GO!

Feral Cats....Is there a good solution?

This is a special section for cats needing new homes and for inspiring stories of cats that have found their furever home through Catster or through the love and energy of rescuers. This is also the place to discuss shelters, rescue organizations, rescue strategies, issues, solutions, etc. and how we can all help in this critical endeavor. Remember that we are all here for the love of cat! If you are posting about a cat that needs a new home, please put your location in the topic of your thread so those close by can find you! Make sure to check out Catster's cat adoption center!

  
Celina (In- Loving- Memory)

No dog is too- big for me to- smack
 
 
Purred: Sun Aug 14, '05 4:27pm PST 
Feral cats are the cute, potentially hazardous problem that's not going away, according to Paul Studivant, supervisor of St. Johns County Animal Control.

Yet, people see animal control, not the furry creatures, as the problem.

"People think we're out to kill cats," Studivant said.

Judging by the looks Studivant received from residents on Thursday when checking the feral cat traps at Coquina Lakes apartment complex, an overpopulated feral cat colony location on West Pope Road, he's not exaggerating.

"We're fighting a losing battle," he said, pointing out the food bowls residents place in areas to defer the cats from the traps. "You'd think I was beating (the cats) in the head."

In St. Johns County, Studivant estimates there are 12 major feral cat colonies -- approximately seven in the South end and five in the North end -- with 40 plus cats in each colony.

There also are smaller colonies cropping up all over the county, with three or four more in the Northwest alone, he said. Many prosper because residents feed them.

Most feral cat colonies are behind shopping and businesses areas, in alleys, parks and rural areas.

"It's like the woods are alive," Studivant said.

The stray colonies come about because of negligent owners, either renters or homeowners who sell or leave their homes, abandoning the cats, despite the fact that pet abandonment is illegal in every state.

Feral cats are also the result of pet owners who fail to spay and neuter their animals, allowing them to breed uncontrolled.

"These cats are multiplying at a steady rate it's an ongoing problem," he said. "It's a bad thing as far as my job goes."

Bad because, in the words of Dr. Virginia Quelch, vet at St. Johns Veterinary Clinic, "(feral) cats can be the most horrible predators."

At the paws and jaws of feral, or wild, cats all over the county, wildlife such as dune mice, rabbits, mocking birds and what Studivant calls "bush friends" are being killed.

"They'll devastate an entire area of songbirds," Studivant said. "Not to mention the threat of rabies."

On June 29, a rabid stray cat in Ponte Vedra Beach bit a person after the individual attempted to catch and feed the animal.

The woman, most likely a "rescuer" is like several other advocates of feral cats. Some groups trap, spay and neuter the wild cats. Others give inoculations as well before turning the cats loose again.

Yet, "these colonies keep multiplying, so something's not going right," Studivant said.

Still other groups provide a food source for the cats, but nothing else.

Just feeding the wild cats, Quelch said, is controversial because providing food, and thus nourishment, allows female strays to reproduce.

"When a person provides a steady food source, the cat can set up house and have her kittens. Then, you have her seven kittens. Soon, they all get pregnant it becomes exponential," Quelch said.

Two relatively healthy cats could ultimately be the starting point of producing well over 100,000 cats in 10 years if each female cat has an average litter of two females and one male, Studivant said.

"People don't understand the two-month gestation period," Quelch said, referencing how quickly a cat can produce offspring.

And, according to literature on the Feral Cat Coalition Web site, the price tag for maintenance of the kitties isn't cheap. Annually, more than $50 million -- largely from taxes -- is spent statewide by animal control agencies and shelters for cat-related expenses.

Approximately 18 to 20 traps are set weekly over 609 square miles of land by animal control. If the weather is good, Studivant said, there is potential to bring in 40 cats a week.

After Studivant catches a feral cat, he takes it to the local humane society shelter for a 48-hour assessment period. If the animal shows signs of being handled without posing a threat to people within that time, it has the possibility to be adopted out, but the majority of them are not adoptable, he said.

"They're most likely going to be euthanized because they're not habituated to humans at all," said Cindy Bishop, director of the St. Augustine Humane Society.

Roberta Butler, president of Coquina Lakes board, feels torn on the subject of the feral cats. Although she is eager to help Studivant eradicate the problem, her heart goes out to the nomad cats.

"It's horrible," Butler said, tearing up. "Just horrible."

Quelch said sources now suggest that the wild cats be trapped, evaluated for disease (then properly treated), spayed or neutered and then released again. "They can enjoy and live out their lives."

Furthermore, the Feral Cat Coalition Web site points out that studies have proven that trap-neuter-release is the single most successful method of stabilizing and maintaining healthy feral cat colonies with the least possible cost to local governments and residents, while providing the best life for the animals themselves.

But, Studivant says it's not that easy.

"If someone is wanting to get involved, my recommendation is not to do that at all. If someone is providing food that's all they're providing. If someone wants to get (the feral cats) fixed, he or she would have to check up on these animals yearly (for diseases, etc.)," he said. "Yes, it would cut down on my population, but will it help the animal as far as survival goes? No."

Quelch pointed out that, ideally, "tremendous marketing campaigns" could help solve the problem. "When everyone hears about (spaying and neutering) relentlessly."

Though hope seems bleak for the homeless cats, Bishop is optimistic in people: "Education is the answer."

____________________________

Several places have actually allowed hunting cats legal. As digusting and inhumane as this sounds, we are already doing it and have been for many years. Wild boar is another animal our ancestors introduced, which escaped or were set free and took over the land. They destroy land and crops and chase off resident animals. They also breed faster then many herbivores, like deer. Yet, we hunt them every year in hopes that we can make a dent in their population and cut them down enough to allow natural wildlife to make a comeback. And no one seems to care. The idea of killing a wild boar seems good, and hardly every is brought up to be disgusting or inhumane. Yet, pigs are rated the 4th smartest animal in the world. Right under dolphins and apes. Pigs are kept as pets in many homes. Though they are a different type of pig then what the boar is, they are still one in the same when it comes to their brains.
Here's something else to chew on....In St. Johns county, where this article comes from, people are tripping traps and feeding the cats. They are only helping the problem. So one day in the future, St. Johns may have to join the list for hunting cats. What's worse? These cats being caught alive, behaviourly and biologically tested to see if they can be places in a home, and some may be adopted and yes, of course, many put to sleep or being shot? It's better then a life on the streets, with cars, dogs, other cats, bobcats, snakes, rabies, starvation, and a 100 other dangers always on their tail.
Several organizations have been started to capture the cats, spay/neuter them and administer rabies and set them free. I certainly don't disagree with this practice. At least they can't breed, and thus aren't contributing to the population problem, however, this doesn't save them from all the other dangers.
[notify]

MommaCat

121823
 
 
Purred: Fri Aug 26, '05 8:52pm PST 
Was that article from a real newspaper? Its not good journalistic practice to speculate that someone who was bit by a rapid cat was "probably a rescuer".
[notify]

Vieno

Smart, genuine &- gorgeous feral
 
 
Purred: Sat Aug 27, '05 9:27am PST 
Vieno doesn't want to talk about killing cats so this is Her human writing about this serious topic:

I agree with MommaCat. Besides, every single rescuer knows it can be dangerous to handle / be near animals, tame or wilder ones. It's not news if a feral bites someone and pointing up such a thing only proves how anti-feral the tune of that article was.

I live in Finland and we have different kind of rules here. Even though we have ferals the problem is nothing compared to the one in USA.
In Finland cats are protected by law and even a thought of cat hunt is absolutely mad and ridicilous. Cats are not as popular as dogs but hunting them... that's insane. A person who would even suggest such a thing in Finland would be considered as mentally ill.

What we do here in Finland is we capture them, medical examine, spay / neuter, vaccinate, tattooe / microchip. After that they live in a shelter as long as someone adopts them*. They don't have to be co-operative and usually the only reason to kill is a serious attack (I don't mean hissing or giving some paw)*. We don't have rabies so that's not a problem.

I personally don't support any kind of killing. To capture a feral just to euthanize it is not acceptable according to my morals. We may pity them but we can never know how they feel. Life with a good human is no doubt safer. But life without home is still better than no life at all. I've never understood "animal lovers" who want to save an animal from possible future diffuculties by killing it. I don't think the animal would appreciate it either :| It's a different thing to kill someone who's in serious pain than to prevent someone from living it's life (maybe the only life it knows).

I don't know what's the answer with ferals, or even if there is an answer (or should be!). But we can do something:

Spay / neuter all your pets. There are millions of homeless kittens and puppies, there's no need to witness the miracle of birth, that's an selfish act.
Give money to your local SPA (or other) which supports some kind of Trap-Neuter -program.
Speak for the ferals, speak for the life.
Choose always to adopt, not purchase.
Volunteer. There's many kind of things you can do to help.
Links: Feral Cat Network, Alley Cat Allies

Ps. Paul Studivant should be sacked because of that interview. He made everything sound so useless, like there's no point of helping ferals since they breed anyway.
And what comes to other animals, it's not our decision to make who gets to live and who doesn't. As simple, brainless creature as fly exists here for a reason. And the reason is not to please people. We are not the centre of this planet.

* All the shelters may not be able to take care of their homeless animals as well as Helsinki Humane Society but the law protecting them is same everywhere in Finland.
[notify]



Member Since
03/25/2005
Other posts by this user
 
 
Purred: Sat Aug 27, '05 4:42pm PST 
I have heard about cat hunting. I think it is extremely cruel to hunt any animal. Some do it for sporting purposes, some do it for fur, some do it for food, and any other reasons they can come up with to kill an innocent living being. There are many feral cats in the area I reside in, many with tipped ears. These cats are feral that have been spayed/neutered and set free by the shelters. I think this is great, they are still getting a chance to live. No matter what there are going to be dangers for any animal whether they live in a home or out on the streets. Animals can get out of a fence, get loose from a leash, can get into a fight with another animal, the list goes on. You can't protect them all from the dangers in this world. It's people doing this, not the animals. It's not their fault that they are roaming the streets. I brought in a feral cat that had a tipped ear a couple of years back and she was warming up to me. Unfortunately she got outside, my neighbor set a live trap for her and she was caught. They took her to the humane society and she was set free somewhere and I was to never see her again. They tend to set them free in heavily wooded areas to try to avoid the dangers of society but you can't. I know as long as I watch my animals closely nothing will happen to them, but there is always that slight chance that they could get loose and get hit by a car or even be abused by another human. Killing them to protect them is no way to go about things. You can't protect anyone from anything. It's impossible the way the world is today.
[notify]

Cali

Not so big?
 
 
Purred: Sun Aug 28, '05 1:06am PST 
About 11 years ago some not too bright or not too nice people in my neighborhood either let their unaltered pets roam free outside or abandoned them, and the result was some homeless kittens. They found me (Cali's person) and I started feeding them. They had kittens, their kittens had kittens, etc., etc. I never took the time to do a rough inventory but counting kittens who died young I'd say at the very least 50+ cats have been born in my backyard. Of those we've taken in 10. The remaining ones outside would go unfixed due to lack of funds, and even though bad genetics and harsh winters would usually claim their lives before the age of 3 they still managed to have a population surge every spring through fall so we usually had 5-15 cats. Then we were down to 5 cats outside and we got all but one annoying tomcat who refuses to be trapped fixed and we took in 3 of them. The remaining spayed female and unaltered tom have been living it up for 2 years now, no kittens in sight. And they never get into any trouble, we have a fenced in backyard with little tunnels underneath not big enough for anything bigger than a raccoon, and the raccoons never give the cats any trouble. Bunnies know to stay away, and they only catch the occasional live animal, maybe 2 birds and 8 small rodents a year.

So my experience is that TNR is very effective, as long as we can get people to keep fixing their pet cats when they get them, and someone continues to feed and watch over the colonies after the cats are fixed. Hunting cats and traping to euthanize just freaks the cats who are left out, they think their species is going extinct and their reproductive urges naturally step up to the plate and try to fill in the gap. And they don't need a human intentially feeding them to thrive, they'll find enough food to survive on their own, which is usually when they start hunting other wildlife and messing with the balance of the ecosystem.
[notify]

Beatrice- (Miss You!- '94-'12)

The very Beast- of all

moderator
 
 
Purred: Sun Aug 28, '05 2:59pm PST 
We've read about some success in controlling wild animal populations using immuno-contraceptive vaccines. I wonder if there is something similar available for cats or if one could be developed, since I'm sure it would be a lot more cost-effective and less traumatic than capturing them and performing surgery.