If you have ever shopped for cat litter, then you know that Arm & Hammer is one of the top manufacturers in the business. They make so many different formulas, that trying to find the right one for your cat can become overwhelming.
It seems like there is a separate formula for every situation and preference, and buying the wrong one could leave you with a smelly mess on your hands. That’s why we decided to take a look at Arm & Hammer’s top litters, so you can find the perfect one for your situation.
In the reviews below, we’ll show you which litters are capable of handling anything your cat can throw at them, as well as which ones will crumble under pressure.
There are only two things you want a kitty litter to do: clump neatly and seal in odors. As you might expect given the name, Clump & Seal is exemplary at both.
It quickly clumps up when it comes in contact with a mess, and the clumps are hard, making them easy to scoop out (and easy for your cat to avoid). This helps each box last a long time, as you’re not wasting litter on messes that spread unnecessarily.
You won’t have to deal with much dust either, which may be related to the clumping abilities.
It can seal in odors for up to a week, giving you plenty of time to clean out the box before your home starts to stink, making it our choice for the best overall Arm & Hammer cat litter. This is a multi-cat formula too, so you can imagine how powerful the odor control would have to be in that case.
The biggest issue we have with this formula is its tendency to stick to paws, which leads to it being tracked all over your house. You can solve this to a certain extent by placing a mat outside the box, but it’s annoying all the same.
Overall, though, Clump & Seal is our favorite Arm & Hammer litter, and we feel it is clearly deserving of its place atop this list.
Pros
Makes hard clumps
Seals in odors for a week
Capable of handling a multi-cat household
Little dust
Box lasts a long time
Cons
Gets tracked all over the place
2. Arm & Hammer Slide Multi-Cat Scented Cat Litter — Best Value
Slide Multi-Cat is designed to come out of the box with minimal effort, so if you get frustrated by stuck-on clumps on the bottom and sides of the pan, this might be the litter for you.
This makes cleaning the box out much easier than it would normally be, so hopefully, it will stop being a chore you dread doing. It can also save you money, as there’s less wasted litter, but this stuff is inexpensive enough that it’s not much of an issue (in fact, we feel this is the best Arm & Hammer cat litter for the money).
It works well in self-cleaning boxes as well. Since it doesn’t stick to surfaces, it’s less likely to cause the rake to get stuck in the middle of a pass.
As you’d likely expect, given its ability to keep messes from sticking to surfaces, it makes nice, tight clumps, even in the middle of the box. You shouldn’t have much issue with clumps breaking apart as you scoop them either.
It’s a good thing this litter is easy to clean, though, because it’s not the best at controlling odors. In fact, it has its own smell that isn’t pleasant, so you’ll want to sprinkle it with deodorizer religiously and clean it every day.
As long as you stay on top of cleaning the box, Slide Multi-Cat is one of the company’s best litters and certainly its best value, which is why it earns a silver medal here for the best Arm & Hammer cat litter for the money.
Pros
Doesn’t stick to bottom or sides of box
Makes tight clumps
Cuts down on wasted litter
Performs well in self-cleaning boxes
Cons
Litter has a pungent smell
Struggles to contain odors
3. Arm & Hammer Cloud Control Cat Litter — Premium Choice
Cloud Control gets its name from the fact that it has Dander Shield Technology, which means this stuff cuts down on dust as much as possible. It does a good job too, so you shouldn’t have a fine layer of soot surrounding the box.
This makes it a good choice for users with respiratory issues. That is especially true given that the scent is allergen-free, so there shouldn’t be anything inside the box to aggravate your lungs.
The litter itself is soft, which your feline friends should appreciate, and that can help reduce incidents of going outside the box. The softness also helps cut down on tracking, making this one of the cleanest overall litters you’ll find anywhere.
Of course, that cleanliness comes at a price, and a box of this stuff isn’t cheap. It also takes quite a while for the clumps to solidify, so you’ll likely encounter a few that aren’t fully formed every time you clean the box.
If you’re looking for a way to control the mess around your cat’s litter box, you can’t go wrong with the Cloud Control formula. Just expect to spend a little extra on it.
Platinum Double Duty is infused with baking soda, which helps it tame noxious odors. It can handle urine and feces odors equally well, so your home shouldn’t stink every time your cat does their business.
The baking soda is moisture-activated, ensuring that the litter won’t have an overwhelming smell just sitting in the box. It still springs into action once it comes in contact with pee, though.
Since it does such a good job of neutralizing odors, it’s great for multi-cat households. It’s also a good choice for users who can’t get around to cleaning the box as often as they’d like.
While it’s great at stopping smells, its clumping abilities leave something to be desired. The clumps tend to disintegrate as you scoop them (although they perform better in automatic boxes for some reason).
It’s also dusty, especially when poured, so keep a broom and dustpan handy.
If odor control is your main concern, we’d recommend buying a box of Platinum Double Duty. However, its limitations as an all-around litter prevent us from ranking it any higher on this list.
Multi-Cat Clumping offers extra-strength odor control at a budget-friendly price, making it a solid choice for anyone trying to keep up with several kittens without going broke in the process.
It’s a low-dust formula, so the area around the box should stay fairly clean. However, the reason it is low dust is that it’s extremely heavy. Your cat may have a bit more of an issue digging through this than similar litter.
All that weight helps it clump, though, and messes should stay relatively contained. The clumps hold together well while you scoop them, but it uses a large amount of clay when it clumps. As a result, you’ll probably go through a box of this faster than some other options.
It has a mild, pleasant scent, and it’s infused with baking soda to help control odors. This isn’t a litter you can leave for a week without smelling anything, but you can certainly go a few days before smells become an issue.
Multi-Cat Clumping isn’t a perfect litter, but given how well it clumps and how inexpensive it is, it represents one of the company’s best values.
If you’re an eco-conscious cat owner, you may have been curious about experimenting with corn litter. Arm & Hammer’s Naturals Corn is the company’s attempt at this type of product.
Many users like it because it’s biodegradable, and you can flush it or toss it in a composter rather than sending it to the landfill in a bag. It’s also extremely lightweight and low-dust, giving it several advantages over traditional litters.
Unfortunately, it doesn’t clump as well, especially when it comes to sealing in urine. Instead of one tight, manageable ball, you’ll get tiny little crumbles. This makes it extremely difficult to completely remove waste, which is unsanitary.
As those bits of leftover waste accumulate, they will start to overwhelm the corn’s ability to neutralize odors. You’ll either need to add a ton of deodorizer or start over with a fresh batch of litter, and this stuff isn’t cheap.
Not all cats will use it, either, especially if they’re accustomed to the traditional stuff. It seems to be an issue with the texture, and if your feline friend doesn’t like it, there’s little you can do to change their mind.
We’re always fans of protecting the environment, and Naturals Corn is one of the best litters on the market for that purpose. It’s simply not as good as its rivals, though, so you may have to pick between protecting the planet or your cat.
Instead of containing odors, the manufacturers simply tried to cover up smells by making the litter itself extremely pungent. This stuff is swimming in perfume, and the smell is so overpowering that you might actually be grateful when your cat climbs in to use it.
That won’t last long, though, because then you’ll just have a combination of waste and perfume lingering in the air.
It doesn’t clump so much as it makes mud, and your cat will track that wet, sticky mess all over your house. As you can imagine, scooping those wet messes is a chore.
The good news is that it doesn’t kick up much dust, so if that’s your only criterion, feel free to give this a whirl. Otherwise, though, we expect you’ll be happier with any of the other options listed.
Pros
Creates little dust
Cons
Overpowering fragrance
Doesn’t contain odors well
Makes wet, sticky messes
Difficult to scoop
Combating tough cat litter smells is an ongoing battle for pet parents but luckily, there are products out there designed to help! Two products that significantly reduce odors are the Hepper Litter Additive and the Hepper Enzyme Spray. Find out which is better suit to your needs with our breakdown of each product below.
Hepper Advanced Bio-Enzyme Pet Stain & Odor Eliminator Spray
At Catster, we’ve admired Hepper for many years and decided to take a controlling ownership interest so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!
Buyer’s Guide – How to Choose the Best Arm & Hammer Cat Litter
We’ve looked at a wide range of Arm & Hammer cat litters, but how do you know which one suits your needs the best? Besides reviewing the pros and cons of each one, here are some things to consider.
Clumping vs. Non-Clumping
All of the litters we’ve chosen are clumping litters, which means that the litter will form clumps when your cat urinates in the litter, making it easier to scoop. However, you may come across a litter that is non-clumping.
Clumping vs. non-clumping is really just a matter of personal preference. Although easier to scoop, clumping litter can also stick to the sides of the litter box, which can make it harder to clean without some serious scrubbing. Clumping litters are also often made of clay, and some cats may be sensitive to it.
Scented vs. Unscented
Again, this is a matter of personal preference. Scented litter can help to keep odors at bay. But keep in mind that come cats can have a sensitivity to strong scents and artificial fragrances like those that are used in cat litter. So, they may refuse to use scented litter or have a reaction to the litter if they try to use it.
Many Arm & Hammer litters just use baking soda as a more natural form of odor control that doesn’t seem to bother cats as much, even if they are unscented. However, you may still come across some versions that are scented.
Multi-Cat Litter
If you have more than one cat, it is a good idea to choose litter designed for multiple cats. Ideally, you’ll have more than one litter box also if you have more than one cat. But litter designed for multiple cats tends to have better odor control. And we know how smelly one litter box can be, so you can imagine the odor of having multiple litter boxes for multiple cats.
Our Arm and Hammer Cat Litter Selection Process
Catster’s dedicated team of writers and editors collaborate with expert veterinarians, considering a wide range of factors when selecting the best cat litter for cats. These parameters include customer reviews, brand reputation, veterinary experience, and in some cases, hands-on testing. Of course, our cats have a say in the process, too! We strive to select and review the highest-quality products available, to help you choose the best possible product and make the most informed decision for your and your cat’s needs.
Why Trust Catster?
Catster has been a trusted online brand since 2001, so we know a thing or two about cat litter. We’re a team of cat-loving writers, editors, and veterinarians dedicated to helping you make the most informed decision for your feline. We deeply believe in providing the best information for cat owners to help their cats live their best life possible. We look at reviews from the most trusted sources available, and this, combined with our veterinary team’s experience and expertise, helps us gather the best options on the market. Our team is invested in the welfare and health of cats around the world, and believe that expert knowledge is one of the best ways to achieve this.
Our second favorite is Slide Multi-Cat, as it is inexpensive and doesn’t stick to the box. You won’t have to spend a ton of time trying to chisel out stuck-on waste with this formula.
Christian started writing for a local newspaper as a teenager, and he's been involved in the publishing industry for most of his adult life. Combining his love of writing with a passion for animals, he is currently the Director of Editorial at Pangolia and the Editor-in-Chief at Catster.
Christian lives in the Philippines with his wife, son, and four rescue cats: Trixie, Chloe, Sparky, and Chopper.
A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2024
