Next to cat food, kitty litter is one of the most important things that you need when you own a cat. Adding it to your shopping list is all well and good, but the boxes can be unwieldy and heavy, especially when you have other groceries to get. Your local store might not have your preferred brand either, which can make both you and your cat unhappy.
Cat litter subscriptions save you from lifting heavy boxes and remembering kitty litter during your shopping trip. They also save time if you run out of litter before your weekly grocery run. These reviews are the seven best cat litter subscription services. We hope that they’ll help you decide whether a subscription for cat litter is right for you and which one to choose.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2024
|Kitty Poo Club Subscription Service
|Click to Save 35%
|Really Great Cat Litter by Tuft and Paw
|Best for Kittens
The 7 Best Cat Litter Subscriptions
1. Kitty Poo Club Cat Litter Subscription — Best Overall
|Diatomite, silica crystals, clay, soy
Cleaning the plastic litter tray when you change out old litter is a job that all cat owners hate. Kitty Poo Club tackles this by sending out litter with a disposable litter tray once a month. The litter and tray don’t require any special shipment packaging and only require setting up once it arrives.
You can choose diatomite, silica crystals, clay, or soy litter, depending on the preferences of you and your cat. A few of the more expensive plans have bonus accessories, like cat litter scoops, litter mats, and litter box domes. It’s the overall best cat litter subscription.
Since the one litter box and one bag of litter are designed for one cat, Kitty Poo Club can get expensive for multi-cat houses.
2. Chewy Autoship — Best Value
|Varies by brand
|Set by you
|Varies by brand
Although it’s not a cat litter-oriented company, Chewy Autoship enables you to keep track of all the supplies that you need for your cat, including their kitty litter. As an online pet store, Chewy gives you access to more litter types and brands than other subscription services, making it the best cat litter subscription for the money.
Unlike other kitty litter subscriptions, Chewy Autoship doesn’t require a membership fee, and you can receive deliveries as often as you want. It’s also easy to cancel if you no longer need the supplies.
While it’s cheaper than many other options, Chewy doesn’t have free shipping unless your order is over a certain amount.
3. Really Great Cat Litter by Tuft and Paw — Premium Choice
|Monthly or quarterly
If you don’t mind spending more, the Really Great Cat Litter by Tuft and Paw enables you to adjust the amount of litter that you get depending on monthly or quarterly shipments and how many cats you have.
Made with soybean fiber, Really Great Cat Litter is sustainable and completely biodegradable, so you can do your part to lower your carbon footprint. This litter is designed to clump while remaining dust free and reduces litter tracking when your cat leaves the tray. It’s also flushable to help save you from using plastic bags to dispose of used litter.
The Tuft and Paw subscription is one of the most expensive options on this list, especially for quarterly shipments. You should also make sure local regulations allow you to flush kitty litter before doing so.
4. Litterbox.com — Best for Kittens
|Monthly or quarterly
Made with natural clay that’s fragrance-free, Litterbox is designed with sodium bentonite clay to lock in odors and form tight clumps. This keeps the litter box smelling fresh and reduces the amount of litter that your cat uses.
Unlike crystal litter, clay litter is soft on delicate paws, and Litterbox makes its litter with low levels of dust by sun-drying the clay during processing. The orders are shipped for free to your door and are customizable depending on how often you want to receive shipments — monthly or quarterly — and how many cats you own.
Litterbox only has clay litter available, and it may take a while to transition your cat to clay litter if they’re familiar with another type.
5. Catalyst Pet
Catalyst Pet lets you try its litter without opting into its subscription plan. It’s slightly more expensive than the plan fee, but you can introduce your cat to a new type of litter without tying yourself into a monthly subscription.
There are three types of litter formulas: Healthy Cat, Unscented, and Multi-cat. All of them are lightweight to save you from carrying around heavy bags and are dust free to prevent litter tracking.
While the hard-clumping formula helps make plastic litter boxes easier to clean, it’s unsuitable for litter robots or other automatic litter trays.
|Silica gel crystals
Your cat might take a while to get used to silica crystals if they’re not already familiar with the litter, but it can mean less work cleaning your cat’s litterbox. PrettyLitter is a monthly subscription service that can be customized for single or multiple-cat households and relies on silica gel litter to keep your litter box lightweight and odorless. Silica crystals are also more absorbent than other litter types, which means you will scoop out the poop and clean out the tray less often.
Cats are notorious for hiding their health issues, and PrettyLitter can help you monitor their well-being. The silica crystals are designed to change color depending on the moisture that it absorbs, which can let you know whether your cat has any underlying health concerns that need addressing.
While PrettyLitter is affordable for single-cat households, families with several cats may find this subscription expensive. It only offers silica gel litter.
|Coconut, non-clumping, clumping
For cats and cat lovers who prefer their cat litter to be 100% natural, CatSpot is made with organic coconut. The use of coconut makes this litter lightweight, dust free, and hypoallergenic. Odorless and highly absorbent, CatSpot is designed to last longer than most other litters. It’s completely biodegradable and can be composted or used in your yard if your local regulations allow it. To suit the preferences of you and your cat, CatSpot has two formulas available: non-clumping and clumping.
Unfortunately, CatSpot only offers the coconut litter option, and your cat may dislike the litter if they’re used to another type. Some subscribers have also had issues with the bag breaking open during shipment.
Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Cat Litter Subscription
There’s more to choosing a cat litter subscription than just comparing them. Understanding what each service offers, how it benefits you, and how to choose the best one for your needs is essential if you want to make the most of your subscription. Here are a few frequently asked questions about these subscription services to help you out.
What Are Cat Litter Subscriptions?
Cat litter subscriptions work on the same principle as food or toy subscriptions. The company that you subscribe to sends a bag or box of litter to your door once a month or quarterly, depending on the service that they offer. This automated shipment means you’ll most likely always have cat litter on hand and won’t need to carry heavy boxes of the litter around your local supermarket.
Some subscription services send their litter in disposable litter boxes to save you from icky cleanups. A few offer bonuses for first-time cat owners too, with free poop scoops and litter mats.
How Do I Choose a Cat Litter Subscription Service?
There are many things to consider when you choose a subscription service, whether it’s for food, cat litter, or something else. More than anything, you need to make sure it’s suitable for you and your cat — or cats, if you have more than one. Here are a few important factors to consider before you decide which cat litter subscription is the best for you.
Not all cat litter subscriptions offer bonuses in their plans, but any special accessories can be a lifesaver, especially when you’re a new cat owner with limited supplies. Some subscription services include a free litter box with your first order or send each shipment with a disposable litter box that you don’t need to clean out when you replace the litter. Others even have accessories, like litter mats to prevent litter tracking or poop scoops to make clean-up easy.
Overall, the cost is one of the most important things to consider when it comes to subscription services.
In general, litter subscriptions are more expensive than running to the grocery store, but the litter also tends to be higher quality and the company is more likely to have it in stock. The price between services can also vary, and you should weigh the pros and cons of each subscription that you look at before settling on a final decision.
Adjusting the plan to suit the two, three, or more cats you have in your household will push the price up more, although some services do offer discounts for multi-cat households.
You should also consider the shipping cost. These can vary from free to a minimum-order limit and a standard shipping charge, depending on the subscription service that you choose.
There are all sorts of cat litters available, but not all subscription services offer them. Some specialize in silica gel crystals — like PrettyLitter — or only have a small selection of different types — like Kitty Poo Club.
The type of litter that you and your cat prefer should point you toward the subscription service that’s right for you. One with more of a selection might also be the best choice, just in case your cat decides that they dislike the current litter that you’re using.
This is where Chewy Autoship wins. With its broad range of brands and litter types available, you can switch when you need to and still benefit from the service.
Single or Multi-cat Household
Along with changing the price of the service that you choose, the number of cats in your household determines how much litter you’ll go through in a month. It may also determine which service you go for if all your cats prefer different litter types. In this case, a service that offers several types of litter will benefit you more than one with a limited selection.
How Do I Choose the Right Cat Litter?
For first-time cat owners, choosing the right cat litter can be a challenge. How do you choose between clumping and non-clumping or between clay and silica crystals? The answer often comes down to personal preference for both you and your cat. You have to find a happy balance between a litter that’s easy for you to clean up and one that your cat is happy using.
Crystal litter might be a good match for your automatic litter box, but if your cat is used to softer litter, they’ll avoid the sharp edges and do their business elsewhere.
If you’ve got several cats, cat litter is most likely to be one of the supplies that you go through quite quickly. These reviews introduced you to the best cat litter subscriptions to save you frequent trips to the grocery store.
Kitty Poo Club is a monthly subscription with several types of litter available to cater to cats that are particular about where they do their business. A budget option that gives you access to other supplies that your cat needs — like food and toys — and a wider range of litter types is Chewy Autoship.
Featured Image Credit: jamesjoong, Shutterstock
- A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites of 2024
- The 7 Best Cat Litter Subscriptions
- 1. Kitty Poo Club Cat Litter Subscription — Best Overall
- 2. Chewy Autoship — Best Value
- 3. Really Great Cat Litter by Tuft and Paw — Premium Choice
- 4. Litterbox.com — Best for Kittens
- 5. Catalyst Pet
- 6. PrettyLitter
- 7. CatSpot
- Buyer’s Guide: Choosing the Best Cat Litter Subscription
- What Are Cat Litter Subscriptions?
- How Do I Choose a Cat Litter Subscription Service?
- Litter Types
- Single or Multi-cat Household
- How Do I Choose the Right Cat Litter?
- Final Thoughts