Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

It’s Crunch Time, Cyril: A Weight Loss Journey (Part 1)

We are not amused

Hi, I’m Dr. Karyn! Read my introduction to learn more about me and meet my five hilarious cats: Clutch, Cyril, Alex, Zelda, and Zazzles.

I have to stop making excuses. Calling him squishy and cuddly does not change the fact that Cyril is overweight, and it’s up to me to do something about it. One could easily accuse me of being a pot calling the kettle fat, and they’d have a fair point, but this isn’t about me. It’s about Cyril and his love affair with food.

Cyril eying off my mother's lunch
Cyril eying off my mother’s lunch

Cyril ❤️ Food

I get the impression that someone once told Cyril that being fat is what happens when you eat too much food and lounge around not exercising. So, from a very young age, he had a goal. He would become fat. No food could be left unattended, no cakes left out to cool, and our meals were eaten in a state of constant vigilance. It is because of Cyril’s voracious appetite that we came up with the idea of scatter feeding. If food was set out in bowls, Cyril would start on his, then steal mouthfuls from everyone else’s before returning to his own. Annoyingly, he had won the hearts of all the other cats and they just let him do it! Getting rid of the individual bowls and spreading their food over a larger surface stopped Cyril from being able to steal mouthfuls of food and kept all the cats at a similar eating speed.

This approach has been successful in maintaining the status quo, and Cyril hasn’t put on any more weight, but he certainly hasn’t lost any, either. At 6.6kg (14 1⁄2 lbs), and a Body Condition Score (BCS) hovering around 7-8, it is time for Cyril to shed some pounds – 4, to be exact. Being a larger-framed feline, he should ideally weigh between 4.5kg and 5kg (10-11 lbs). So now that we have a goal, we need to make a plan.

Cyril’s Weight Loss Plan

Showing Cyril the Hard Truth
Showing Cyril the Hard Truth

Losing weight is all about being in a calorie deficit – burning more energy than you put in. Simple, right? The trouble is, just like with humans, what works for one doesn’t necessarily work for all. Take our ginger cat, Alex, for example. Alex is two years younger than Cyril, is of a similar body height and length, has very similar exercise habits, and shares Cyril’s love of food. However, Alex’s BCS is around 5-6. Genetics and individual variation in metabolic rate can have a significant impact on how the body uses, loses, and stores energy, so it’s not necessarily as simple as just feeding Cyril less; I have to feed him differently.

The majority of my cats’ diet is dry kibble, which I confess, is largely because it makes feeding five cats much easier and more affordable. One downside to scatter feeding is that I can’t be certain how much each cat is consuming. However, the amount put down is less than the overall daily recommended amount, so I know that Cyril can’t be consuming significantly more food than the others, and I’m not convinced that simply separating him and feeding him less food is the right approach. He already looks for extra food between meals, and this will only get worse if I reduce his portions.

It was time to switch things up a bit.

Cyril’s current food consists mostly of a veterinary brand food for gastrointestinal health and hairball reduction, and it contains more carbohydrates than he really needs. In theory, carnivores like cats don’t need to consume any carbs, but dry cat foods include it to:

  1. improve stool quality and prevent constipation
  2. reduce costs

For Cyril’s new and improved diet, I am switching him to wet and dry formulations of Wellness Core, which are lower in fat and carbohydrates and contain more ‘whole meat’ ingredients, with fewer fillers and by-products. And unsurprisingly, all the cats LOVE it!

To start with, I will be feeding Cyril the recommended portions for a 5kg cat, then reducing after 2 weeks to a 4kg cat. The plan will be to stick to that amount until we reach his goal weight, then maintain him on a 4.5kg portion long term, making adjustments if needed.

Old Dry Food New Dry Food
Protein 36% 38%
Fat 14% 13%
Carbohydrates (Fiber) 7.4% 4.5%
Main ingredients Dehydrated poultry protein, wheat gluten, rice, vegetable fibres, maize, animal fats, Chicken 54% (Fresh Chicken 16%, Dried Chicken Protein 16%, Dehydrated Chicken 15%, Chicken Fat 4%, Hydrolysed Chicken Protein 3%), Peas 15%, Dried Potatoes, Dehydrated Turkey 4%, Beet Pulp 4%,
  Old Wet Food* New Wet Food*
Protein 8% 7%
Fat 5.6% 5.4%
Carbohydrates (Fiber) 0.24% 0.1%
Main ingredients Poultry by-products, chicken meat, maize flour, pork blood products, corn starch mixture Chicken Broth, Chicken 25%, Chicken Liver 6%, Potato Starch

*Figures are based on ‘as fed’ values, not dry matter measurements

Zelda, Clutch, Cyril and Alex enjoy a meal, whilst Ned and Fred look on sadly
Zelda, Clutch, Cyril and Alex enjoy a meal, whilst Ned and Fred look on sadly

Exercise

As you probably already know, it’s really hard to make a cat exercise, particularly indoor cats. It’s easy to take your dog for a run or a swim but not as straightforward with cats. Even those cats that walk well on a harness are usually the ones setting the pace, not their humans. Although I try not to rely on laser toys, in Cyril’s case, I decided to make an exception. He enjoys chasing the little dot but doesn’t become obsessed. I had to lock Alex away as I didn’t want him falling off the wagon.

Cyril and I committed to a 5-minute session twice daily, which was just enough to get him really moving without running out of puff. After all, I didn’t want him to overdo it and injure himself!

Exercising, appropriately, in the exercise room
Exercising, appropriately, in the exercise room

No Excuses

Now that we’ve told the world about Cyril’s weight loss plan, we are committed! And I am optimistic about our success. Click here to read my six-week update on our progress!

dr.karyn signature

This article is a part of Dr. Karyn's series with her five hilarious cats.

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

What Does the Bird Flu Pet Food Recall Mean For You & Your Cat?

You may have heard about the sad death of at least one cat after eating raw frozen cat food contaminated with the H5N1...

What’s the Cost of Chemotherapy for Cats? 2025 Price Overview

Cancer is a very serious disease in cats, and it’s one of the most common causes of death for elderly felines. Chemotherapy is...

Is Best Western Pet Friendly? (2025 Guide)

When you’re traveling but have pets, a whole new set of problems comes up. Perhaps the biggest and most important is what hotels...

Why Does My Cat Wink at Me? 3 Vet-Verified Reasons for This Behavior

If you are like most cat owners, you are regularly surprised by your cat’s behavior. Cats are rarely predictable, at least until they...

More related

How to Tell If a Stray Cat Is Pregnant? 10 Vet-Approved Signs

There are many challenges to taking in a stray cat. First, you need to make sure that they’re healthy and uninjured. Second, you...

20 Most Playful Cat Breeds (With Info & Pictures)

Cats are low-maintenance pets that don’t need as much attention as dogs. They’re independent animals that want to do things how they want...

How to Detect and Prevent a Cat Attack: 4 Signs & Prevention Tips

We’ve all been there. You’re relaxed, petting your cat, when they suddenly turn and scratch, bite, or swat at you. It may seem...

Aural Hematoma in Cats: Vet Reviewed Signs, Causes & Care

Your cat’s ears are fascinating parts of their body. They can give you information about how your cat is feeling, and petting, scratching,...

Keep reading

How Bad Are Fleas in Washington State? Vet-Verified Facts & Considerations

If you live in Washington State with a cat that loves the outdoors, you must educate yourself about fleas. The milder weather throughout much of Washington can make fleas a year-round problem, so much so that even your indoor cat...

Cat with fleas

Can Cats Drink Gatorade? Vet Approved Nutritional Facts & FAQ

If you have a cat that needs help rehydrating, Gatorade might be the first idea to come to mind. You’re not the only person to get this idea. Many cat owners have tried offering Gatorade to their kitties as a...

Can Cats Drink Gatorade

Why Did My Cat Throw Up? 8 Vet-Reviewed Likely Reasons

When your cat throws up, it can send your mind into overdrive: What’s going on? Do I need to take them to the vet? What can I do for them? The solution starts with identifying why your cat is vomiting...

a cat that feels sick and seems to vomit

Is Celosia Toxic to Cats? Vet-Approved Facts & Safety Guide

Celosia argentea var. plumosa is a plant that is commonly used as an ornamental flower. It is a part of the amaranth family, and while it is native to Asia, it can now be found in many parts of the...

Catster_Is Celosia Toxic to Cats

My Cat Is Obsessed With Their Automatic Feeder, Should I Worry? Vet-Reviewed Causes & Facts

Cats, generally speaking, are food lovers. They become very intrigued and interested in food and are always hoping for a bit more. Given that you are reading this article, it is assumed you tried out an automatic cat feeder. But...

automatic cat food dispenser or pet feeder

How to Keep Cats Warm in Winter: 7 Vet-Approved Methods

If you own a cat, you might be wondering if they easily get cold. You may have observed them hiding under a blanket, sitting by a heater, or snuggling up with you to stay warm. If you would like to...

Devon Rex kitten on a white fluffy blanket

Why Do Cats Scoot? 5 Vet Reviewed Reasons & What to Do

If you live with a feline, you may have seen your buddy engage in a few less than elegant activities, including the dreaded scoot—where your cat’s dragging their butt on the floor leaving something stinky behind. Cleaning up the results...

cat-sitting-scooting

Are Ladybugs Poisonous to Cats? Vet-Confirmed Toxicity

Ladybugs are small, brightly colored beneficial insects that can help any garden thrive to its fullest extent. They are exceptional friends to your garden because they eat aphids, tiny pests that gardeners and farmers spend hundreds to thousands of dollars...

a ladybug on yellow flower