Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Not So Crappy! Reframing Poop to Not Hate Cleaning Cat Litter

What comes out of a cat can be just as important and informative as the things that go in. Paying attention can help elucidate many issues!

Hi, I’m Dr. Lauren! Read my introduction to learn more about me and my two adventurous cats, Pancake and Tiller.

Poop. We all might shudder a bit when the topic arises. But touching it? Looking at it? Quantifying and qualifying it? That’s a whole different level of “eww” for many of us.

But what if we reframed these negative connotations about poo, into a positive?

This week’s article aims to provide just that insight, and show you just how your cat’s stool can be useful for indicating your cat’s health, happiness, and beyond. We often think long and hard about what goes into our cats: e.g. food- is it healthy, tasty, how often and how much should we feed…but we often spend little to no time on what is coming out of our cats. Yet it can be equally important. Let’s change that.

Pancake enjoying kibble
We tend to focus on what cats eat, but not the other end of digestion.

divider 3 paws

Rethinking Cat Poop

So, what is poop? Essentially, it’s what is leftover from eating, that the body couldn’t digest, or wanted to eliminate. In humans, poop is around 76% water, the frequency of defecation is predominantly determined by the ingestion and amount of fiber, and the average number of stool productions is around 1.2 daily.1 Though published data is sparse, it’s likely fair to say that cats are similar. Additionally, just like people, one study in cats found that there is huge variation in the length of time it takes to digest food depending on the individual.2 (Importantly, this same study found as a side note that dry pilling your cat, e.g., giving your cat a pill without food or water– led to 3 out of 17 cats having the pill stuck in their esophagus for over an hour!) But now, back to poop!

Poop also reflects the overall health of the producer. Too firm, and there may be dehydration. Too wet, and the body isn’t absorbing all the water from the stool. (Note, this is not due to an excess of water! I have had many clients over the years that tell me they stop feeding their cat wet food because their cat’s stool was too soft, or their cat had diarrhea! Nope! The colon had an issue, and couldn’t absorb the water before the stool left the body. It wasn’t the amount of water itself! And canned food is great for cats, so please don’t fall into that trap of thinking canned food causes diarrhea by containing too much water!)

Poop also reflects the amount, type and distribution of bacteria living in the digestive tract, also referred to as the microbiome. This has become a buzzword area of medicine in recent years, looking at everything from how the microbiome contributes to gut health, but also brain, kidney and heart health, as well as the immune system. And new data is continually forthcoming! For instance, a recent publication found that certain probiotic strains may significantly reduce skin allergies in certain cats. Sounds like a big deal? It is. All of this is simple, easy, side-effect-free medicine that is cost-effective, and safe. What’s not to love?

Pancake the cat sprawling on a rug
Pancake sprawling

divider 3 paws

What Is a Fecal Transplant?

Did you know that in human and feline medicine we can use something called fecal transplants to help with chronic diarrhea or other conditions? I’ve met many people who have spoken about their positive experiences with FMT: fecal microbiota transplants.

As a vet, I’ve had some amazing results in my own patients, including my first FMT patient that I’ll call Jesse, who was a 16-year-old Domestic Shorthair diabetic with many years’ history of diarrhea. His owners were ready to euthanize him after trying years of medications aimed to improve his stool, and his quality of life was poor, but a fecal transplant bought him almost an extra year- with normal stool appearing within 24 hours of his transplant.

Basically, the process is similar to blood donation—just involving a different organ. A donor cat (healthy and screened for fecal parasites) provides stool, which is then liquified and used to populate the recipient cat’s fecal tract, therefore transplanting healthy bacteria. It’s an amazingly simple, and yet effective, process. It’s not always curative for patients, but it can be a good tool in the diarrhea arsenal. Medicine can be both functional and mind-aweing, at times! The gut, quite simply, is quite simply powerful.

Pancake and Tiller spend the majority of their day sleeping
Pancake and Tiller at rest

Rules of Thumb for Cat Poop

So, where does this all leave us? Cleaning the litter box may be a drag (or litter tray, for those so inclined), but the information it can provide is proverbial gold. Here are a few rules of thumb, when it comes to feline feces:

  • Overall consistency should be pliable, but firm. Since we all like food, using a Snickers bar analogy: you should be able to deform it, but the stool should still be firm. (Hopefully no one is eating lunch or dessert while reading this!)
  • Color: a light to dark brown. Black can indicate digested blood. I’ve also had clients start new foods that led to color changes in their cat’s feces. A whitish color can mean a lack of pancreatic enzymes, though this is uncommon in cats.
  • Smell: highly malodorous or smelly stool may indicate an issue, such as microbiome upset. But all stool will smell to some extent- that is normal!
  • If using probiotics, use one recommended by your veterinarian. Many probiotics do not meet label claims when tested, therefore using one that actually stands up to scrutiny is important. In one study, only 2 of 25 tested probiotics actually matched product labelling.  I personally tend to use Fortiflora to start, as many cats like the taste, and it’s easy to use, in addition to meeting label claims.
  • Middening is the term for cats defecating inappropriately. In indoor cats, this means outside the litter tray. It can indicate communication about stress, or even dislike of the litter box or litter. Speak with your vet, if this is occurring. Middening should not be confused with cats that go to the tray, but defecate over the edge, or miss the box.
  • Size: Most feline feces is around the diameter of the average human finger. If it’s extremely thin, say pencil diameter, this can indicate a narrowing or stricture of the intestinal tract, and should be investigated. If it’s very large, it can indicate intestinal motility issues, and should also be mentioned to your vet.
  • Never be afraid to take photos of your cat’s stool if something doesn’t look right. Similarly, a video of them in the box can help your vet to see and share any concerns you may have!

If you need to speak with a vet but can't get to one, head over to PangoVet. It's an online service where you can talk to a vet online and get the advice you need for your pet — all at an affordable price!

PangoVet_Mention-in-Content for PangoVet2 save money

The old saying goes: it will all come out in the end. In this instance of poop, certainly, that is true. Health indicators, and gastrointestinal function, can all be assessed by looking at what your cat leaves behind. Hopefully, this sheds some new light on the daily cleaning of the box, and gives you something else to think about during the time you are cleaning, making cleaning the box both functional, and thought-provoking!

This article is a part of Dr. Lauren, Pancake, and Tiller's series.

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

8 Common Cat Spay or Neuter Surgery Complications: Our Vet Explains Important Facts

It is widely accepted that neutering (spaying or castration) is part of being a responsible feline parent. Aside from stopping urine spraying, monthly...

Can Cats Eat Lychee? Vet-Reviewed Nutritional Facts & FAQ

Cats are obligate carnivores, so they need little more than animal protein to stay happy and healthy throughout their lives. However, this is...

Single Kitten Syndrome: What Is It? Vet-Reviewed Facts & Myths

Single kitten syndrome refers to behaviors sometimes displayed by kittens adopted alone into a single-cat household or who, for whatever reason, go through...

150+ Adorable American Shorthair Cat Names in 2025

When choosing the perfect name for your American Shorthair cat, there are countless options to explore. These charming felines deserve a name that...

More related

Can Cats Eat Pringles? Vet-Reviewed Facts & FAQ

Does your cat come running every time you pop open a can of Pringles because he loves the funny-shaped potato chips? If you’re...

Can Cats Eat Sunflower Seeds? Vet-Verified Nutrition Facts & Considerations

Sunflower seeds are the edible gifts of the sunflower. Not only are they tasty, but they are nutritious and considered to be one...

Why Has My Cat Stopped Eating Dry Food But Still Eats Treats? 6 Reasons

Dry food is one of the most common foods for cats. It’s quick, easy, and affordable — depending on the brand that you...

Can Pregnant Cats Have Catnip? Vet-Verified Risks & Safety Guide

Catnip is an herb with a wide variety of uses and is most well-known for the strange behavior that it causes in cats....

Keep reading

Why Did My Cat Stop Sleeping With Me? 8 Possible Reasons & What to Do

Do you ever wonder why your cat stopped sleeping with you? It’s a question that has puzzled cat owners for years. There are many reasons this might happen, but there are also some unexpected reasons you might not have considered....

Cat sleeping

Do Cats Pee to Mark Territory? Vet-Reviewed Cat Behavior Explanation

If you’ve ever seen your cat back up to a wall, the couch, or anywhere that is a vertical surface and spray urine, it’s called urine marking or spraying. Cats indeed spray to mark their territory, especially if they are...

a white cat spraying the wooden gate

Are Scottish Folds Hypoallergenic? Allergy Care Tips & Other Breeds

The Scottish Fold is an adorable cat species known for its folded ears. They are low-maintenance and love being around humans, making them great for families with kids. Scottish Folds are smart and caring, so they’re the perfect in-house pet....

grey scottish fold sleeping

How Long Do Cat Colds Last? Causes, Signs, & Treatments

Just like us, our cats can get the sniffles here and there. Respiratory illnesses are among the most common things that can go wrong with cats, and severe cases generally require veterinary attention. So, before reading the rest of this...

tired or sick cat

How Many Muscles Does a Cat Have? Science & FAQ

If you know anything about cats, you know how athletic and graceful they can be. Their muscles help them with agility and give them extraordinary flexibility. So, you might wonder how many muscles a cat has to aid in their...

Cat muscle computer rendering

Kitten Biting: Why, How to Stop It & What Not to Do (Vet Approved)

Kittens are adorable, and getting a kitten can be a fun and exciting time for anyone. Unfortunately, one of the first things people learn is that kittens adore biting. Sometimes, kittens can bite hard, and sometimes, they seem to want...

kitten-biting-his-owner

Messy Mutts Messy Cats Interactive Slow Feeder Review 2025: A Detailed Look

If you have a tubby tabby or a food-obsessed Felix, you’ve probably considered using a slow feeder. But finding an effective, quality slow feeder that works for cats can be tricky. I know, I’ve been searching for one for my...

Messy Mutts Messy Cats Interactive Slow Feeder

How Do I Apologize to My Cat in A Way They Understand? 7 Effective Ways

After only a short time with your pet, you develop a special bond, and one of the things that makes it so special is being able to read their body language and moods. But like our relationships with those we...

sad lonely cat lying on bed