Did your cat stick their paw into the latest litter and scoff in disapproval? Or maybe you bought a new litter on sale and they don’t seem happy with what you’re providing. No matter what the case is, you need to have a litter that attracts your cat to their box—and not your carpet.
So, if you have a finicky feline, we hope this article makes your life easier. We rounded up eight of the best litters we could find that might just get a paws up from your cat. Check out these picky kitty-approved litters.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2024
|Kitty Poo Club
|Click to Save 35%
|Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter
|World's Best Cat Litter Picky Cat
|Best for Kittens
|Fresh Step Advanced Simply Unscented Clumping Cat Litter
|Dr. Elsey's Premium Clumping Cat Litter
The 9 Best Cat Litter for Picky Cats
1. Kitty Poo Club Cat Litter – Best Overall
|Single cat household
|Clay, Wood, Corn, Wheat
Our top pick for best litters for picky cats is the subscription service offered by Kitty Poo Club. They have six premium litters to choose from, such as clay, silica, soy, and diatomite. With so many options, there is sure to be a variety suitable to all cats, even the particular ones! All of the Kitty Poo Club litters are free of scents, dyes, and chemicals, making them more tolerable to cats than the dusty, fragrant options sold in stores.
With this subscription service, you also receive a brand new, recyclable litter box every month with the litter of your choice. If your feline is not keen on the litter you’ve initially selected, you can swap it out for another variation, until you find one your cat enjoys using.
All of their bundles include free shipping and are delivered directly to your doorstep. They also offer bundles for multi-cat homes, allowing you to select different litter types according to the preferences of each cat.
2. Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter – Best Value
If you’re trying to save a few bucks but need your cat to do their business in the box—try Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter. This product is a zero-dust formula, keeping your cat’s nasal passages free and clear.
We were impressed at how effective this cat litter is about clumping—it forms immediate bonds around the waste with micro granules to keep the rest of the litter clean.
Arm & Hammer also gives a 7-day freshness guarantee, making this litter ideal for households with a few felines running around. It uses natural odor-fighting power, like baking soda, for optimal freshness. You’ll appreciate the extra strength—and the price tag!
3. World’s Best Cat Litter Picky Cat – Premium Choice
|All life stages
Sure, no one wants to spend an arm and a leg on cat litter, but sometimes it’s necessary to up the ante to keep the rest of your house pee-free. The World’s Best Cat Litter Picky Cat is formulated to meet the needs of all felines—especially those troubled felines of yours.
Rather than being clay-based, this litter uses corn as the main component with natural attractants. What’s even better about this cat litter? It’s 100% septic-safe and flushable. So, once you’re ready to clean the box, it can go down the John—no problem.
This clumping formula works great for multi-cat households—kittens, adults, and seniors alike. So, no matter the life stage, they have you covered. However, the corn might not combat odors as much as other options.
4. Fresh Step Advanced Simply Unscented Clumping Cat Litter – Best for Kittens
If you have a kitty that’s finicky about textures or smells, the Fresh Step Advanced Simply Unscented clumping cat litter might be exactly what you need to try. This litter is 99.9% dust-free and completely void of dyes or fragrances that could irritate your pets.
The key ingredient here is activated charcoal, which eliminates odors for up to ten days—and it really does have superb odor control. We like how easy this cat litter is to scoop. You don’t have any particles fall off into the clean litter for a later date.
You can effectively get all the waste without a problem—it’s equipped with Fresh Steps “Clumplock” technology. So, if you need a base clay formula that doesn’t affect the senses, we think your cat will say yes.
5. Dr. Elsey’s Premium Clumping Cat Litter
If you’re having trouble getting your kitty to take to litter, Dr. Elsey’s Cat Attract formula is superb. It’s on our list because it has dedicated appeal for all felines—and we have to say, it works!
So, there is a natural herbal attractant in the clay litter that persuades your cats to use it. The product is developed for multi-cat households with a highly advanced strength odor control formula.
We think this litter has the perfect texture, and it’s 99.9% dust-free and hard-clumping. If your cat has issues with having litter stuck on their paws—fear not. The size of the particles shouldn’t allow that to happen often. Your kitties will thank you for it.
6. Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter
Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter is an up-and-coming formula that appeals to the pickiest of cats—and we think you’ll approve, too. This bio-enzymatic formula will take care of odors and appeal to your finicky feline, too.
Because of it being scent-free, we were a little concerned as to how it would combat smells, but it did so with flair. This litter bag comes in a plastic resealable container with a side handle, so be careful you reseal it every time to prevent spills or messes.
We do want to point out that the company offers a successful purchase—or your money back. So, if your cat gives this litter a big paws down, you can get a refund to move on to other options.
7. Tidy Cats Free & Clean
Your picky cat might enjoy the natural, airy formula Tidy Cats Free & Clean has to offer. The textures are fantastic for optimal coverage. Rather than using harmful chemicals or dyes, this litter uses activated charcoal to effectively combat odors—leaving your home fresh.
This formula is ideal for multi-cat households, so if it works for your pickiest—consider it a done deal. This clumping cat litter adheres to waste with a light coat, not using too much litter while doing the job.
This litter lasts up to one month at a time before you need to replace the whole batch. This product does have tiny granules, so it doesn’t work as well for cats who hate litter sticking to their paws.
8. BoxiePro Deep Clean
BoxiePro Deep Clean takes your cat’s litter seriously as they do. It provides outstanding material to reduce odors, attract cats, and stop bacteria from spreading at the source. This scent-free formula is a probiotic clumping cat litter that reduces tracking—and won’t irritate your kitty.
The only two ingredients listed on the bag are pure premium clay and deep-cleaning probiotics to give your cat terrific textures without repelling them.
This cat litter has a money-back guarantee if you aren’t satisfied with the product. The entire mission of Boxie is to reduce troublesome waste tracking in the home—and we think both you and your cat will appreciate it.
9. Petfive Sustainably Yours Natural Sustainable Multi-Cat Litter
If you’re looking for an environmentally friendly choice, we think that the Petfive Sustainably Yours Natural Multi-Cat Litter is a great option to consider. You can use this litter for every cat in your home, including the picky ones, with this blend of corn and cassava.
The combination of these two plant-based products creates a quick-clumping, highly absorbent litter that works like a charm. We love the fact that this litter is so environmentally friendly. The litter is both biodegradable and compostable.
Plus, the granules are large, so it reduces tracking particles that can irritate your cat and clog up your home. The lighter color in the litter really helps when you’re scooping, too. You can see the dirty spots with ease, so you can remove them for a fresh finish.
We will say that the clumps do fall apart easily while cleaning, which can make things a little more difficult. Plus, the larger granules make regular scoops incompatible.
What Kinds of Cat Litter Might Irritate Cats?
Tons of factors might influence why your cat is rejecting their litter. Every kitty is different, and even though they can’t tell you what’s up, you can pick up on a few cues.
Some cats are quite frankly not happy about litter sticking to their paws. You might share this sentiment because you probably find these tiny particles scattered on your belongings and floors.
Some cats are highly sensitive to strong perfumes and fragrances. Most of the time, if these smells are overwhelming to them, they might avoid their boxes entirely.
Even if the litter doesn’t stick to their paws, your cat might not be crazy about how the litter feels on their pads. If you notice a lot of flicking
Cats are genetically programmed to cover their waste. If they don’t feel like their litter is doing the job, they might try to find another part of the house that’s more desirable.
Dust can clog up your cat’s airway, causing sneezing and breathing problems. If your cat feels like it’s too dusty every time they cover their waste, they might not want to use it.
Cat Litter Quality for Picky Cats
If you have a particularly finicky feline, here are some bases you might want to cover when looking for litter.
Some cats prefer a softer textured litter that is easy to sift through. They want to be able to cover up their waste easily without scooping through rough particles.
It can make a cat pretty irritated when they have litter stuck to their paws. It can even lead to overgrooming the paw pads in some cases.
If you’re concerned your cat is sensitive to the fragrances used in cat litter, try out a scentless product.
Some cat litters, such as most non-clumping types, can make it difficult for your cat to cover. If they aren’t able to properly bury their messes, it could cause litter box issues.
Of all the litters we checked out, we liked Kitty Poo Club the best. We love how easy and convenient it is, and love the company’s exchange policy in case your cat doesn’t like the litter you chose!
If you want to save a few bucks, check out Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter. It does amazingly well for coverage—and it’s perfect for multi-cat households. We think it’s not only the biggest savings—it’s super effective.
No matter which one of these cat litters caught your eye, we hope it will be a solution to all your litter box issues.
Featured Image Credit: Tanya Plotnikova, Shutterstock
- The 9 Best Cat Litter for Picky Cats
- 1. Kitty Poo Club Cat Litter – Best Overall
- 2. Arm & Hammer Clump & Seal Platinum Cat Litter – Best Value
- 3. World’s Best Cat Litter Picky Cat – Premium Choice
- 4. Fresh Step Advanced Simply Unscented Clumping Cat Litter – Best for Kittens
- 5. Dr. Elsey’s Premium Clumping Cat Litter
- 6. Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter
- 7. Tidy Cats Free & Clean
- 8. BoxiePro Deep Clean
- 9. Petfive Sustainably Yours Natural Sustainable Multi-Cat Litter
- Buyer’s Guide