- and you have to change? She will happily eat a certain food- brand/flavor for a few days or weeks and then decide- NOPE, I am not eating this ANYMORE! I have wasted more money on food because she up and decides she does not like a food she was been eating before. thankfully I found a woman who feeds the ferals and I give her the food my cat won’t it.

    1. I’ve had my cat for 7 years since was a kitten. I have changed her foods over and over. I’ve both wet and dry foods that Ai thought was heathy for her and she throws it up. I don’t know what to do. She drinks a lot of water, thank goodness. What should I do? She runs when she sees the carrier to take her to the vet. What should I do?

  2. Pingback: Make the Diet Switcheroo Safe for Your Cat – Pet Grooming And Pet Care

  3. Pingback: Make the Food plan Switcheroo Secure for Your Cat – Cute funny cat kitten pictures videos

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Catster in your inbox!

Stay informed! Get tips and exclusive deals.

Current Issue

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
Error: No posts found. Make sure this account has posts available on


Follow Us

Shopping Cart