Get

In Your Inbox

Catster is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you. Learn more.

Pet Care Insurance Review 2026: Pros, Cons & Verdict

Share

PetCare Insurance
Our Final Verdict

We give Pet Care Insurance an overall rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars.

As a pet professional, you know the importance of protecting your business and your clients. You also know how unpredictable four-legged companions can be. That’s why choosing reliable insurance is so important. If you have a business in the pet industry (cat sitter, pet groomer, dog daycare, etc.), Pet Care Insurance (PCI), will protect you and your clients no matter what life throws at you. With their custom add-ons, you won’t have to worry about the what-ifs or worst-case scenarios. Whether a kitten gets sick under your care or you lose your client’s keys, PCI has you covered.

divider 2 cats

Pet Care Insurance Review

Pros
  • Exclusively designed for small business pet professionals
  • Customizable coverage
  • Online transactions
  • Claim filing is quick and easy
  • Live chat available
  • Downloadable certificate at checkout
Cons
  • Customizations are purchased separately
  • Some coverage items require deductibles

About Pet Care Insurance

PCI is an insurance provider that services small pet businesses. They were founded in 2013 as a subdivision of Veracity Insurance and have been on a mission to provide pet professionals with accessible and affordable insurance. Unlike traditional insurance, PCI only caters to businesses in the pet industry, which means they know the kinds of problems you and your furry clients face. Over the past decade, they’ve been trusted by over 14,000 pet care professionals across more than 10 industries.

A few of the industries PCI covers include:

  • Pet Sitters
  • Dog Walkers
  • Pet Groomers
  • Mobile Pet Groomers
  • Dog Trainers
  • Pooper Scoopers
  • Pet Kennels
  • Doggy Daycares
  • Pet Boarders
  • Cat Sitters
  • Dog Sitters
  • Pet Taxi Services

There’s never a good time for minor accidents or major catastrophes, and it can be hard to find insurance that gives you full coverage. But, with PCI, it’s simple. You get extensive liability coverage with the Base Policy and get to pick and choose custom policies that best fit your needs. This means cat sitters get coverage for drop-in visits while pet groomers get coverage for teeth cleanings. With their flexible policy options, you’re protected for everything you need and you’re not stuck paying for things you don’t.

Best of all, it’s affordable. PCI is committed to keeping premiums low and coverage high, so you can have peace of mind that you’re protected without blowing your budget. While PCI doesn’t offer insurance for services outside of your pet business (including pet health insurance), they’re a great option for pet professionals across the United States.

Pricing & Plans (Updated in 2026)

Pet Insurance Cost Comparison

Company Average Monthly Cost For Dogs Average Monthly Cost For Cats Learn More
Pet Care $13.33 $13.33 Get Quote
Healthy Paws $49 $19 Get Quote
Lemonade $46 $27 Get Quote
Embrace $20 $10 Get Quote
Trupanion $131 $51 Get Quote
Fetch $35 $20 Get Quote
Spot $38 $17 Get Quote

* Prices vary depending on your pet’s age, breed, and location. Averages updated January 2024.

Base Policy

When you purchase insurance from PCI, you’ll get coverage for a variety of unforeseen events, like property damage, accidents, and injuries (to name a few). Unlike other insurance providers, PCI’s Base Policy includes Animal Bailee and Veterinarian Reimbursement. This means you’ll automatically get financial protection for animal-related injuries or veterinary expenses at no additional cost to you.

The Base Policy also covers the following:

  • Dog walkers
  • Pet waste removal
  • Pet taxi services
  • Basic care of client’s pet(s)
  • Bathing and brushing (not related to grooming)
  • Teaching basic commands (sit and stay)

Customizations

PCI offers custom policies for pet professionals based on individual business needs. The following options are available as add-ons to your policy.

Higher Animal Bailee Coverage Limits

If you’re liable for injuries or (worst case scenario) the death of an animal in your care, Animal Bailee protects your business. While this is automatically included in every policy, the add-on lets you purchase higher limits (up to $30,000) if needed.

Independent Contractors Coverage

This is a great option if you hire independent contractors. It provides coverage for independent contractors and lets you include them in your plan.

Broadened Property Damage Coverage

This covers property damage caused by pets under your care.

Dog Training Coverage

If you’re a dog trainer, this protects against incidents related to training beyond basic commands, like behavior and obedience.

House Sitting Coverage

This covers overnight and drop-in house-sitting services, as well as food, water, and medication administration.

Pet Taxi Coverage

Pet Taxi Coverage is a great add-on for anyone who transports four-legged friends. To be eligible, you must ensure the following:

  • Pets are separated in an emergency
  • Pets are checked for temperament
  • You won’t transport more than five pets in one vehicle

Employee Dishonesty

In the event an employee steals from a client or damages their property, this will cover financial loss and property damage.

Pet Daycare

This covers overnight and daytime daycares in any private location or facility that you rent or own. It also covers food, water, and medication administration.

Pet Groomers Professional

You’ll need to purchase this if most of your revenue comes from grooming and teeth cleaning.

Equipment & Inventory 

Also known as Inland Marine Insurance, Equipment & Inventory protects against damaged or stolen equipment, inventory, and supplies.

Deductibles & Claims

There is a $250 deductible for Veterinary Expense Reimbursement and Equipment and Inventory coverage (per incident). You’ll pay the bill in full before reimbursement and the appropriate amount will be deducted after filing a claim.

For example, if you are pet-sitting a cat that gets sick and the vet bill is $800, you’re required to pay the $800 bill regardless of why the cat is sick or whose fault it is. Once you file the claim, you’ll receive reimbursement.

Filing a claim is easy and can be completed online through your online dashboard. All you need to do is fill out the form with your contact information and details about the incident. It’s best to check the list of exclusions before filing to make sure your incident is covered.

Within 24 to 48 business hours after submitting the form, you’ll receive a phone call or email from one of PCI’s Service Agents. The agent will gather additional information and then pass the claim to their insurance carrier (Lloyds of London), where it will be reviewed and validated. This is the longest part of the process and could take several weeks or months. If it’s approved, the claim will be settled and the process is complete.

What Does Pet Care Insurance Cover?

PCI covers a range of accidents, incidents, and liabilities. The following table shows each coverage item included in the Base Policy for all pet business owners.

Coverage Item Annual Limit
General Liability Coverage $1,000,000 (Each Occurrence)
$2,000,000 (Aggregate Limit)
Products-Completed Operations $2,000,000
Personal Advertising Injury Limit $1,000,000
Each Occurrence Limit $1,000,000
Damage to Premises Rented to You Limit $100,000 (Any One Premises)
Medical Expense Limit $5,000 (Any One Person)
Pet Protection (Animal Bailee) – Animals in Your Care, Custody, or Control $2,500 (Each Occurrence)
$5,000 (Aggregate Limit)
Veterinarian Expense Reimbursement $1,000 (Each Occurrence)
2,500 (Aggregate Limit)
$250 (Deductible)
Lost Key Liability Coverage $2,000 (Each Occurrence)
$2,000 (Aggregate Limit)
Not Covered
  • Any animals owned by the insured or breeding
  • Housesitting operations (without pets present) that generate more than 45% of your annual revenue
  • Kennel operations (more than 5 pets staying over on a single night)
  • Landscaping services
  • Livestock or farm animals
  • Pet services or daycare operations of more than 10 pets at one time
  • Pet care for animals that are not household pets
  • Pet taxi services for more than 5 pets at one time
  • Practice or participation in any athletic contest, exhibition, activity, game, or sport
  • Professional veterinarian services
  • Training operations of service, guard, protection, attack, or fighting dogs

Waiting Periods

Filing a claim only takes a couple of minutes and PCI streamlines the process for you so you can quickly and efficiently complete the process online. After submitting the online form, a Service Agent will get in touch with you via email or phone within 1-2 business days.

While filing a claim is fast, it could take several weeks or months for you to hear back from the insurance carrier about whether your claim was approved or denied. Since every case is different, there isn’t a designated waiting period, so it’s important to plan accordingly.

Reviews from Customers

With an impressive 4.9 out of 5-star rating across multiple sites, the overall consensus is that PCI is a service you can trust. Satisfied pet professionals rave about how easy and user-friendly it is to enroll in a policy, file claims, and navigate PCI’s website. When compared to competitor insurance providers, pet business owners say they switched to PCI due to their affordable prices and comprehensive coverage plans.

From the hundreds of Google reviews, it’s clear that PCI also has a stellar customer service team. Happy customers speak highly of PCI’s Service Agents, saying they were not only helpful when troubleshooting problems and answering questions, but patient, courteous, and professional while doing so.

divider 2 cats

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What if I want coverage for my pet?

While PCI is a great option for pet business owners, they don’t provide coverage for furry family members. If you’re looking for pet health insurance, PCI has partnered with two premium providers, Hartville Pet Insurance and Trupanion, to help you access the pet care you need.

How long does it take for my insurance to be effective?

After your payment is verified, your policy will go into effect immediately. At this point, you’ll have access to your account and be able to add any optional policies you might need.

How long am I covered?

Your policy will be effective for 12 months. Once you’ve reached the 12-month period, you’ll have 30 days to renew it in your account. If you sign up for EZ-Renew, your policy will renew automatically.

divider 2 cats

Our Verdict

If you’re a pet professional looking for business insurance, PCI is a great option. Along with offering easy online access and a comprehensive Base Policy, they cater to individual businesses with flexible policy options. Insurance should be convenient and affordable, and with PCI, it is. They streamline the process for you and have dedicated support agents ready to answer your questions and help you find the best policy for you and your clients.


Catster acknowledges that it is not licensed as an insurance agent, and therefore will not offer any insurance advice, nor recommend a particular coverage, policy, or insurance company.

Want content like this delivered to you?

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

News, insights, expert advice, and everything cat

* By submitting, you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy & Cookies Policy.




How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate (you can leave written feedback after clicking submit)

Help us improve Catster for pet parents!

Your feedback really matters.

What did you like about this post? Also how can we improve it?

Join the conversation

Leave a Reply

You’re very welcome to leave a comment or question. Please know that all comments must meet our community guidelines, and your email address will NOT be published. Let’s have a positive and constructive conversation.


Catster's Digital Magazine is Back!

Vet-approved health & behavior advice

Real cat stories & community features

The Bite Stuff: The Truth Behind a Cat’s Sudden Nip

A cat bite that seems to come out of nowhere is one of the more confusing things a cat owner deals with. Everything...

Your Cat’s Purr Proves They’re One of a Kind

There are few sounds more comforting to a cat parent than the familiar rumble of a purring cat. You probably know your own...

“Pspsps!” Why Cats Find This Sound Irresistible

There are a few things that will capture the undivided attention of virtually any nearby feline: the sound of a can of tuna...

“Trophy Pets”: Two Rescued Lions Finally Find Freedom

Ori began life in a basement. BenTzur was found tied to a tree on a short rope. Both were rescued as lion cubs...

More related

10 Fascinating Vet-Reviewed Facts About Polydactyl Cats (With Pictures)

Polydactylism is when an animal has a higher-than-usual number of fingers and toes. It is actually surprisingly common in some animals, including cats....

4 Best Flooring for Cats: Pros, Cons & FAQ

Cats and flooring are a tricky combination. If cats aren’t creating time-intensive cleanups by shedding, spraying, or hacking up hairballs, they’re digging in...

Can Cats Be Sexually Attracted to Humans? Dispelling the Myths (Vet-Verified)

Our relationship with our animal companions has evolved through the ages. When we once considered cats to be mere mousers, we’ve since invited...

60 Fitting Names for Cats With White Paws

Choosing a name for your cat is an opportunity to highlight your interests and those of your cat’s personality and appearance. The task...

Keep reading

Why Do Cats Curl Their Paws? Vet-Verified Reasons, Facts & FAQ

Cats have many adorable habits, one of which is their tendency to curl their paws underneath them and sit in a “loaf” shape. While we rarely think much of the sitting position—other than how cute it is—a cat will curl...

cat folding his paw while sleeping

How to Prevent Insect Bites on Cats: 6 Useful Tips

It stands to reason that if you have to worry about mosquito and other insect bites in the yard, you have to worry about them biting your feline pal. As with humans, mosquito bites can be harmful to your cat....

sleeping cat bitten by mosquito on its nose

Can Cats Eat Garlic? Vet-Reviewed Risks & FAQ

Few foods are as popular and as potent as garlic. We use garlic to imbue its delicious, savory flavor into our foods, and millions love the bulbous, flowering plant. However, if you’re a cat owner, you might wonder if your...

Can Cats Eat Garlic

Can a Cat Laugh? Vet-Reviewed Scientific Facts & Information

Cat videos took the internet by storm for good reason; these extraordinary little creatures have a way of making us laugh like no other. Every cat lover knows that when you share your life with a feline companion, you are...

laughing cat

How to Tell if Your Cat Is Happy: 16 Vet-Reviewed Signs

Some people prefer dogs to cats because dogs are considered easier to read and more demonstrative with their affection. Many cat enthusiasts will insist that if you know what you’re looking for, it’s quite easy to know if your cat...

bengal cat being stroked by man's hand and purring

Can Cats Get Razor Burn? Vet-Reviewed Care Facts

If you have a cat, there is a good chance that they will need to be shaved at some point in their lives, whether it be for a surgical procedure like getting spayed or neutered, or to treat a wound....

pet grooming at home

Should I Brush My Cat’s Teeth? Vet-Approved Advice & Tips

Brushing your cat’s teeth is critical for their dental health. Regular brushing prevents plaque and tartar from accumulating, which can help keep problems such as gingivitis and periodontal disease at bay. Dental disease can also be linked to other health...

man brushing cat's teeth

Are Orchids Toxic to Cats? Vet Approved Advice

Some houseplants are poisonous to cats. If you want to have a house full of greenery but also have cats, it’s essential to know which plants are safe and which are poisonous. If you love orchids, it makes sense to...

Catster_Are Orchids Toxic to Cats

Love Cats? So Do We! Join the Catster Community

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.




Sign up for the Catster Email Newsletter

Stay informed with expert pet care insights delivered straight to your inbox! Discover professional guidance on animal behavior, feeding tips, trusted product picks, and much more.