10 Best Tasting Cat Foods for Picky Cats in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

It’s no secret that our cats love dinnertime. It’s arguably their favorite part of the day! But some cats are a little on the harder-to-please side. Maybe they are spoiled by wet cat food, or they just don’t like the new kibble they have in their dish.

Regardless, if you have a picky little cat on your hands that makes you want to pull your hair out—we have a few options we think might turn the tables. Hopefully, our reviews have a recipe that wins the approval of your picky kitty.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2025

The 10 Best Tasting Cat Foods for Picky Eaters

1. Smalls Fresh Ground Bird Recipe – Best Overall

If you’re looking for the best overall best-tasting cat food for picky cats, we have to go with the Smalls Fresh Ground Bird Recipe. Smalls is human-grade cat food designed to give your cat a more natural diet with less processing.

We chose the chicken recipe because most cats love chicken, but if your cat doesn’t like chicken, or is allergic, Smalls also has other recipes you can try including turkey, pork, and salmon flavors. Smalls food is also easy to digest and free of preservatives and artificial ingredients.

All you have to do is go on the website, answer a few questions about your cat, and they’ll tailor your cat’s meals just for them. We have to say that it is a subscription service and it can get a little pricey due to the nature of the food. But if you have a picky cat and you have the budget for it, they’re sure to love this food.

---

2. Weruva Cats in the Kitchen Variety Pack – Budget Buy

If you’re on a budget, try out Weruva Cats in the Kitchen. It is the perfect way to spruce up boring kibble or use as a standalone diet. It has two servings in portion trays so you can keep your cat under close watch with their consumption.

This particular pack of cat food is grain-free. It’s a variety pack, so you can try out the six different flavors until you find out which ones your cat likes best, and then order only those flavors. The downside of this is that picky cats may not like all the flavors in the variety pack. But we think it’s the best-tasting cat food for picky cats for the money.

---

3. Fussie Cat Market Fresh Dry Cat Food

Another good cat food for picky cats is the Fussie Cat Market Fresh Dry Cat Food. This recipe is crafted with guinea fowl, which is an incredibly fantastic recipe, especially for protein, sensitive cats. This recipe delivers very high-quality protein, with added turkey, and that nourishes the system.

This particular recipe is completely gluten-free, so it is designed with your feline in mind. It is 100% free of any fish or chicken, so cats with common dietary restrictions can enjoy! It contains helpful ingredients like taurine and antioxidants, using a bounty of delicious fruits and vegetables.

Ultimately, this is a very wholesome recipe that it will not be triggering to any feline with allergies, for the most part. Ultimately, we think that the canalizing temptation of the protein will draw your cat in, making even the pickiest cat salivate.

Keep in mind this recipe is designed for certain food sensitivities, so it is perfect for those houses that have different kinds of personalities and dietary restrictions. However, it does come in traditional flavors as well, such as chicken and salmon. It’s a little on the expensive side, but it is made with premium ingredients, so that’s to be expected.

---

4. Applaws Complete Kitten Dry Cat Food – Best for Kittens

If you have a picky kitten on your hands, you definitely want to make sure they’re getting a good start in life. If your cat is deprived of necessary nutrients when they are young, it can impact them later, adding to unnecessary vet bills, and other health issues—so try Applaws Complete Kitten Dry Cat Food.

This particular recipe was crafted with complex carbohydrate sources like peas, chickpeas, lentils, and flaxseed. These ingredients replace other more difficult to digest carbs, and also make sure that the system is running smoothly, so it really helps with their digestive tract.

This is a high-quality protein recipe with chicken and chicken meal being the first ingredients. This recipe was made without the use of artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. It is also green free with no potatoes, corn, wheat, or soy. So, if your little one has a sensitive tummy, it really is the perfect recipe!

---

5. Sheba Perfect Portions

When it comes to your picky cat, they might love the scrumptious ingredients in Sheba Perfect Portions. It’s affordable and comes with 3 different flavors, making it our pick for the best overall best-tasting cat food for picky cats.

If you have a kitty that’s partial to fish, you will really steal their heart with these seafood recipes! This particular pack of cat food is made of delicious ingredients without added grain, corn, wheat, soy, artificial flavors, or preservatives.

It has two servings in portion trays so you can keep your cat under close watch with their consumption. These recipes also contain wholesome protein from salmon, trout, and sustainable tuna.

What’s really cool about Sheba is that they work with ocean protection organizations to ensure all of their ingredients are responsibly sourced. Ultimately, it is a complete and balanced recipe that any cat will be grateful to have in their food bowl.

---

6. Tiki Cat Born Carnivore High Protein

If your cat could use a little extra protein in their diet, we have to recommend the Tiki Cat Carnivore High Protein Cat Food. It is made of real deboned chicken, chicken meal, herring, salmon meal, herring meal, and dried egg product.

Talk about a real protein cocktail! This particular recipe was made using only non-GMO ingredients. It is also free from any artificial colors and flavors, so you can feel good about what you put in your kitty’s food bowl. In total, this recipe contains over 43% protein with 80% of that directly from animal sources.

This is a very species-specific recipe that can give your cat a more natural diet. Ultimately, we think that you will be totally happy with the ingredients and your kitty will love the taste!

---

7. Made By Nacho Bone Broth Infused Dry Cat Food

This Made By Nacho recipe is a well-thought-out formula that supports healthy digestion and overall nutrition. It contains premium cage-free, chicken, duck, and quail! So, your cat can enjoy a wide variety of protein that is tantalizing to the taste buds.

This particular cat food contains dehydrated bone broth to deliver flavor and additional nutrients. It also contains both prebiotics and probiotics to support your cat’s natural gut microbiome.

This formula contains omega fatty acids, DHA, antioxidants, and a bounty of other nutrients. It also contains pumpkin to soothe digestion for those kitties who have an upset tummy after eating. Ultimately, we think that this is an extremely exceptional recipe that will delight, despite their level.

---

8. Rawz Dehydrated Dry Cat Food

Rawz Dehydrated Dry Cat Food is a great way to introduce new flavors onto the menu. It combines the power of amazing raw diets with the long shelf-life of dry kibble. This particular recipe is 100% nutritionally complete—perfect for all life stages.

There is no rendered meat in this recipe. It is also free of gum and additives to create a fresher, more species-specific recipe without the extras. Each batch is gently cooked in small batches to ensure that the ingredients stay nutrient-rich.

This kitty food contains all the right type of protein to attract even the pickiest of cats. You can even add broth to rehydrate and revitalize the recipe. However, food like this tends to be more expensive, and Rawz is no exception.

---

9. Friskies Shreds in Gravy

Friskies Shreds in Gravy can be your secret weapon to get your kitty to eat the most boring of kibbles. You can toss it on top of any dry kibble as a topper or serve it as a standalone meal—whichever you prefer! One thing is for sure, Friskies knows taste!

These recipes combine a sampler of four flavors: beef and gravy, turkey and cheese dinner, chicken and salmon, and ocean whitefish and tuna. Each comes drenched in a highly palpable sauce that is sure to lure any lurking feline.

In total, there are 40 cans, so it will be a while before replacement, too. These recipes are completely balanced, high in protein, and versatile for a great result every time. However, it might not match the needs of all allergy restrictions—so check labels!

These cans provide plenty of new aromas and textures. We think most picky felines will flock to the food bowl, but only your kitty can be the real tester.

---

10. Stella & Chewy Chick Chick Chicken Dinner Morsels

Appealing to your cat’s tastebuds might be tough, but it’s manageable with Stella & Chewy’s Chick Chick Chicken Dinner Morsels. Combining the power of raw animal protein and a bounty of other ingredients, your cat can’t resist.

This isn’t the only recipe, either! There is also Duck Duck Goose, Sealicious Salmon and Cod, and Tummy Ticklin’ Turkey, among other flavors. So, you can choose from an assortment of protein sources—or try them all for good measure!

This recipe contains chicken with ground bone and chicken liver to deliver a wallop of protein in every bite. This freeze-dried product can be rehydrated to add even more flavor. Each morsel is 100% certified-organic without the use of fillers, grains, or artificial additives.

What’s not to love?

Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Tasting Cat Food for Picky Cats

When you’re investing in a food that will make your kitty happy (finally), you’ll want it to be well worth your money. So, here are a few categories to check off your list when shopping.

Type of Food

You have a couple different options when it comes to the type of food you want to get your cat. Of course, there’s always dry kibble and wet, canned food options, such as those that we have on our list.

But there are other exceptional options as well, such as fresh or raw food. Fresh food typically comes on a subscription-based service based on your cat’s need straight to your door!

Raw food takes a little bit more careful consideration, and definitely veterinary approval before you serve. However, these two options tend to be a little bit more feline specific and healthy for your kitty counterpart.

Recipe

The recipe matters! There are certain ingredients that our kitties either really don’t like or shouldn’t have. If your cat snubs their nose at many of the common recipes on the market, you can always try to get something different to see if it curbs their appetite.

Often, families get different recipes to mix together, such as adding fresh or wet canned food on top of dry kibble. This really spruces up the palette, increasing their appetite.

Flavor

Flavor matters! After all, every finicky cat needs something aromatic and delicious! If they have a boring dry kibble, that really isn’t cutting the mustard, it might be best to get them a wet canned or fresh food option that’s really going to ignite the appetite.

Palatable Qualities

You always want to get easily digestible ingredients in your cat food. Selecting a recipe that will be easy on the belly can ensure that not only they stay interested, but it aids digestion as well. Some cats also need a recipe that is easy to chew, so wet canned food works better in these scenarios.

Price

Price matters! Even though your kitty wants something tastier, you also have a budget! Always make sure to sample foods that are within your price range. That way, if your cat gives a paws up, you can keep buying the same recipe to appease them.

Quality

You definitely want to make sure the recipe you choose is a quality source. All the ingredients should be traceable, and you should avoid potentially irritating additives.

Ingredient Content

Take a quick look at the ingredients. Are there multiple protein sources? If so, it might be a really good idea to try it out. Cats are obligate carnivores and protein will be the most important ingredient in the entire formula. Also, look for broths, liver, and other organ meats, as this will increase attraction.

Our Tasting Cat Foods for Picky Cats Selection Process

Catster’s dedicated team of writers and editors collaborate with expert veterinarians, considering a wide range of factors when selecting the best foods for cats. These parameters include customer reviews, brand reputation, veterinary experience, and in some cases, hands-on testing. Of course, our cats have a say in the process, too! We strive to select and review the highest-quality products available, to help you choose the best possible product and make the most informed decision for your and your cat’s needs.

Why Trust Catster?

Catster has been a trusted online brand since 2001, so we know a thing or two about cat foods. We’re a team of cat-loving writers, editors, and veterinarians dedicated to helping you make the most informed decision for your feline. We deeply believe in providing the best information for cat owners to help their cats live their best life possible. We look at reviews from the most trusted sources available, and this, combined with our veterinary team’s experience and expertise, helps us gather the best options on the market. Our team is invested in the welfare and health of cats around the world, and believe that expert knowledge is one of the best ways to achieve this.

Conclusion

Smalls is our big for the best overall choice for picky cats. These meals are tailored to your cat, and there are several different flavors available.

Weruva Cats in the Kitchen is pretty affordable, well-crafted, and easy to digest! Plus, it makes a wonderful topper to spruce up boring meals.

Fussie Cat Market Fresh Dry Cat Food is designed for sensitive and picky cats—so it’s our premium choice.

We loved the results! Ultimately, it is your choice to try out, and your cat’s choice to enjoy. However, we hope our reviews have given you some amazing options that will work for any appetite.

Related Reads:

• Best Grain Free Cat Foods – Reviews & Top Picks
• Best Cat Foods for Picky Cats in the UK: Reviews & Top Picks

---

Featured Image Credit: LightField Studios, Shutterstock