Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Why Do Cats Drop Toys in Water? 7 Possible Reasons

Cat Sensory Toy

Cats sometimes do unpredictable things. They’ll get startled when you move your shoes and jump straight into the air; they will suddenly dart around the room, making unearthly noises. A kitten can make a toy out of anything, whether it’s a pen or the TV remote. Why they drop toys into water had us scratching our heads until we did some research on cat behavior. However, a lot of the possible reasons still remain only assumptions and anecdotes.

Cats are much closer to their wild side than you may realize. That explains much of their behavior. But what are the reasons for dropping toys in water, specifically?

divider cat faces oct 2024

The 7 Possible Reasons Cats Drop Toys in Water

1. Just an Accident

Some cats really go into overdrive when they play. Toys go flying, landing everywhere. Sometimes, they fall into places they shouldn’t, such as your pet’s water bowl. If you fish the toy out of water often, know that it might just be accidental. Felines are usually pretty stealthy, but kittens are another story. If it starts to be a problem, simply move their bowl out of harm’s way—but still make sure it’s easily accessible.

Generic rubber fish toy floating
Image By: Bits And Splits, Shutterstock

2.  Playing

All bets are off when a cat starts playing. You may have just fed them, and the food is beginning to fuel their bloodstream. Many pets experience short bursts of energy. Sometimes, things get out of hand. There isn’t a rhyme or reason to it; it’s all just a part of the game, even if your kitty ends up dunking the umpteenth toy in their water bowl.


3. Hunting Lessons

Wild or feral cats will feed their kittens and turn on the instinct to hunt rodents. Domestic felines may react similarly if exposed to mice or toys when young. A pet dropping a toy into their bowl could simply be their way of dealing with their kill and dragging it to a place that feels like “their” territory.

little red ginger striped kitten playing with duck toy
Image By: MarinaTr, Shutterstock

4. Caching Prey

Cats and water usually don’t go together. We don’t always think of them hiding food. However, researchers have documented a European Wildcat (Felis silvestris) catching prey. These observations are significant since the ancestor to our pets is a subspecies of the wild feline, the African wildcat (Felis silvestris lybica). We know that cats have many wild instincts. Perhaps, storing toys in a safe place is one of them but ending up in the water bowl may be accidental rather than done on purpose. Leaving a fresh kill near water may enhance its decomposition and cats will avoid leaving their prey around water if they can.


5. Boredom

You’ve undoubtedly noticed your kitty knocking objects off of a table. You put it back in place, and down it goes again. Cats do many things, appropriate or not, out of boredom. Remember that you’re dealing with an intelligent animal. They must have mental stimulation or enrichment for a good quality of life. A toy in the water bowl simply might entertain them as they bat it around and watch it move.

Toy cat with a blue background and a glas bowl
Image Credit: Patrick von Bargen, Shutterstock

6. Being Impulsive

A cat’s personality can affect behavior. Scientists have studied feline behavior and use specific terms to describe various personality traits. One tool is the ”Feline Five” personality model, which includes dominance, agreeableness, extroversion, neuroticism, and impulsiveness.

This study found that impulsiveness was associated with owner assessments of excitable, erratic, and reckless. Indeed, dropping toys in a water bowl qualifies. We can then strike up this behavior as a part of the cat’s personality that manifests itself in this odd way.

maine coon cat with toy in his mouth
Image Credit: Alena A, Shutterstock

7. Getting Your Attention

Probably one of the main reasons your kitty acts this way is to get your attention. They figure out the cause and effect. They may use this behavior to remind you that it’s feeding time. Many pets learn that doing something naughty rouses attention, even if it doesn’t always result in a positive response. The fact is that you’ve noticed, and that cements the positive association.

cat lying next to a toy
Image Credit: I.K.Media, Shutterstock

divider 1 paws

Conclusion

Realizing your cat’s close ties to their past can make it easy to understand what seems like odd behaviors. Remember that your pet is still hardwired to roam the steppes and scrublands of their ancestral home. It’s also worth noting that felines are obligate carnivores that get most of their food from animal-based proteins, which explains many of their food-motivated traits and behaviors.

See also:


Featured Image Credit: SoulArtimage, Shutterstock

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.

Talk With A Vet Online

Peace of mind,
anywhere, anytime

Affordable vet advice

How Much Wet Food Should a Cat Eat? Vet-Approved, Healthy Diet Advice

Many cat owners are unsure how much wet food their cat should eat; however, the answer is not as clear since it will...

How to Get the Best Cat Care While on Vacation: 5 Vet-Approved Options to Consider

As much as we’d love to spend every moment possible with our cats, most of us can’t be home 24/7/365. There will come...

10 Tortoiseshell Cat Breeds (With Info & Pictures)

Tortoiseshell cats are cats with beautiful and unique bi-colored, sometimes tri-colored, coats that are often black and orange or brown and gold, sometimes...

How to Stop a Cat From Scratching Carpet: 6 Vet-Verified Tips & Solutions

One of the most significant downsides of owning a cat is their claws. Not only can they scratch you, but they can also...

More related

9 Best Foods for Siamese Cats in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Siamese cats, with their striking blue almond-shaped eyes, short coat, and distinctive color points, are known for their friendly, sociable, and affectionate nature....

Scratch Lounge 2025 Review: Types, Pros, Cons & Verdict

When it comes to cardboard scratchers, it doesn’t get much better than the Scratch Lounge. This three-sided scratcher will last far longer than...

7 Best Halloween Costumes for Cats in 2025: Reviews & Top Picks

Our pets are part of the family, and generally, getting dogs on board with dress-up days is easier than cats. That means our...

9 Best Cat Litters for Picky Cats in 2025 – Reviews & Top Picks

Did your cat stick their paw into the latest litter and scoff in disapproval? Or maybe you bought a new litter on sale...

Keep reading

How to Introduce a Third Cat to Your Home (11 Vet-Reviewed Tips)

If there’s one thing to know about cat lovers, it’s that they cannot get enough of their cat. You can find many cat owners who started off with one or two cats, and eventually grew their cat family into a...

three Korat kittens

How to Moisturize Cat Paws: 6 Vet Approved Tips & Tricks

Your cat’s paws are an important tool for navigating the world. Each paw pad has a cluster of nerve receptors that relay information about their surroundings, which can be compromised if they become dry and cracked. The discomfort may also...

cat reaching its paw out

Are Cats Monogamous? Vet-Verified Mating Practices

It might be a sweet idea to get two cats that you’re sure are going to fall in love and live happily ever after together. Unfortunately, that type of love and relationship is not in a cat’s DNA. Cats are...

two different cats standing side by side outdoors in the garden

Can Cats Eat Parmesan? Vet-Approved Nutritional Facts & FAQ

As a cat owner, you know how tough it can be to say “no” to your kitty begging for a taste of food off your plate at the dinner table. Some human foods are okay to offer your kitty in...

Can Cats Eat Parmesan

How Long Can My Cat Stay in Their Crate? Vet Reviewed Safety Guide

Cat fanatics know too well that their beloved felines can become real monsters at night and wreak havoc in the house. This makes the idea of putting them in a crate quite tempting. However, you should be aware that keeping...

cat in cat carrier

Fussie Cat Food Review of 2025: Recalls, Pros & Cons

Review Summary This cat food is one of the higher-quality options on the market. It is made with whole meat in Thailand following strict guidelines. The recipes are quite high in protein and fat, which is exactly what cats need...

Fussie Cat Food Review

Why is My Cat Peeing Everywhere All of a Sudden? 7 Vet-Reviewed Reasons

Cat owners can agree that the smell of cat urine is overwhelming. It’s a difficult odor to remove from furniture, carpeting, and other fabrics. Your home quickly becomes unpleasant if your kitty isn’t using their litter box. There are several...

cat with pee stain on the carpet

Can Cats Drink Plant Milk? Vet-Reviewed Facts & FAQ

Plant milk has become a popular alternative to cow’s milk and is available at grocery stores or coffee shops. With more people turning to vegan options and plant-based foods and drinks, it’s natural to wonder if they are appropriate for...

Can Cats Drink Plant Milk