In this article
A Quick Look at Our Favorites in 2025
| Image | Product | Details | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Best Overall
|
|
Hepper Stick Catnip Cat Kicker |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
|
Hepper Whale Plush Toy |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
|
Yeowww! Banana Catnip Toy |
|
CHECK PRICE |
|
MeoHui Retractable Cat Wand Toy |
|
CHECK PRICE | |
|
Catstages Purr Pillow Kitty Calming Cat Toy |
|
CHECK PRICE |
The Best Cat Toys for Older Cats
1. Hepper Stick Catnip Cat Kicker – Best Overall
With simplicity in mind, these handmade catnip stick toys from Hepper are the best overall cat toys for older cats. They can be used both indoors and outdoors and are free of unsafe “fillers” that can be harmful to your feline friend. Made with 100% organic catnip, they’re sure to bring your cat lots of fun with a toy that’s easy to toss around – and it can be a less strenuous way for older cats to entertain themselves. They can simply lay on the floor and scratch, knead, or nibble at the plush kicker. The flexible tube-shaped kicker is double-lined and made of solid construction, which’ll prevent your cat from ripping it after a few hours of use. So, if you’re looking for something that’s long-lasting and affordable, consider this simple yet fun cat kicker toy.
At Catster, we’ve admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest, so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!
- Affordable cat toy
- Contains cat-loving catnip
- Can be enjoyed with little effort
- Cat may get bored quickly
2. Hepper Whale Plush Toy
The Hepper Plush Whale Toy is the perfect budget buy for senior cats who may not be as nimble as they once were. While this toy is large enough to be a kicker when the moment strikes, where it really shines is the comfort it provides. The exterior is a fluffy, soft material ideal for face rubs and the premium cotton interior makes it extremely snuggly when your aging kitty just wants to cuddle. Its light weight so they can easy transport it to where ever they like to lounge.
It only comes in one color though which is a non-issue since it mimics the true coloring of whales!
At Catster, we’ve admired Hepper for many years, and decided to take a controlling ownership interest, so that we could benefit from the outstanding designs of this cool cat company!
- Affordable
- Easy to clean
- Can be placed in any room
- Ideal for cuddling
- Lightweight
- Only comes in one color
3. Yeowww! Banana Catnip Toy
The Yeowww! Banana Catnip Toy is a great choice for senior cats, offering plenty of mental stimulation without needing much physical effort. Filled with high-quality catnip, it gives off a strong scent that can excite even the sleepiest of felines. The large banana shape and bright color make it easy to spot and grab, especially important for cats with reduced mobility or vision. It’s made from tough fabric with safe, non-toxic materials, so it’s built to last and won’t harm your elderly buddy. Many owners say their cats love this toy and that it brings out playful behavior even in less active pets.
- Affordable
- Durable
- Bright and large
- 100% organic catnip
- Only comes in 1 color
4. MeoHui Retractable Cat Wand Toy
This toy is an excellent option for cat owners looking for a fun and interactive toy for older cats that are still quite active and have good mobility. This toy is designed to keep cats engaged and entertained for long periods, stimulating their natural instincts to hunt and pounce. The retractable wand allows for easy storage and portability, making it a great option for on-the-go playtime. Not only is the wand fun for cats, but it also provides a great opportunity for owners to bond with their pets. On top of that, the wand is also comfortable, as it features a soft grip handle to prevent slipping during playtime and a secure attachment point to prevent the toy from detaching from the wand during use. However, it may become worn out quickly with lots of play.
- Perfect for active cats
- Great for low-budget buying
- Can be taken anywhere
- May become worn fast
5. Catstages Purr Pillow Kitty Calming Cat Toy
The Catstages Purr Pillow Kitty is a comforting toy designed to help anxious cats feel relaxed and secure, making it ideal for elderly kitties. It emits a gentle, touch-activated purring sound that lasts for two minutes, mimicking the soothing presence of another cat. This can be especially helpful for older cats dealing with anxiety, loneliness, or changes in their environment. The soft, plush fabric makes it perfect for cuddling during naps, and the purring mechanism can be removed, allowing the toy to be machine-washed. Many owners report that this toy helps their cat feel calmer and more at ease.
- Large and soft
- Machine Washable
- Ideal for cuddling
- Some users report that the purr is too loud
6. Pets First Large Size Cat Ball with Bell Toy for Cats Kittens and Other Animals
Here’s another great toy for an older feline. This toy is designed to provide entertainment and exercise for cats in their senior years. The ball is large enough to prevent choking hazards and has a bell that makes a sound when it moves, making it easier for older cats to locate the toy. The bell will stimulate the cat’s senses and encourage them to engage in physical activity – something essential for maintaining their overall health. The ball is also made of durable materials that can withstand rough play, making it a long-lasting investment for pet owners. And it’s affordable!
- Great low-budget toy option
- Usable in any location
- Safe for long-term play
- The noise can be annoying for owners
7. Potaroma Cat Toys Cat Pillows
These cat pillow toys can be a great option for older cats that may not be as interested in chasing toys or playing as they once were. These soft, plush cat pillows are designed to appeal to a cat’s natural instincts to cuddle and knead. They come in a single tube shape (with frills), and they’re filled with catnip to encourage play and interaction. The comfy pillows can provide a source of comfort for older cats. Many cats enjoy sleeping on soft, cozy surfaces, and these pillows can provide a warm and comfortable place to rest. And because cats love to knead things, they’re perfect for offering a soothing and calming activity for tired or low-energy cats, which can help reduce stress and anxiety.
- Great for cats that are less mobile
- Can be used anywhere
- Affordable toy option
- Cat may get bored quickly
8. Fashion’s Talk Cat Toys Variety Pack
This fun variety pack includes a range of toys designed to appeal to cats’ natural instincts, such as feather wands, crinkle balls, and catnip mice. These toys are made from soft materials that are easy on an older cat’s teeth and gums, while still providing plenty of stimulation and entertainment. And an older cat doesn’t need much strength or mobility to have fun with them – they can simply lay on their backs and have at these toys .With a variety of toys to choose from, older cats can enjoy a range of play experiences without becoming bored or overstimulated.
- It’s an affordable toy option
- Can be utilized in lying positions
- Affordable
- Materials aren’t of high quality
9. Pets First CAT Scratcher Spinning Mouse Toy for Cats
This cat scratcher spinning mouse toy is great for helping them keep their claws sharp and it doesn’t require a lot of physical or strenuous movement. The spinning mouse adds an element of excitement for cats, encouraging them to play and pounce. The toy is also fairly lightweight and easy to move, making it perfect for older cats that may have difficulty with heavier toys. The scratching surface is made from durable materials that can withstand even the most enthusiastic scratching. Overall, it is a great choice for owners looking to keep their older cats active and engaged, but may not be the best choice for cats with mobility issues.
- Affordable
- Doesn’t require complex setup
- Can be placed in any room
- Does require some mobility
10. AGYM Cat Spring Toys (30 Pack)
The AGYM Cat Spring toy pack is a fantastic option for older cats that may have less energy and are in need of relaxed entertainment. The cat spring toys come with a rolling ball and a mouse for minutes (or hours) of fun play. This toy is sure to activate your cat’s natural prey drive and can help stimulate its hunting instincts. You can easily set up this toy in any room for keeping your cat entertained, and if you have more than one cat, even better!
- Doesn’t require much mobility
- Non-noisy cat toy
- Great for multi-cat households
- Cat may get bored quickly
Buyers Guide: Choosing the Best Cat Toys for Older Cats
Why Choosing the Right Toys for Older Cats Is Crucial
As cats grow older, they may become less active, and playing with suitable toys can help keep them active and reduce the risk of obesity, arthritis, and other age-related health issues.
However, not all toys are suitable for these senior cats. It’s best to choose toys that are safe and easy for them to play with given their activity level. So, when it comes to choosing toys for your senior cat, always consider the following factors:
Age
As cats age, they may have different needs and preferences when it comes to toys. Senior cats may have more sensitive teeth, weaker jaws, less energy, and reduced mobility. So, it’s best to choose toys that are safe and easy for them to play with.
Physical Abilities
Older cats may have reduced mobility, so try to get toys that are easy for them to grasp and play with. Toys that require jumping and climbing may not be suitable for senior cats with arthritis or other mobility issues. Consider toys that your cat can play with while laying on their backs (like the catnip kicker toys above) or simply by lifting up their paws. Chewing and kneading toys are also great because they don’t require a lot of energy expenditure and they’re soft enough for the cat to play with safely.
Individual Preferences
Just like humans, cats have unique personalities and preferences. Some cats may prefer interactive toys, while others may enjoy soft toys or catnip toys. It helps to observe your senior cat’s behavior and preferences to find toys that they’ll enjoy. So to say, if your cat tosses it after 30 seconds of play, it may not be their favorite.
Safety & Materials
Safety should always be a top priority when choosing toys for your senior cat. Be sure to avoid toys with small parts that can be swallowed or toys that can easily break apart. And always supervise your older cat during playtime to ensure their safety. You’ll also want to consider the materials that the toys are made of. For example, toys made with harmful plastics (or metal) can be dangerous for your cat.
Toys That Are Suitable for Senior Cats
All toys aren’t created equally, and some toys can be easier for older cats to enjoy than others. So, let’s look at some of the best types of toys suited for older cats to play with.
Interactive Toys
Interactive toys are great for senior cats as they provide mental stimulation and encourage physical activity. Toys such as puzzle feeders, treat dispensers, and wand toys can keep your senior cat engaged and entertained. Puzzle feeders and treat dispensers can also slow down eating and promote healthy digestion.
Soft Toys
These are ideal for older cats who enjoy snuggling and cuddling. Soft toys include toys like stuffed animals, plush toys, and catnip pillows that can provide comfort and warmth for your senior cat. They can also be a good alternative for cats who have lost interest in playing with more active toys.
Catnip Toys
Catnip-based toys can be a great way to stimulate your senior cat’s senses and encourage playtime. It can help reduce stress and anxiety in cats, and many senior cats enjoy the effects of catnip. These toys are typically soft and can come in many shapes and sizes, from plush mice to balls and puzzles.
Laser Pointers
Laser pointers can be a fun and interactive toy for senior cats, but it’s important to use them safely. These may not be suitable for all senior cats, particularly those with mobility issues. Never shine the laser directly into your cat’s eyes but aim it on different areas of the floor or lower areas of walls. It’s also important to end the play session with a tangible toy, such as a treat or a feather wand to help your cat wind down.
Ways to Encourage Playtime with Senior Cats
Older cats don’t always have the energy to be active and encouraging them may take a bit of effort. But here are some of the best ways to do it.
Get the Right Toys
It’s important to choose the right type of toy for your senior cat. Soft toys that are easy to grip and carry around or toys that make noise or have a scent can be particularly appealing to older cats. Avoid toys that require too much physical agility or have small parts that can be easily swallowed.
Set Specific Play Times
Make sure you set aside specific times for playtime throughout the day. This can help your senior cat get into the habit of playing regularly and looking forward to those times. It’s important to be patient and persistent as it may take some time for your cat to adjust to a new routine.
Make It NOT Boring
Thirdly, try to make playtime as interactive as possible. Older cats may be less interested in playing on their own, so it’s important to engage with them during playtime. You can use toys that require your participation, like feather wands or laser pointers. This can help stimulate your senior cat’s natural hunting instincts and keep them engaged. Also, consider adding scratching posts or cat trees near your senior cat’s favorite lounging spots. This can encourage them to climb and play, even if it’s just for a few minutes at a time.
How We Selected Our List Of Cat Toys For Older Cats
Catster has an experienced, expert team of writers, editors, and veterinarians who carefully consider a wide range of parameters when choosing the cat toys. This includes but is not limited to customer reviews, brand reputation, veterinary experience, hands-on testing, and of course, our cats have a say in the process too! We aim to select and review only the best products available, to help you make the best possible choice and most informed decision for your and your cat’s needs.
Why Trust Catster?
A trusted online brand since 2001, Catster has a lot of experience with cat toys. Our team of cat-loving writers, editors, and veterinarians is dedicated to helping you make the best decision for your precious cats. Our aim is to provide the best information available for cat owners to help cats live their best life possible. To do this, we scour reviews from the most trusted sources available and this, combined with our veterinary team’s experience and expertise, helps us gather the best options available to readers. Our team is deeply invested in the health and welfare of cats the world over, and believes that expert knowledge and veterinary guidance will help you make the right choices—for you and your cats!
Final Thoughts
So, in conclusion, playtime is an important part of an older cat’s health and well-being, and as you can see, many toys are better, easier, and safer for older cats to use. We like the Hepper Catnip Stick Toy as our best overall choice, followed by the Hepper Plush Whale Toy as our budget buy choice.
By choosing the right toys, making playtime interactive, and overall creating an environment that encourages playtime, you can help keep your older cat active and engaged well into their golden years. Hopefully, these reviews helped you find the best toys for your senior cat.
Featured Image Credit: Hepper
