Catster logo

Bad Idea: Buying Cheap Resale Items Used by Other Cats


Wonderful treasures are found through Craigslist, Freecycle, garage sales, flea markets, and other resale venues. Additionally, in economically challenging times, these resale communities are choice for finding utilitarian objects at bargain prices. Although it’s enticing, leave behind all secondhand cat-centric items that were used by unfamiliar felines. They can cause your kitties to become ill or stressed, and also develop behavior issues.

Don’t give your cat items that were used by other cats. A cat enters a carrier by Shutterstock

Here are the reasons that pre-owned cat items including scratching posts, cat trees, litter boxes, cat carriers, grooming tools, and toys should not be introduced to your kitties:

Olfactory clues can cause stress

Cats have highly developed senses of smell — it is paramount for their survival. Olfactory clues help cats navigate their environment, and it functions as a means of communication. Scent also identifies a cat’s family and friends, and it helps cats avoid rivals and potentially dangerous situations. Cats also use scent to mark their territories and for signalling sexual availability. Olfactory signals last — scent can be detected long after an object has been marked. Although you probably can’t detect other cats’ smells on gently used bargains, your kitties certainly can. The scent of feline strangers can disrupt and threaten your established household cats. They don’t know whether a rival has invaded their territory.

Scent is detected long after an object has been marked
Scent is detected long after an object has been marked. A cat sniffs by Shutterstock

Cats distribute their scent a number of ways. Pheromones are secreted through glands located on different areas of their bodies. Scent glands on the bottom of the paws release pheromones whenever objects are scratched — marking territories and broadcasting information about the scratcher. Every time cats scratch, they leave little territorial messages for other kitties. They also mark and claim ownership by rubbing their cheeks and heads on objects such as cat furniture and toys. Olfactory clues left by scratching, head bunting, and cheek rubs linger long after they are deposited.

The author’s cat marking her territory by scratching
Here my cat marks her territory by scratching. Photo by Marilyn Krieger

Scent also binds individuals in a clowder together. (A clowder is a group of cats.) Ferals as well as kitties in multicat households form groups. Developing a group scent is important — helps individuals recognize family and friends and identify potential rivals. This group scent is established through allogrooming and rubbing and is also distributed on shared resources. Although disputes sometimes happen, kitties who live together will use communal litter boxes, relax on cat trees, and play with the same toys. Introducing cat-centric objects that have unfamiliar cat scents on them can disrupt the dynamics of the group and stress the individuals.

Kitties who live together develop a group scent
Kitties who live together develop a group scent. Three cats by Shutterstock

Used litter boxes, even if gently used by a stranger, shouldn’t be brought into your home either. Smelling an unfamiliar cat can upset the residents, sometimes to the point of avoiding the litter box.

A cat can smell when a litter box has been used by an unfamiliar cat. A cat sniffs a litter box by Shutterstock

Used items can carry disease

Olfactory considerations aside, used cat items have other built-in unknowns. The previous cat might have been ill. Some pathogens that are shed by sick felines survive in the environment for weeks, months, and years. Panleukopenia, a fatal and highly contagious virus, can exist for years at room temperature on objects. Ringworm, a fungus, is contracted by spores that are shed — it can easily live on grooming tools, cat furniture, and beds for as long as two years. These pathogens are robust, and decontaminating the objects can be difficult. For your cat’s sake, it’s better to overlook the used bargains and invest in new.

Help keep your cats healthy -- buy new items
Help keep your cats healthy — buy new items. A woman shops for cat toys by Shutterstock

No matter how attractive and alluring secondhand cat items are, pass them by and buy new. Don’t take a chance on them, they’re risky. You don’t have to spend a lot of money on cat stuff — you can make your own. You can also build cat trees and put shelves up for climbing and perching. Instead of used litter boxes, buy large, plastic storage containers. They’re inexpensive and double perfectly as litter boxes. Buying new items or making your own will ensure your kitties aren’t stressed by the smells of felines they’ve never met, and it will help minimize exposure to potentially serious pathogens.

Please follow Marilyn on Facebook!

Do you have a cat behavior question for Marilyn? Ask our behaviorist in the comments below and you might be featured in an upcoming column. If you suspect a behavioral problem, always rule out any possible medical issues that may be causing the behavior by first having your cat examined by a veterinarian.

Marilyn, a certified cat behavior consultant, owner of The Cat Coach, LLC, solves cat behavior problems nationally and internationally through on site and Skype consultations. She uses positive reinforcement, including environmental changes, clicker training and other behavior modification techniques.

She is also an award winning author. Her book Naughty No More! focuses on solving cat behavior problems through clicker training and other positive reinforcement methods. Marilyn is big on education — she feels it is important for cat parents to know the reasons behind their cat’s behaviors.

She is a frequent guest on television and radio, answering cat behavior questions and helping people understand their cats.

About the Author

Get Catster in your inbox!

Stay informed! Get tips and exclusive deals.


Follow Us

Shopping Cart