Subscription cat boxes help to solve this problem by offering specially curated collections of new toys and treats for your cat every month. However, not all subscription cat box services are the same, and there’s always the risk of ending up with a box of products your cat doesn’t enjoy. Our reviews of some of the best cat subscription boxes are here to help you determine which ones might be a good fit for your cat. We’ll also go over some key things to consider when shopping for monthly subscription boxes for cats. So, make sure to read on before signing up for a cat subscription box.
Click to Skip Ahead
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2024
| Image | Product | Details | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Best Overall
|
|
Meowbox |
|
CHECK PRICE |
Best Value
|
|
Pet Treater |
|
CHECK PRICE |
Premium Choice
|
|
Smalls Cat Food Subscription |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
Kitty Poo Club |
|
CHECK PRICE | |
|
CatLadyBox |
|
CHECK PRICE |
The 10 Best Cat Subscription Boxes
1. Meowbox – Best Overall
| Box Contents: | Toys, treats, wellness products |
| Customizable Options: | Yes |
Meowbox is one of the most popular cat box subscription companies and with good reason. It’s the best overall cat subscription box because of how well-rounded it is. Each box follows a cute and fun theme and contains a mix of toys, treats, and cat wellness products. Some boxes may even contain cat apparel. All the items are carefully curated only to include high-quality, unique toys that aren’t commonly found in pet stores. The treats are also often organic, limited-ingredient, or made in human-grade facilities. While you can’t substitute treats for food allergies, Meowbox does offer customization to request toys only.
Another great thing about Meowbox is that it offers a bi-monthly shipment option that enables you to extend the amount of time between boxes without having to pause your subscription. Meowbox is also known to have excellent customer service. Each box comes with a handwritten note addressed to your cat, and your cat will also receive a free birthday toy on their birthday month.
- Contains unique toys not commonly found in pet stores
- Only includes high-quality cat treats
- Toys-only boxes available
- Excellent customer service
- No treat substitutions for food allergies
2. Pet Treater – Best Value
| Box Contents: | Toys, treats |
| Customizable Options: | Yes |
Cat subscription boxes don’t have to burn a hole in your wallet. Pet Treater is a budget-friendly option and the best cat subscription box for the money. The boxes tend to have fewer products than their competitors, but they’re all carefully selected, high-quality toys and treats. If you want more toys and treats, you can always choose Pet Treater’s multi-cat pack, which has five to eight items, rather than the standard three to four items included in the regular cat pack.
Pet Treater also considers common food allergies and will omit treats that contain peanuts, chicken, and grains if you indicate that your cat is allergic to one of these foods. So, while Pet Treater may not have the fancy packaging that other subscription boxes for cats offer, it provides the essentials. It’s a straightforward service that’s really a great option for cats that want to cut to the chase and just play with their toys and enjoy their treats.
- Has multi-cat pack option
- Customizations available for some food allergies
- Budget-friendly
- Standard box has just three to four items
3. Smalls Cat Food Subscription – Premium Choice
| Box Contents: | Food |
| Customizable Options: | Yes |
If you’re looking for a subscription cat food box, Smalls offers a convenient experience for you and tasty and nutritious meals for your cat. Smalls has a trial box that you can test out before committing to a subscription plan. Once you determine your cat’s favorite recipes, you can sign up for a monthly subscription relatively quickly.
All of Smalls’ cat food recipes are human-grade and made fresh with USDA-certified ingredients. Smalls sources its ingredients from businesses that have humane and sustainable business practices. The recipes have simple ingredient lists and are considerable choices for cats with sensitive stomachs or food allergies.
While Smalls offers a convenient way to give your cat fresh cat food, it can be difficult to ensure you have enough food in emergency situations because Smalls products are only sold through the company website. It’s always helpful to have a package or two of backup meals in case your regular shipment runs late, or if the packages have been tampered with or punctured.
- One-time trial box option is available
- Delivers fresh human-grade cat food
- Clean recipes for cats with food allergies or sensitive stomachs
- Not available in pet stores
4. Kitty Poo Club
| Box Contents: | Cat litter, disposable cat litter box |
| Customizable Options: | Yes |
While your cat may not have fun with this subscription service, Kitty Poo Club’s cat litter subscription offers convenient and sustainable cat litter box options for cat owners. This service sends a monthly shipment of cat litter in a disposable cardboard cat litter box. The litter boxes are designed to last a month and have leak-proof linings. They come in two sizes, and the larger size can hold cats that weigh over 20 pounds. You can also add an optional dome to guard against splashing. Once you receive a new shipment of cat litter, you can simply toss the old litter box and lay out the new one.
Kitty Poo Club offers both clumping and non-clumping cat litter options. So, it’s less likely for your cat to notice the change in cat litter while you transition over to Kitty Poo Club. Overall, Kitty Poo Club makes litter box cleanup fast and easy. However, the downside to this subscription service is that it’ll be difficult to get a replacement box quickly. So, it’s helpful to have a backup box in case of emergencies.
- Sustainable litter box option
- Large litter box size available for large cat breeds
- Offers clumping and non-clumping cat litter
- Difficult to get replacement boxes quickly
5. CatLadyBox
| Box Contents: | Apparel, decor, cat toys |
| Customizable Options: | No |
CatLadyBox is a subscription box for cat owners who don’t want to be left out. Each of their “CRAZY” level boxes includes three to four pieces of fun apparel and decor for you and two toys for your kitty. Every item included is exclusive to CatLadyBox, which means you won’t find these crazy cat items or cat toys in any store.
The boxes cannot be customized in terms of specific items, but you do have the option to choose from multiple themes each month. You can also buy individual items a la carte and add them to your order. With this subscription service, you have multiple delivery options to choose from: every month, every other month, or every six months.
- Fun cat stuff for humans
- Unique cat toys
- Discounts for multi-box subscriptions
- Customizable delivery schedules
- Company donates proceeds to cat organizations
- Box contents are not customizable
6. KitNipBox
| Box Contents: | Toys, treats, wellness products |
| Customizable Options: | Yes |
KitNipBox is an excellent option for kittens because of all the variety it offers. KitNipBoxes contain five unique items that follow a fun monthly theme. The selections of toys that KitNipBox curates are diverse and only include high-quality toys, so your kitten is sure to be entertained all month long. KitNipBox also introduces kittens to exclusive new treats that may not be sold at major pet retail stores. The company doesn’t offer treat substitutions, but you can request only to receive toys if your kitten has a sensitive stomach and isn’t able to eat new foods easily.
Overall, KitNipBox offers a wide selection of toys and treats for your young kitten to explore. It’s a great way to introduce your kitten to new experiences and discover what their personal favorites are.
- Wide selection of toys and treats
- Toys-only option available
- Boxes only include high-quality, durable toys
- No food substitutions available
7. VetPet Box
| Box Contents: | Toys, treats, wellness products |
| Customizable Options: | Yes |
Though VetPet Box runs on the more expensive side, it offers a specially curated subscription box experience for your cat. After you complete your pet’s profile, a veterinary team will ship toys and treats tailored to your cat’s preferences. This process reduces the risk of getting a box full of items that your cat isn’t interested in.
VetPet Box has a more rigorous quality control process to ensure your cat gets premium toys that are durable, safe, and engaging for cats. The treats are also tailored to your cat’s preferences, and you can also request alternatives to any treats that contain any food allergens. The boxes also contain vet-approved cat wellness products and educational material. So, these boxes are excellent choices for new cat owners looking to learn more about their cats and how to best care for them.
- Subscription boxes curated by a veterinary team
- Alternative treats for food allergies available
- Includes vet-approved wellness products and education materials
- Relatively expensive
8. BoxCat
| Box Contents: | Toys, treats |
| Customizable Options: | Yes |
BoxCat excels in customizations for your cat and includes a wide variety of cat products with each monthly box shipment. The basic BoxCat box contains a mix of four to five toys and cat gear and one bag of handmade treats. The treats are made with all-natural ingredients, and you can also notify BoxCat of any food allergies.
Another way you can customize your subscription is to opt for the luxury box option, which includes a large luxury item, such as a cat bed, cat mat, and bigger and more complex toys. You can choose multi-month plans for both the basic and luxury boxes and will receive discounted prices for longer plans. There’s also a seasonal subscription plan, which ships four boxes with luxury items annually. All subscription plans come with free shipping.
Keep in mind that while BoxCat does a great job of introducing your cat to new toys, it doesn’t provide the option to purchase your cat’s favorites. You may be able to include an extra toy if it’s in its clearance section, but it’s generally difficult to choose individual toys.
- Many customization options
- Treats are handmade with all-natural ingredients
- Make savings with multi-month plans
- Can’t purchase old favorites
9. RescueBox
| Box Contents: | Toys, treats |
| Customizable Options: | No |
RescueBox is a great option for anyone who’s also looking to support a great cause. Each purchase of a subscription box helps pay to feed shelter animals. The RescueBox for cats is suitable for cats of all sizes and contains five premium cat products. However, keep in mind that RescueBox doesn’t offer customizations, so it may not be the best option for cats with food allergies.
RescueBox only offers month-to-month subscription plans, but the boxes are more affordably priced than many other competitors. Shipping is also free in the U.S., so RescueBox is a considerable budget-friendly option while being a fun way to support charitable causes.
- Supports charitable causes
- Suitable for cats of all sizes
- Affordable prices
- No customizations available
10. Gus & Bella
| Box Contents: | Toys, treats, home decor |
| Customizable Options: | Yes |
Gus & Bella offers high-quality cat toys and treats, and each box always includes an item for humans. The items are catered toward cat ladies and have a more feminine style. So, the design may not be for everyone, but each item is fun and practical. Gus & Bella also offers some customizable options to ensure you and your cat receive products that better suit your tastes.
Since Gus & Bella are based in the UK, you’ll have to pay international shipping fees. However, the company has a reliable shipping system, so you can expect your cat box to arrive on time consistently.
- Includes items for humans
- Offers some customizable options
- Ships internationally
- Must pay international shipping fees
- Items are catered towards traditionally female audience
Buyer’s Guide: Finding the Best Cat Subscription Box
Different cat subscription boxes have unique perks. Some excel in procuring new toys, while others will specialize in delivering high-quality treats. So, the best way to find the right subscription box for your cat is to consider what features your cat will appreciate most. Here are some things to consider before signing up for a monthly cat subscription box plan.
Included Items
Finding high-quality, unique cat products can be a challenge, as many pet stores will cycle through the same items. Subscription cat boxes can introduce you to a wide selection of new toys or treats that are made by small businesses that don’t sell their products to large retail stores. So, your cat subscription box selection will depend on what types of items you’re looking for.
Most cat boxes will focus on toys and curate themed toy collections. You’ll find some cat boxes that focus more on high-quality treats and cat wellness products. Occasionally, you’ll come across cat boxes that include a mix of products for both cats and humans.
Customization Options
Customizations will be a priority for cat owners with picky cats. While most cat subscription boxes don’t have customization options for toys, some do have more options available for treats. They may provide alternatives for treats that contain food allergens, or they can offer to swap treats for an extra toy in the box.
Multi-Month Plans
An easy way to save on costs is to sign up for multi-month plans. Most subscription boxes for cats offer month-to-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month plans, and they often have discounted prices for subscription plans with longer durations. Most companies allow you to put a pause on monthly shipments, even if you sign up for a multi-month plan. So, you can still experience savings on multi-month subscriptions and skip months if you don’t need new toys or treats.
How We Selected Our List of Cat Subscription Boxes
Catster has an experienced, expert team of writers, editors, and veterinarians who carefully consider a wide range of parameters when choosing the cat subscription boxes. This includes but is not limited to customer reviews, brand reputation, veterinary experience, hands-on testing, and of course, our cats have a say in the process too! We aim to select and review only the best products available, to help you make the best possible choice and most informed decision for your and your cat’s needs.
Why Trust Catster?
A trusted online brand since 2001, Catster has a lot of experience with cat subscription boxes. Our team of cat-loving writers, editors, and veterinarians is dedicated to helping you make the best decision for your precious cats. Our aim is to provide the best information available for cat owners to help cats live their best life possible. To do this, we scour reviews from the most trusted sources available and this, combined with our veterinary team’s experience and expertise, helps us gather the best options available to readers. Our team is deeply invested in the health and welfare of cats the world over, and believes that expert knowledge and veterinary guidance will help you make the right choices—for you and your cats!
Conclusion
Among our reviews, Meowbox is the best cat subscription box because it provides a wide variety of toys and treats that you normally wouldn’t have access to, and the subscription prices are reasonable and affordable. If you’re looking for a more budget-friendly option, Pet Treater boxes are an excellent option that adequately delivers the basic essentials included in cat boxes. If you’re looking for a different type of subscription, Smalls Cat Food and Kitty Poo Club are great options.
Each cat subscription box excels in different things. By getting to know your cat’s preferences, you’ll be able to select the option that best suits your cat’s needs.
Featured Image Credit: rom_olik, Shutterstock
